This site is in beta — data may be incomplete and features are still being added.
Back to Meetings

Council Meeting

Tuesday, January 20, 2026
Council
No sources available
Updated 2 months ago
Connecting to video

Meeting Overview

Council rescinded and amended Zoning Bylaw No. 1160 to remove Personal Service Establishment and Retail uses from the CD-26 zone before scheduling a Public Hearing. Council debated the location and safety of new accessible equipment for Chancellor Park, ultimately defeating the recommended Option 1 award. A temporary non-enforcement period for Short Term Rentals was approved for the 2026 World Cup (June 1 - July 31). Additionally, Council directed staff to write a strong enforcement letter regarding property maintenance issues at 294, 296 Eltham Road and 242 Helmcken Road, and endorsed a motion requesting the Ministry of Transportation install cable barriers along the Trans-Canada Highway through View Royal.

Key Decisions

  • Council approved the bylaw for its second reading after incorporating the two amendments.
  • Council reduced the minimum size requirement for a potential cafe in the development.
  • Council voted to remove Personal Service and Retail establishments as permitted uses in the new zone.
  • Final motion allowing the second driveway under specific conditions, incorporating the amendment.
  • Amendment to ensure the second driveway is removed upon future redevelopment of the property.
48
Agenda Items
42/43
Motions Passed
2h 52m
Duration
20
Participants

Transcript

1447 segments
Sid Tobias0:00

Good evening and welcome to the council meeting for the town of View Royal for January 20th, 2026.

Sid Tobias0:08

And we'll start with a territorial acknowledgement that we recognize the Lekwungen speaking people known today as the Esquimalt Nation and the Songhees Nation, and that their historic connections continue to this day.

Sid Tobias0:19

This evening we'll hear from the public during public participation and question periods portions of the agenda.

Sid Tobias0:27

To provide comments virtually during the public participation or to ask questions during the question period, scan the QR code or use the link on the live webcast stream on the town's website.

Sid Tobias0:40

Again, we ask you to provide your name and your street name to begin your comments.

Sid Tobias0:46

Your comments will be read out loud at the appropriate time by a member of the webcast team.

Sid Tobias0:50

Public participation comments are limited to five minutes for each speaker and must be related to an item on the agenda.

Sid Tobias0:57

Question period is open to any question and is limited to two minutes for each speaker, and you will be timed.

Sid Tobias1:03

If this meeting will be recorded by participating in the webcast, you are consenting to being recorded, and the recording will be available on the town's website for future access.

Sid Tobias1:30

Now would be appropriate if anybody wanted to pull anything out of the consent agenda to do so, and that will then become item 11.

Sid Tobias1:43

And we'll start with the first one we pull out, uh naming it A, B, or C.

Sid Tobias1:46

Uh, if no action is taken, the consent agenda has actions that uh Eleanor put down.

Sid Tobias1:53

Uh, so it was uh uh the adoption uh or received would occur in accordance in brackets with the actions.

Sid Tobias2:02

Uh Councillor Brown, you had an item you would like to pull out?

Don Brown2:06

Yeah, um yeah, and from the consent agenda, items uh L and N, please.

Sid Tobias2:16

L and N and not M, correct?

Don Brown2:19

That's that's correct.

Don Brown2:20

Uh and sorry, if you um if you allow me, I got a notice of motion on the agenda today as well that I'd like to get uh same same day consideration.

Sid Tobias2:29

But perfect.

Sid Tobias2:30

Thanks, Councillor Brown.

Sid Tobias2:31

Yeah, we we can uh do discuss that when we do your your motion so we can motivate around that then.

Sid Tobias2:37

Thanks for letting us know for that.

Sid Tobias2:39

So uh L will become 11A, uh and N will become 11B.

Gery Lemon2:47

Counselor Lemmon Um from the consent consent agenda O, please.

Gery Lemon2:57

No, not O.

Gery Lemon2:59

P.

Gery Lemon3:00

P.

Sid Tobias3:01

It's a lot of alphabet.

Sid Tobias3:03

Okay, it's a lot of alphabet one go.

Sid Tobias3:05

So uh P it is, and P will become 11Cone under P.

Sid Tobias3:19

Uh Is it So you're looking P, yeah.

Sid Tobias3:32

Is the email dated January 15th?

Sid Tobias3:34

Is that the one you're looking for?

Gery Lemon3:42

Yeah, the email dated January 15th.

Gery Lemon3:45

Yeah.

Sid Tobias3:45

January 15th, that's the one you're looking for.

Sid Tobias3:47

So that's P.

Sid Tobias3:48

Does do you have a different uh number?

Sid Tobias3:51

Uh Counselor?

John Rogers3:58

Paper.

John Rogers3:59

You see the paper and the pageable?

Sid Tobias3:59

Okay, so we're running off the paper.

Sid Tobias3:59

Okay.

Sid Tobias4:01

Oh.

John Rogers4:05

Paper does not have Q.

John Rogers4:08

So P is the letter with respect to 268 Talmud 4.

Sid Tobias4:13

So it is still P.

Sid Tobias4:14

Yep.

Sid Tobias4:15

Yeah.

Sid Tobias4:15

That's the one you're looking for.

Sid Tobias4:16

Okay.

Sid Tobias4:17

So P and uh paper.

Sid Tobias4:21

Okay.

Sid Tobias4:22

Uh so we're clear on that.

Sid Tobias4:24

And she's pulling out item P.

Sid Tobias4:29

I see that as both the same uh online and on the copy that I have.

John Rogers4:35

It is the email dated January 15th, 2026 for two six eight Elmkin Road it's on the it's on the digital it's on online yeah question your worship yes uh so P which is with respect to two six eight Helmican uh is that something that we would be discussing when that matter comes up um um oh no, no, that's no sorry, no, I'm I'm wrong.

John Rogers5:18

No.

John Rogers5:19

I'm wrong.

John Rogers5:20

Sorry.

John Rogers5:21

Thank you.

Sid Tobias5:22

Are there any other ones that we want to pull?

John Rogers5:25

Seeking clarification, your worship.

John Rogers5:27

Um, so you're saying that um those items that we'd heard um from the um and petitioners delegation of the committee of the whole that being from the West Shore budget um package and the library buggage package.

John Rogers5:43

Um, leaving those in, we would be approving the budget packages as presented for consideration in 2026 budget.

John Rogers5:50

Thank you.

Sid Tobias5:57

And your microphone and uh are there going through three times?

Sid Tobias6:01

Does.

Sid Tobias6:01

Anybody want to pull a consent?

Sid Tobias6:03

And the only reason I'm doing that is a significant consent agenda, so I don't want everybody to get the opportunity, but I'm not seeing any motion there.

John Rogers6:10

I moved so your worship, I will pull H.

John Rogers6:12

Is it H.

John Rogers6:12

Oh no sorry.

John Rogers6:19

Urban yes to the urban forest one.

Gery Lemon6:26

So which Urban Forest strategy Holmes the same number.

Sid Tobias6:35

Yeah it's uh H online and H on the paper.

John Rogers6:38

So urban forest.

Sid Tobias6:40

H H will become 11 uh D.

John Rogers6:46

Okay.

John Rogers6:47

Thank you.

Sid Tobias6:47

Uh can with those changes and with the acknowledgement that Councillor Brown had uh wanted same day consideration for his uh notice of motion.

Sid Tobias7:00

Can I get a mover and a seconder for the approval of the agenda, please?

Gery Lemon7:04

So moved.

Gery Lemon7:05

Seconded.

Sid Tobias7:06

Moved by councillor Lemon, seconded by Councillor McKenzie.

Sid Tobias7:09

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias7:11

Any opposing none opposed motion carries?

Sid Tobias7:15

And that brings us down to public participation period.

Sid Tobias7:20

So we'll start in the room.

Sid Tobias7:21

If anybody wants to address council on anything on the agenda, this is your opportunity to do so.

Sid Tobias7:30

Please.

Sid Tobias7:34

Just you press the silver button uh on the microphone so it turns red, and just start with your name and your street name.

Sid Tobias7:44

Kelly Irish and it's uh Stancil Lane.

Sid Tobias7:45

You don't have to give your number address.

R. Irish7:52

Um I'm here to address the there was a proposal to consider vacation rentals for the period that was uh FIFA soccer period for a couple months.

R. Irish8:03

And uh myself and my neighbor who's out of town wanted uh to put forward to you guys to allow short term rentals and issue licenses because we uh we conform to the BC um ways with living in the same dwelling as the suite that's legal uh to uh allow the people like in our in our case, we live right next door to the hospital.

R. Irish8:32

We can see it, and it's a walking distance that's very short.

R. Irish8:35

So we've been able to accommodate nurses, doctors, uh X-ray technicians.

R. Irish8:41

Um prior to being any uh marketplace forum like Airbnb, we were dealing directly with the agencies.

R. Irish8:49

Uh my father passed away like the day of COVID when he had a stroke.

R. Irish8:54

Uh so uh for the last 10 years he didn't have the use of his right side of his body, and he was down bugging you guys to allow him to build an addition on the back of the house that would allow easy access, and it was all handicapped, uh supportive.

R. Irish9:09

So when we lost him, uh my neighbor had already taken his house and renovated it and the existing suite.

R. Irish9:14

I reminded him he had to get down here and pay the hundred dollars because it's a legal suite.

R. Irish9:20

So he kept his suite active, and uh it was him that figured out that the nurses were needing spaces.

R. Irish9:26

So we started off just with them, just through a single agency.

R. Irish9:31

Um, my father, when he passed, we had the empty space.

R. Irish9:34

We, of course, had to go through time to let uh you know the estate finish up, and so we uh right away we helped with the nurses as well.

R. Irish9:44

And uh back then they would bunk up to to the you know, it was a better minute den, so we could have one person in, they'd move over to the master, and then second person would come in because we did it by the room, sort of uh unordinary as today's standard because the nurse agencies they like to keep them all separate now not shared spaces so with the agency that we were dealing with they went towards the Airbnb platform because it was easier for them to decipher spaces and transfer monies and all the stuff so we had to learn that platform to follow them which led us to getting uh tourists involved and people coming from all over the place but it was our target uh was the the hospital and uh I one thing I didn't mention too is people go in for back surgery or they could then then they get complications.

R. Irish10:34

So and my place was all set up with the poles and the adjustable beds and stuff, so they could stay as long as they needed to to recover before they could safely travel home.

R. Irish10:45

So uh to amend that for just the two months to allow us to get a business license because the registry audited us both of us and suggested we needed to come to you for the business license to find out it wasn't available.

R. Irish10:58

So we're trying to make it available.

Sid Tobias11:01

Um, the the hospital is very glad to have us.

R. Irish11:07

And uh I have a nurse in there right now that does uh some uh mental stuff with the uh pediatrics, and uh even though she's there for four and a half months this particular stay directly through an agency.

R. Irish11:20

Uh I I don't know how often these longer than three months options will come around.

R. Irish11:26

And I just like us, even if it's not for the whole of View Royal, just if it was to draw a line within a circumference of the hospital, because we don't have the hotels to support them.

R. Irish11:36

They come they arrive from different parts of Canada without a vehicle.

R. Irish11:40

Uh in our case they can walk to work and back, which is perfect.

R. Irish11:45

They they want closeness.

R. Irish11:47

Sometimes they're stuck in a hotel and it's further away because we don't have the option for them.

R. Irish11:52

It's more money and then they got expenses for transportation.

R. Irish11:57

I'm working with Airbnb they suggested to me because I've been a super host seven consecutive terms in a row to to lose my ability to be a part of it would be uh the worst.

R. Irish12:10

And they had just uh reached out to me to be a support for or a leader for the community that we are creating here, hopefully, to help people get into this or help show them how it's done, fathom them through the things that we've learned to make it uh easy upon them to do what I'm doing, especially in that general area.

R. Irish12:32

But uh hopefully I'll open it up for everybody because uh they sent me some stuff to say that the issuance of the business license would align with the short-term rental accommodations act and be consistent with other capital regional municipalities such as Victoria Colwood and Langford.

R. Irish12:49

I also went and attended the the town meeting that they had in Via uh the squimalt because they paid a consultant to put together uh a space for everybody that's concerned to come in and put their opinion forward whether they wanted or did not want short-term rentals in that area.

R. Irish13:08

And I took pictures and stuff while I was there because uh you took little color dots and put I was gonna ask you to sum up sir because you're out of time.

R. Irish13:17

Anyway it was a 99% of the people in that that showed up for that town meeting was that they paid the consultant to put forward was positive towards the short term rentals.

R. Irish13:30

The traveling nurses and healthcare I went into this this uh FIFA thing.

R. Irish13:35

Hopefully, it's just gonna be uh even if it's a trial and and then to proceed ahead with uh allowing business licenses to be uh put in place for guys like us.

R. Irish13:48

The other uh there's a positive economic impact from these short-term rentals, which is too much to get into, and I will forward this email along with the other ones I sent in from agencies and stuff because it has the the the closest to 2026 is 2023 and 2024.

R. Irish14:05

And you'll find if you take a look at it, the the benefits from short term rentals is huge.

R. Irish14:11

It's like in the 2.5 million for BC, and there's uh 76 million in tax monies that that comes in from short-term rentals alone, and that's just the one platform at Airbnb, and I'll send that along.

R. Irish14:28

It just came to me this morning, so you'll get it later.

R. Irish14:31

And uh hopefully you'll take the time to have a look at it and see that this hopefully will be beneficial for our community as well.

Sid Tobias14:39

Thank you.

Sid Tobias14:40

Thank you very much.

Sid Tobias14:42

Is there anybody else in the room that would like to address council?

Sid Tobias14:48

Yeah, if there's nobody here, Carl, have we got anybody online that would like to address council?

Sid Tobias14:53

Mayor Tobias, we have no messages on the board.

Sid Tobias14:58

Okay, thank you, Carl.

Sid Tobias15:01

Um, then we can move on to bylaws, and I think we have um the zoning bylaw 900 amendment, and that's for to the amend the zoning bylaw with respect to amending comprehensive development 26 on Island Helmcken, uh Helmcken and I Island Highway Comprehensive Development Zone.

Sid Tobias15:25

And so uh was there staff presentation, Lynn, to go with this?

Sid Tobias15:31

There was nothing we had it all uh in the last meeting.

Sid Tobias15:35

So uh the staff recommendation is that we rescind second reading, and then what we're gonna do is amend it and then pull it back to um second reading as well as schedule a public hearing date.

Sid Tobias15:51

Um so can I get a motion that the uh so we're gonna first rescind second reading uh and that the second reading of the zoning bylaw number nine hundred twenty fourteen amendment bylaw number eleven sixty twenty twenty five given on November fourth twenty twenty five be rescinded second uh we can go to vote all those in favor sure I have no idea what's included under I it's got cafe, medical clinic, neighborhood grocery, personal services establishment and retail.

Ron Mattson16:40

And I have no idea what's included under the latter two.

Ron Mattson16:42

Personal services establishment and retail.

Ron Mattson16:45

So if somebody could just clarify that for me.

Leanne Taylor17:20

So personal service establishment means the use of a building in which services are provided that are specifically related to the clothing or body of a person or household pet.

Leanne Taylor17:33

But specifically excludes massage parlors and any and um unless it's for aesthetic care facility, uh tattoo parlors, brothels, escort services, those sorts of uses.

Leanne Taylor17:48

So it's uh for um essentially clothing or um body of a uh sorry uses that services that pertain to clothing or body of a person or household pet.

Speaker_Unknown18:04

Okay.

Ron Mattson18:05

And retail can be anything, except for cannabis.

Sid Tobias18:13

So I can comment on the motion you can comment on it or you can make a motion within that even better than a comment counselor oh okay sure i'd like to just rescind i know we're just rescinding that's right not to rescinding but yeah uh let me just let let lean chime in if if uh council didn't want let's say two of those options is that possible uh not under this particular motion because council is rescinding second reading.

Leanne Taylor18:46

Right.

Leanne Taylor18:46

So after so i'm so what you can rescind second reading could but when you consider um amending second reading, that is when council can consider those other uses right so we'll get to rescind second reading and then we can talk about when yes.

Sid Tobias19:02

Yeah.

Sid Tobias19:03

So we got a mover and a seconder already.

Sid Tobias19:06

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias19:08

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias19:10

Seeing none opposed.

Sid Tobias19:12

And now we can amend uh so that um uh as it reads right now that zoning bylaw uh number 900 2014, amendment bylaw 1160 2025 be amended to reduce the minimum required floor area allocated to a cafe from 150 square meters to 74 square meters.

Ron Mattson19:35

I'm assuming that you're going to say and now uh counselor, or do we want to pass this and then do an and so I'm just looking at what the the report is and so it the 13263 so it's got those three uses again cafe medical clinic neighborhood grocery personal service establishment and repail and the drop to 72 or 74 square meters.

Leanne Taylor20:10

So is that what the new second is yeah the mayor, the new second is to add the minimum.

Leanne Taylor20:25

Sorry.

Leanne Taylor20:26

The new second is to reduce the minimum required floor area for a coffee shop from 150 square meters down to 74 square meters as we discussed last week at the committee of the whole.

Sid Tobias20:41

So could we also amend usage after that statement?

Sid Tobias20:46

So that we if we didn't uh if a counselor wanted to put up the motion that we want to take out personal retail and and something else, then we could do it uh after we do the uh motion to amend the bylaw for square footage.

Leanne Taylor20:59

Um through mayor that through the mayor, yes.

Leanne Taylor21:02

Uh you can do it all at once.

Speaker_Unknown21:05

Okay.

Sid Tobias21:06

Let's uh break this up a little bit so we get through this part of it and that uh if we're happy and then we'll uh counselor mattson will get into the end and what you what you're proposing to council to get rid of that uh zoning by law number 92014 amended by law number 1160 be amended to reduce the minimum square footage uh uh area allocated for cafe use from 150 meters square to 74 meters square.

Sid Tobias21:33

Can I get a mover and a seconder, please?

Gery Lemon21:37

So moved.

Sid Tobias21:38

Moved by Councillor Lemon, seconded by Councillor McKenzie.

Sid Tobias21:42

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias21:45

Uh any opposed?

Sid Tobias21:48

Councilor Mattson's opposed.

Sid Tobias21:51

Now uh if you want to make an amendment, Councilor Mattson, you could um what are the two usages or more that you would like to delete?

Ron Mattson22:03

Uh the personal services establishment and retail.

Sid Tobias22:17

Councilor Brown seconds the motion.

Sid Tobias22:20

Your opportunity to motivate counselor Matson.

Ron Mattson22:23

Sure.

Ron Mattson22:23

I mean even with just Cafe, Medical Clinic, and Neighborhood Grocery, we're already sort of getting away from what we originally uh envisioned.

Ron Mattson22:35

But the personal services and establishment and retail are really going far afield from what the community wanted and asked us for.

Ron Mattson22:44

And so for that, for those reasons, I'd like to eliminate those.

Ron Mattson22:47

And um and if we get and if we get one of some of the other three, we're we're way closer to what uh we'd asked for and not everything I wanted, but it's it's a lot better than you know potentially having retail in there that isn't isn't something that's gonna draw the community in.

Sid Tobias23:08

Thank you.

Sid Tobias23:09

Uh counselor, Council Brown.

Don Brown23:11

Yeah, I agree with Councilor Mattson and make it more specific and and more to what we're actually looking for.

Sid Tobias23:18

Thank you.

Sid Tobias23:18

Uh Leanne.

Leanne Taylor23:20

Uh through the through the mayor, council may recall that um the applicant has agreed to register a section two nineteen covenant on title to secure at least a neighborhood grocery or medical clinic for for 10 years.

Sid Tobias23:38

But uh that wouldn't interfere with us adjusting this uh bylaw, correct?

Leanne Taylor23:44

Um through the mayor, no, it it would not.

Leanne Taylor23:47

It just means that for at least for the first 10 years of this building, there would be there would have to be either a neighborhood grocery or a medical clinic on the ground floor in 10 years.

Leanne Taylor23:58

Um potentially there could be a hairdresser or um a small retail shop on the ground floor after 10 years, but at least for the first 10 years, council would be securing those uses.

Ron Mattson24:10

So just to follow up on specifically that uh so in 10 years if it's a grocery store or a medical clinic and they want to come back they can come back to the council in the future and ask for it rather than just allowing them to put in whatever they like.

Alison MacKenzie24:27

So we can see I just have a question for staff.

Alison MacKenzie24:32

So we have a minimum space for the cafe.

Alison MacKenzie24:36

We don't have a minimum space for the medical clinic but realistically how many of these could be in that space at once?

Alison MacKenzie24:46

Like could there be three uh a cafe medical clinic and retail in in that space?

Leanne Taylor24:54

Um thro through the mayor, the the space is approximately it's just slightly slightly less than 6,000 square feet.

Leanne Taylor25:03

So supposedly there could be three ground floor commercial tenants.

Leanne Taylor25:08

However we've we've heard um through this application that um a um potential medical tenant is interested in the ground floor space and um would would I think prefer to have the entire space for that medical use um um but uh uh uh if a if a medical um practitioner can have a smaller space, then that is also possible.

Leanne Taylor25:40

So it could be a medical clinic, a small retail, and the coffee shop.

Alison MacKenzie25:48

Thank you.

Alison MacKenzie25:49

If I can comment then I think it's important to write this not based on particular interested parties right now.

Alison MacKenzie25:59

You never know what's going to happen.

Alison MacKenzie26:01

And so I would want to keep it open.

Alison MacKenzie26:03

I don't think there's a need to remove any of those.

Alison MacKenzie26:07

It leaves it open that there could be a third space if somebody else with a medical uh center came in.

Alison MacKenzie26:13

So I just don't think it's necessary to remove it and it gives flexibility.

Sid Tobias26:20

Thank you.

Sid Tobias26:20

Uh other comments, Councilor Rod.

John Rogers26:27

Thank you.

John Rogers26:28

So Council Lemon had asked to uh pull um P from the consent agenda, which is related to this whole discussion.

John Rogers26:38

And um so rather than having in the consent agenda, your worship, could we include this discussion from that correspondence committee?

Sid Tobias26:45

Well, I think it's already pulled out.

Sid Tobias26:46

So if you want to address that now, that's completely appropriate.

John Rogers26:49

Great.

John Rogers26:49

So I wonder, Steph, could you speak to um uh the correspondence here from a medical team that's uh seeming to suggest that this isn't gonna work um through the mayor?

Leanne Taylor27:06

I I I'm not quite sure.

Leanne Taylor27:08

It would be helpful if you could have a specific question.

Leanne Taylor27:10

It's just really hard for me just to speak directly to the correspondence in a corner.

John Rogers27:14

The correspondence uh from um uh this doctor is uh suggesting that um uh the parking situation is um you know if the clinic were to provide six care practitioner rooms, four procedure rooms, they would be requiring 24 to 30 stalls.

John Rogers27:32

So there's they're saying that the the um I guess that um to be able to provide adequate medical coverage for those 68,000 or what however residents that don't have a primary care.

John Rogers27:46

Um they're they're saying that the parking calculations aren't going to work to be able to accommodate those individuals that need um drop off and uh easy access, mobility, and so forth.

John Rogers27:57

So if he's got questions and concerns about this site, I wonder how the um how practical and how realistic um the ideas of a potential doctor coming in here.

Leanne Taylor28:13

Through the mayor, I I I can't comment on all, you know, medical tenants and um different medical practitioners depending on the type of services they provide, they have different needs.

Leanne Taylor28:25

Um if the um in terms of parking, the the parking, the current site has 29 parking spaces uh for the commercial uses.

Leanne Taylor28:36

If um if the entire uh ground floor commercial space was a medical clinic, a parking variance wouldn't be required.

Leanne Taylor28:44

They'd have sufficient amount of parking based on the parking requirement in the zoning bylaw.

Leanne Taylor28:48

Um based on um so I'm just looking at the report from last week that was on a committee of the whole, and in the staff report there is a table that does break down the the parking calculation for a cafe and a medical uh clinic.

Leanne Taylor29:05

And uh medical clinic um requires uh 26 parking spaces, and there are 29 parking spaces uh in on on site.

Leanne Taylor29:15

Um obviously, you know, pickup drop off sounds like perhaps some of their um patients might need that service, so maybe that's that's not exactly uh provided um in a convenient manner on the site.

Leanne Taylor29:29

Um but in terms of parking, uh the site has you know sufficient parking for um for the for a medical clinic.

Leanne Taylor29:40

A cafe would require five spaces.

Leanne Taylor29:43

Um so that tips them over.

John Rogers29:51

I I g I guess your worship is maybe in support of um uh what Council McKenzie is saying that um from this letter uh it may be um um a potential medical that uh the um the owners have uh have secured, but it's um it may mean that we may have to keep some options open to um um in in cases no doctor takes any of the space up so even though we we have the those interests it seems like the uh well this is all and I guess this is the other thing this is all going to the public hearing and if the public is saying I don't see this happening I don't see this working you know if I don't have uh you know easy access into you know to a doctor's office I'm not using it so it um you know it I guess we'll just wait to see how it fair is with the public and if they do support um those other um options um that are provided in the proposed bylaw.

Sid Tobias30:49

Well if we're doing it to amend it now to remove those then that is the way it will be presented to the public hearing.

Sid Tobias30:59

Am I correct, Leanne?

Sid Tobias31:01

If we remove the um uses that is what it will go to public hearing for retail and personal establishment.

Leanne Taylor31:11

Uh correct Mary Tabaya so if council um gives an amended second reading and removes the retail and personal service establishment from the zone then those two uses would be deleted removed and uh the bylaw that would be presented for public hearing would be one that does not include those two uses what we want forward with the motion on the floor right now, if you want to do a counter motion, we're not voting yet on it.

Sid Tobias31:41

But if you're uh I'm not so sure that you know bringing that up is appropriate, Councilor Rogers, but it doesn't really apply to the amendment.

Sid Tobias31:52

It applies directly to the the motion.

Sid Tobias31:55

Yeah.

John Rogers31:55

I I guess in a way it does apply to the amendment because it it you know we'd have to debate the probability of of the other other aspects.

John Rogers32:04

Um and yet on the other hand, I understand where uh council match is coming from because if we take more things off, it generates a greater probability, perhaps, that the medical clinic and cafeteria, or sorry, the the the cafe medical clinic and and uh neighborhood groceries are are more likely.

Gery Lemon32:25

So that's interesting council and if we take more things off that would potentially free up parking that might otherwise you know go be um occupied by somebody going to a hairdresser or or a physio or whatever.

Gery Lemon32:52

Um but if if I could just ask, since we pulled that, uh I mean there's nothing read the letter.

Gery Lemon32:59

Um there's there's nothing we can do about that.

Gery Lemon33:04

Uh I'm are you corresponding, is staff corresponding with the potential tenants or is that all being done by the owner of the building through the through the property owner?

Leanne Taylor33:25

Um the uh so we've received correspondence from the the potential um medical tenant.

Leanne Taylor33:35

Um and um you know st we've we've staff have responded to inquiries and and that we've received, but uh okay it's um but again like it's just uh any any member of the public, we you know, if we receive an inquiry regarding um a particular building, we we resp respond to that.

Leanne Taylor33:57

Um and uh it's yeah, I yeah, I'm just not quite sure how you know essentially pertain to I get it.

Gery Lemon34:06

It's fine.

Gery Lemon34:07

It's fine.

Gery Lemon34:08

And and and there's nothing we can do as a town or a council and you can't answer what I want to know, and that is has this person inferred that it was that the the uh parking available is not enough.

Sid Tobias34:32

And if I can, our bylaw right now states that we have sufficient parking in there.

Sid Tobias34:38

So if somebody's questioning that, we'd have to change our bylaw to do that.

Sid Tobias34:43

Right now, uh, Leanne, if I'm reading it correctly, there is enough to support a clinic with our current bylaw, correct?

Leanne Taylor34:52

Yeah, correct.

Leanne Taylor34:53

That is correct.

Gery Lemon34:54

I'm so out of that.

Sid Tobias34:55

Yeah, so somebody else might have a concern about it, but the reality is we'd have to change our bylaws for it not to work or or get a variation.

Sid Tobias35:03

Any other questions or comments on it?

John Rogers35:07

Should we have a motion on the floor?

Sid Tobias35:09

Motion on the floor is to remove the personal establishment or retail from the options that it could for use.

Sid Tobias35:20

That is the motion.

Sid Tobias35:24

No other comments, then we will put it to a vote.

Sid Tobias35:28

We've got a mover, we have a seconder.

Sid Tobias35:30

So all those in favor removing the uses of personal establishment and retail from uh from the space.

Sid Tobias35:39

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias35:41

All those opposed.

Sid Tobias35:43

I count uh councillor Bolich and Councilor McKenzie opposed.

Sid Tobias35:48

The rest are in favor.

Sid Tobias35:50

Motion does pass.

Sid Tobias35:52

Now we get into amending the bylaw so that uh so that the zoning bylaw um be amended, or we we actually just did the amendment uh for it.

Sid Tobias36:07

Uh so we need second reading as amended, uh that the zoning bylaw number 900 2014, amendment bylaw 1160 2025 be given a second reading as amended.

Sid Tobias36:21

Can I have a mover and a second?

Sid Tobias36:24

Moved by counselor brown, seconded by Councilor Mattson, all those in favor?

Sid Tobias36:32

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias36:34

Seeing not opposed, motion carries, and that uh we schedule a public hearing that a public hearing for the zoning bylaw 900 2014, amendment bylaw 1160 2025 be scheduled for February 3rd, 2026.

Sid Tobias36:50

Can I get a mover and a secondary, please?

Sid Tobias36:52

Second, moved by Councillor Brown, seconded by Councillor Rogers.

Sid Tobias36:56

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias36:58

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias36:59

Did I get all that right, Eleanor?

Sid Tobias37:03

Okay.

Sid Tobias37:04

So I passed.

Sid Tobias37:06

Um Mayor's report.

Sid Tobias37:09

I'll be uh brief.

Sid Tobias37:11

Um if anyone didn't uh hear our prime minister speak at David House today, he probably um provided a uh era defining speech, I would say.

Sid Tobias37:25

And regardless of your political background, I would encourage any resident or listener to review it because it speaks some truth.

Sid Tobias37:35

Uh bit of an update on rail.

Sid Tobias37:37

We're meeting now almost weekly with the Squamulton Song.

Sid Tobias37:41

He's nation.

Sid Tobias37:42

Uh, and uh they have started a pre-feasibility study in order to go to the federal government for funding uh in March.

Sid Tobias37:54

That funding would provide a full ridership feasibility study uh uh with a cost estimate to the federal government.

Sid Tobias38:03

So not only for the uh actually what needs to be replaced, what needs to be upgraded.

Sid Tobias38:08

Um, so the plan is then the federal government will receive that by the end of March.

Sid Tobias38:13

If they approve the funding for the follow-on study, that would probably start more detailed engineering, um, moving the rail around the squamalt nation and whatnot.

Sid Tobias38:23

Uh, so just a little update on that.

Sid Tobias38:26

On the RCMP building, that's been a lot in the news lately.

Sid Tobias38:29

Uh, and I just wanted to uh we've already passed this, and I've just signed it tonight, but I wanted to speak to a success criteria I had added in to the charter, which I think I wrote with Scott and the CAO from Callwood, and that was as a result of a meeting that we had over the summertime where Colwood had some concerns that needed to be addressed.

Sid Tobias38:56

Uh, item number 16 was success criteria, and you've all seen this because you've passed it.

Sid Tobias39:01

Uh, you might not remember it though, that the relationship between Callwood, Langford, and View Royal is paramount, and the relationship to should take precedence over and above this project.

Sid Tobias39:12

We um, as three municipalities do, we uh, and with the addition of Langford and Machosen, we have worked together to create, maintain, operate, and really fulfill uh the West Shore Parks and Recreation, uh, other things that we collaborate on, and I appreciate that the news has not been kind um to kind of conflate the issue because there's nothing that the news likes more than a little bit of intermunicipal uh disagreements.

Sid Tobias39:47

Um I met with the the mayor of Colwood on Friday, and he has some more questions.

Sid Tobias39:54

And I think, and from my perspective, the more questions on the largest investment we're going to make as a municipality in our history isn't necessarily a bad thing.

Sid Tobias39:59

I think it strengthens all of us.

Sid Tobias40:07

I know council was unanimously in favor of getting it on the on the go, as was Langford uh aside from one counselor.

Sid Tobias40:15

Um but but I honestly do think there is space to receive questions um given that it's going to be council consent and providing an opportunity uh to answer those questions and make those answers public.

Sid Tobias40:31

Scott had alluded to a second report coming out, and I just wanted to remind council that we had our validation report.

Sid Tobias40:40

That's where we're looking for.

Sid Tobias40:42

And you know, in a big hand small map way, the it is the process saying the people that are proposing to build this building said we can do it for this price, right?

Sid Tobias40:53

That's as simple as a validation report gets.

Sid Tobias41:15

We're going to get the answers to uh any and all of the questions that Callwood have.

Sid Tobias41:20

And if we have any questions remaining about it, I would encourage you to uh get a hold of myself or or our CAO Scott and get answers to those questions because I would just want us to be shooting from the facts and all from the same sheet.

Sid Tobias41:38

Um so if you have any questions at all, I'd encourage you to reach out to our CAO who has been in the project would not be where it is today without Scott's involvement.

Sid Tobias41:48

And because he's working with the RCMP and uh uh particularly on a sensitive building, he's had to get a security clearance which takes time in order to process.

Sid Tobias41:58

So he's really not only been our representative in the room, but he's been uh Callwood and Langford's represent uh representative in the room as well so i want scott, I wanna thank you for taking that on on behalf of three municipalities.

Sid Tobias42:12

Um uh that cooperatively we're paying for his time during that period so uh so he wasn't taking time off work uh so that's all the updates i've got and i just wanted to introduce petitions and delegations that we've got uh advancing child and youth wellbeing across the west shore and souk region thank you guests good evening mayor and council i have to say it's particularly delightful to see you, Councillor brown, this evening after some recent scares.

C. Andrew42:51

So and i wish you all a happy new year and a good start to the year.

C. Andrew42:55

I'm cindy Andrew, and i'm the director of community partnerships for a regional collaborative network that I appreciate.

C. Andrew43:01

Some of you may have heard a bit about, but some of you may not.

C. Andrew43:03

And I hope we have time for questions at the end, and I'm happy to answer as many as you like.

C. Andrew43:08

But it basically is a re as the name would suggest, it's regional, as in West Shore Sooke.

C. Andrew43:14

It was initiated through the Sooke School District and Island Health and many other nonprofit youth and family serving agencies saying we know we need to do this work differently if we're going to keep up with the demands of our very fast growing region.

C. Andrew43:27

So related to the villages network and the priorities that it has was, of course, the role of the municipalities.

C. Andrew43:34

And spurred by a request from Mayor Kobayashi in Callwood, and followed up by uh then acting mayor or counselor Jeff Bateman, saying, How does how do we as counselors get more involved in this?

C. Andrew43:45

We know we have a rule a role to play.

C. Andrew43:48

So that led to what we call the municipal leaders advisory team.

C. Andrew43:52

And it brought together mayors from all of the regions, West Shore and Sooke.

C. Andrew43:56

And I appreciate Mayor Tobias, you're a busy man and you haven't been able to make the two meetings that we've had thus far.

C. Andrew44:02

But I know that Mayor Kobayashi and his CAO have been in touch accordingly with you and colleagues at your end.

C. Andrew44:10

What I'm excited to share is that you had a room full of mayors, a superintendent of the school district, and a medical health officer saying this is a good thing that we get in a room and we work together to figure out how do we better serve the needs of children, youth, and families, knowing that it's one of those scenarios of invest now or pay more later and play catch up, particularly as fast growing as we are.

C. Andrew44:31

A line beside that is a whole bunch of service providers, including the school district and others, saying, We do need to work differently.

C. Andrew44:38

We're trying to do that, but we know we can do better.

C. Andrew44:41

Then what we really need is a regional coordinator, that person that can be a bit of a hub with all of the spokes at a at a high level, at a strategic level, to work, for instance, with um with city planners and with other officials and representatives of organizations like I'm joined with here tonight.

C. Andrew44:59

And I'll I'll quickly pass it over to my colleagues.

C. Andrew45:02

One online, Dr.

C. Andrew45:03

Wen, who's the medical health officer for Island Health, and Dr.

C. Andrew45:06

Shelly Cook, who's the executive director of the Social Planning Council in our community.

C. Andrew45:10

Next slide.

C. Andrew45:11

Sorry, I forgot to say the next slide part.

C. Andrew45:13

Apologies.

C. Andrew45:14

It's hard to, I forget sometimes.

C. Andrew45:17

My husband likes to remind me that people can't read my mind, so my brain brain goes faster than it probably should.

C. Andrew45:23

This bold initiative really isn't that innovative in that it is a model that has been used in other jurisdictions, and in fact, in this province, and but certainly across the country.

C. Andrew45:33

It is about an investment in a person to provide that regional coordination that helps get things done, much like I've heard you allude to, Ms.

C. Andrew45:42

Scott's role with RCMP.

C. Andrew45:45

So, this dedicated coordinator role we know is critical to helping move things along and connecting with all of the key players that we all need on board to make these changes.

C. Andrew45:55

Click or ding or slide forward, please.

C. Andrew46:00

We're not gonna spend time on this, but there is no shortage of data that says while many of our kids are doing well, there are reasons to be concerned, and there's a definite call to action from multiple players, including the school district and medical health officer and many others, to say we need to invest now and we need to invest to address some of what we're seeing that's going on with our young people, including but certainly not limited to their mental health.

C. Andrew46:24

Next slide.

C. Andrew46:30

Prepared organization.

C. Andrew46:31

We have this regional network.

C. Andrew46:32

The network is representative of about 70 organizations who serve children, youth, and families, who know kids, who again are saying to us all, we need to do this work differently, we need to do it together.

C. Andrew46:44

This investment in this coordinator role would be help would be very helpful.

C. Andrew46:48

I'm going to step aside shortly, but I do want to be remiss to not mention that as we're coming to you, as we have to all of the other mayors and counselors across this uh West Shore Sooke region with an ask to share in this regional role.

C. Andrew47:04

And if Doug was here, he'd sorry, Mayor Kobiashi would say, you know, it's peanuts for what we're gonna get out of it.

C. Andrew47:09

Um is also the school district saying, we believe in this, we need it, we'll put 15k a year towards us for three years.

C. Andrew47:16

Um, and we have a backbone organization that is is working with us to help support this work moving forward.

C. Andrew47:22

Next slide, and then I think this is where I'm gonna pass it over.

C. Andrew47:27

She I might, and I I do want to give a set.

C. Andrew47:29

I'm sorry, I forgot to mention, I'm already off script, but um, in your agenda package tonight is a very impressive business case.

C. Andrew47:36

This was prompted by discussions with the chief public health officer for Island Health, her team, as well as Mayor Kobayashi and their CAO to say, bring a business case, help us understand why this role matters.

C. Andrew47:49

So that is before you tonight.

C. Andrew47:51

All of the other mayors and councils that we've spoken to have now put motions on the floor to bring this ask into their budgeting exercise, should you be curious about that.

C. Andrew48:01

With one exception, and I think probably we're not surprised, is that uh Al Wickham's director with um JDF, sorry, WandaFuca Electoral Association, said, We believe in this, this is innovative, you go, but we don't have the couple of bucks to throw in the Katie.

C. Andrew48:14

So without further ado, I'm gonna ask you to forward the slide and pass it over to Melissa Wen, who's joining us tonight remotely.

C. Andrew48:24

Melissa.

M. Wan48:26

Thank you so much, Cindy.

M. Wan48:27

Hi there, my name is Dr.

M. Wan48:28

Melissa, I'm the medical health officer for the West Shore communities.

M. Wan48:32

Um, so as Cindy has already stated, the MLAP presents a valuable opportunity to build on the foundation and amplify strategic collaboration with key partners across the region for local youth and families, and increasing their well-being and their health outcomes.

M. Wan48:51

Um we know that investing in youth through this strategic regional collaboration is a very smart investment.

M. Wan49:00

Research has shown that investments in children and youth yield the highest social returns, and many youth programs pay for themselves down the line through improved economic potential and reduced spending on services.

M. Wan49:14

Beyond cost avoidance, these investments also lay groundwork for long term economic and social benefits.

M. Wan49:21

And when youth are supported to thrive, they are better equipped to contribute meaningfully to their communities and strengthen the region's future workforce, civic engagement, and overall resilience, something that I think is well laid out as an objective as part of View Royal's official community plan.

M. Wan49:40

Next slide, and I'm going to pass it over to Dr.

S. Cook49:42

As Cindy had mentioned, my name is Dr.

M. Wan49:42

Shelley Cook.

M. Wan49:42

Shelley Cook.

S. Cook49:45

Thank you so much.

S. Cook49:49

I am the executive director of Community Social Planning Council.

S. Cook49:52

We are a long-standing organization that has been serving this community for over 90 years.

S. Cook49:58

I'll speak to a little bit more about our work in a moment.

S. Cook50:02

So complex issues like ensuring children and youth are thriving are best addressed on a regional basis that recognizes the dynamic interconnected nature of the world we live in.

S. Cook50:12

And what happens in View Royal doesn't stay in View Royal.

S. Cook50:16

So, this is really the role that Community Social Planning, next slide, please, we'll be providing as the backbone organization to help lead this work and bringing all the important partners that Cindy had addressed together.

S. Cook50:30

So, this involves good administrative support, as I mentioned, pulling in new and existing partners to help secure funding, ensuring there's a strong evaluation framework, including a clear return on investment so that we know for every dollar that we're spending now, we can save seven in the long run.

S. Cook50:49

Certainly, next uh next slide.

S. Cook50:52

So, Community Social Planning Council advocates equity and a better quality of life through community based research and analysis, informing policy, engaging citizens, and through service delivery.

S. Cook51:04

Some of our work has included the point in time count.

S. Cook51:07

We did the housing needs report for Callwood, we deliver the rent bank for this region, we uh provide the low income transit program.

S. Cook51:14

So we are deeply embedded within the community.

S. Cook51:19

And this is the nature of the work that we do on an ongoing basis is both bringing people together, ensuring that those important partners are at the table, and then ensuring that there's funding and evaluation to support the work, the important work that we're doing.

S. Cook51:35

CS Community Social Planning Council, next slide, please, will bring the full weight of the organization to this role.

S. Cook51:42

So it's not just simply about one person who's going to be sort of working uh with the community.

S. Cook51:49

This is really about how, as an organization, we can help leverage our expertise, our ability um to to conduct research, to deliver services, to help our community to really inform the work that's happening in in uh to advance the needs of children youth and families in the region um so i think that really sort of sums up uh really the points i wanted to make and so we're happy to certainly entertain any questions that you have about the initiative and 26 seconds thank you very much yeah thank you you did well and crammed in there yeah there are some questions counselor thank you very much.

Gery Lemon52:32

Necessary, interesting.

Gery Lemon52:36

We're in a different school district.

Gery Lemon52:38

Our our children our our students are all in a different school school district.

Gery Lemon52:43

Will they have the same access and opportunities that those in the Suk school district would?

C. Andrew52:48

Yeah, great, great question.

C. Andrew52:50

And you're right, although there may be some of your young people who make their way over to schools on the West on Calwater Langford.

C. Andrew52:58

But that aside, um this is about building infrastructure and services to support children, youth, and families across our our region.

C. Andrew53:07

It isn't about what school they go to or their street address.

Gery Lemon53:11

Good.

Gery Lemon53:12

Thank you.

Sid Tobias53:14

Other questions?

Sid Tobias53:14

Councillor McKenzie and then Councillor Rogers.

Alison MacKenzie53:17

Thank you for your presentation.

Alison MacKenzie53:19

I have a question for you specifically relating to your request for support for funding towards this uh coordinator position.

Alison MacKenzie53:28

So out of curiosity, other people positions employed at the village initiative, how are they funded?

C. Andrew53:37

We don't really have employees.

C. Andrew53:40

I actually have to give credit to Suk School District, who in hiring me as a contractor on a very part-time basis also recognizes that this investment in working with community partners is pivotal, in fact, critical to supporting young people across our jurisdiction.

C. Andrew53:57

And so, and I do want to give a shout out to both United Way and the Victoria Foundation that have stepped up and provided funding along with Island Health and CRD occasionally, with bits and pieces that we put together.

C. Andrew54:07

And I I stretched dollars from here to, you know, Timbuktu.

C. Andrew54:11

Um, but this has been a very loosely organic network, which I think in itself speaks volumes.

C. Andrew54:20

You have it led by stewards of organizations.

C. Andrew54:23

So Dr.

C. Andrew54:23

Shelley Shelley, who is uh uh chief um operating officer, sorry, executive director of intercultural association, the associate superintendent of the school district, uh senior management from public health, uh executive director of Boys and Girls Club as they were formerly known, etc.

C. Andrew54:40

These are people who have come together on their own time in their own dimes to help support this work of this village.

C. Andrew54:47

And what we're saying, and and you know, I'm I'm privileged to basically be a day a week to support the work of the village.

C. Andrew54:55

Um, but I have to say that it's not enough.

C. Andrew54:58

And when the mayors got together and said, We like this idea, we we can do more, it's like it became clear we need a mechanism, and that mechanism can't be relying on senior leaders who have stewarded the organization to actually then, for instance, connect with city planners across the uh the seven municipalities about priorities and how we can address some common ones from a regional perspective.

C. Andrew55:22

So long answer to a quick question, but hopefully helpful.

Alison MacKenzie55:25

No, thank you.

Alison MacKenzie55:25

That's very helpful.

John Rogers55:28

Yes, uh, thank you very much.

John Rogers55:30

Um it's yes, certainly sounds like a a West Shore approach, and um uh and to be able to reach out to the youth and the families, I can see that the school counselors would be a major player in this because they see what's happening day to day and uh and and certainly a key resource for that coordinator to coordinate with.

John Rogers55:52

My concern is that we don't have many kids in the West Shore in School District 62.

John Rogers56:00

I can't think uh, what, 15?

John Rogers56:03

You know, they're all in in the school elementary schools in V Royal, they all go to Shoreline, they all go to Squamalt, they're all in school district 61.

John Rogers56:13

Where is this service available?

John Rogers56:15

Isn't is there an equivalent service for those our youth, our children and our families that are going to be core orientated?

C. Andrew56:22

Um great question.

C. Andrew56:24

Again, this isn't school system dependent.

C. Andrew56:26

This is about where connecting with kids, where they're at and families.

C. Andrew56:29

And so for whether a young person that lives in View Royal goes to school and in Colwood or down the road here, the access to services that are more proximal to home, the drop in centers, I mean, hence you're a partner, a very valued partner in so many important collaborative efforts, including West Shore Parks and Rec, knowing the value of recreation as a proactive investment in healthy communities.

C. Andrew56:55

Okay.

C. Andrew56:56

Kids have been telling us, and not just kids from Colwood or Langford, but you know, the youth through the through various mechanisms.

C. Andrew57:02

So keep in mind many of the service providers around the village network connect with kids who live in View Royal, right?

C. Andrew57:08

They connect with kids who live in Victoria.

C. Andrew57:10

The challenge is for historically too long, we have a dearth of services and supports that are meeting the needs of young people and their families who live West Shore Sooke, right?

C. Andrew57:21

And um a good example is you know, we have a foundry that is downtown that frankly is over, you know, the the wait list, it's it's far beyond what they're able to keep up with.

C. Andrew57:34

And we have young people from View Royal, from Colwood, from Langford, from Port Renfrew, from Sooke trying to access services there.

C. Andrew57:40

And we were very successful, and probably I'll let you know that we wrote the strongest application that the government and foundry headquarters ever received to host a foundry to serve West Shore Soup kids, which means View Royal kids and Families.

John Rogers57:54

Okay, second question.

John Rogers57:56

So um I had a look at your business case, and the the funding and the breakdown of what you're asking from each municipality was based on 50% population.

John Rogers58:07

Based on population.

John Rogers58:08

But in number nine, section number nine of your funding, it actually talks about 50% population, 50% property assessment.

John Rogers58:17

And those so those are two different calculations.

C. Andrew58:19

They are, and that's a that's a miss um a missed opportunity in terms of our iterations of our draft.

C. Andrew58:25

It's 100% based on population.

C. Andrew58:27

This was informed by other CAOs weighing in to say this is how you got to slice it, Cindy, because this is not the world I know.

C. Andrew58:34

This is why we're here having these conversations and why we sit down with with mayors and and staff.

C. Andrew58:39

Um so population based, and so 11,000 is is the con is the request before um view royal at this point.

John Rogers58:47

And the reason I ask is that we are all our discussions with the RCP building is 50% population, 50% assassinate, property assessment.

John Rogers58:56

So that might be a you know maybe a different point of view, but I would like to see what that number would add up to be.

C. Andrew59:04

Thank you.

C. Andrew59:05

Thank you.

Sid Tobias59:06

Council Rogers, any other questions?

Sid Tobias59:09

Okay.

Sid Tobias59:10

Uh normally we don't um create a motion at the end of a delegation, but I think um there's two ways to approach this.

Sid Tobias59:19

One is others have through budget deliberations, and another one, I think uh is through our grant and aid program that could be multi-year for the amount that you're looking for.

Sid Tobias59:29

So I know our staff has uh information about that.

Sid Tobias59:35

I'm not sure how it will mesh with your timing.

Sid Tobias59:37

I think it's uh it might.

Sid Tobias59:39

So there there is that opportunity as well.

Sid Tobias59:43

But um now what will happen is uh if a counselor wants to raise it later, they can uh and and suggest a motion to go.

Sid Tobias59:54

But the grant and aid application would be evaluated by council independently and it'll be free for you to uh put in an application for as well.

Sid Tobias1:00:04

Does that make sense?

C. Andrew1:00:06

It does, and just to share and discussions with other councils through my experience and attending all of these meetings, um there was a comment made, and I'm I'm forgiving me, I can't remember the counselor's name with the District of Highlands, who said, you know, this isn't a grant and aid kind of request.

C. Andrew1:00:23

This isn't a one-off kind of this is this is about doing work differently, and this really does um require a different lens and a different investment.

C. Andrew1:00:33

And we are looking for three years purposely, like you know, one year, which is often the typical grant and aid kind of request, uh, um, does certainly doesn't cut it.

C. Andrew1:00:41

I think three years is the is the minimum.

C. Andrew1:00:44

And uh so you have agencies standing by committed.

C. Andrew1:00:48

Public health has mobilized people to be part of helping support this work.

C. Andrew1:00:52

Shelley's or uh sorry, community Social Planning council, the school district.

C. Andrew1:00:56

So I guess that's my plug to say it isn't a grant and aid kind of request.

C. Andrew1:01:01

It really deserves a motion towards the budget review exercise in my humble opinion.

Sid Tobias1:01:07

Great.

Sid Tobias1:01:07

No, thank you.

Sid Tobias1:01:08

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:01:09

That's um that's good, well justified.

Sid Tobias1:01:11

Uh if there are no other questions, thank you so much for coming out and uh bringing it uh to be alive and um um love the energy that you guys are putting together for it because I I agree with everything that you had to say and that you end up paying for the services that you don't provide one way or another down the road.

Sid Tobias1:01:32

And not only that, it's just a wonderful opportunity, another outlet for our youth.

Sid Tobias1:01:36

So thank you.

Sid Tobias1:01:44

And I think that brings us down to staff reports.

Sid Tobias1:01:49

This next one for request for decision for 309 View Royal Avenue driveway request.

Ivan Leung1:01:55

Thank you, Mary Tobias.

Ivan Leung1:01:56

Ivan Leoung, Director of Engineering.

Ivan Leung1:01:58

The purpose of this report is to seek a decision from council regarding the 309 View Royal Avenue request for second driveway access.

Ivan Leung1:02:05

So, in short, our subdivision development services bylaw for corner property states that the driveway should be on the minor road.

Ivan Leung1:02:11

So it basically says that you can't have two driveways.

Ivan Leung1:02:15

And so we've been administering it that way until this application came.

Ivan Leung1:02:20

So the gentleman here who's in the in the crowd right now is just doing their due diligence.

Ivan Leung1:02:25

They're thinking about maybe putting in a um a detached garden, uh detached garage, the garden suite above.

Ivan Leung1:02:30

Um be facing Best Boro.

Ivan Leung1:02:34

So they're asking if we could put a second driveway in.

Ivan Leung1:02:36

Um that's the reason why we're coming forward to council because it's not in our subdivision development servicing bylaw.

Ivan Leung1:02:41

Uh the recommendation is is that um, and my my typical policy is to go by the bylaw for a recommendation.

Ivan Leung1:02:49

However, there are some aspects of this project or this property that um that may consider having a second driveway and maybe a benefit to the community.

Ivan Leung1:02:57

So the first one is that uh there's a lot of mature trees along Bestboro, and so by or by uh View Royal Avenue, and by having the the applicant widen their initial driveway or provide a path to their existing driveway, would probably destroy all of those trees.

Ivan Leung1:03:13

So there's an urban forests context to providing two driveways in there.

Ivan Leung1:03:19

And then the second reason why is uh having two driveways is to encourage uh users to drive to park within the property.

Ivan Leung1:03:27

Um Shane here has petitioned to uh many of the neighboring residents who have been in support with a second driveway because it would eliminate or mitigate uh the potential for entreep parking in that area.

Ivan Leung1:03:41

Um having the driveway on Bestboro is is actually rather favorable.

Ivan Leung1:03:44

It's a straight road, no sightline issues, there's not a lot of vegetation that would block or impact safety.

Ivan Leung1:03:50

Um, so while the recommendation is that one driveway be permitted on the property, um, staff is also in support with the alternative option was is that a second driveway access be permitted from the 309 Viewer Avenue property to Best Boro Avenue if the property develops a detached garage with a suite above.

Ivan Leung1:04:09

So the uh initiation of a second driveway would only be conditional to uh development should it occur.

Ivan Leung1:04:16

Uh my understanding is that um it's still in this preliminary um application phase.

Ivan Leung1:04:20

You don't have a building permit application.

Ivan Leung1:04:22

And what uh what the homeowner is asking for right now is just a decision so he can move forward with his application.

Ivan Leung1:04:28

Uh but that said, I'm happy to take questions.

Ivan Leung1:04:30

The the property owner is here too, if um if you wish to ask him questions.

Ivan Leung1:04:35

Uh, but yeah, thank you.

Sid Tobias1:04:37

So just to be clear, Ivan, part of this rationale is for the second driveway, is that they're doing their due diligence to get the information but the intent would be to put in a garage with a suite on top of that garage correct uh yes that was what was brought forward to us um as a as a pretty much a uh an idea and and if they put the um second driveway in the proposed position they wouldn't have a need to widen the current driveway which would affect the tree line uh mayor tress that is correct um there is another option where that existing driveway could be eliminated.

Ivan Leung1:05:19

However, that does um increase the chances of on-sheet parking happening.

Ivan Leung1:05:23

Um, but you're correct in the sense that should a should a second driveway in Bessbro be built, that's that existing driveway will remain uh the same.

Sid Tobias1:05:33

And it is a corner lot, correct?

Sid Tobias1:05:35

On uh Best Boro and View Royal.

Ivan Leung1:05:38

That's correct.

Speaker_Unknown1:05:39

Okay.

Sid Tobias1:05:39

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:05:40

Uh questions?

Sid Tobias1:05:41

Uh start with you, Councilor Matts.

Sid Tobias1:05:43

And then Councilor.

Ron Mattson1:05:44

From your report, I sort of got the feeling that you thought the better option was to put it on Besbro and get rid of the one on View Royal Avenue.

Ron Mattson1:05:55

Did I miss read that?

Ivan Leung1:05:57

Uh Mayor Tobias, that's certainly an option.

Ivan Leung1:05:59

Um the and based in the report, there is a line in there that says a staff's in support of either option.

Ivan Leung1:06:07

So it could be to uh have a driveway on Bestboro and remove the driveway on View Royal, uh, which is in line with the staff recommendation that only one driveway access be permitted.

Ron Mattson1:06:14

Another question I had was just in terms of a precedent setting in terms of other people coming out to demand their second driveway.

Ivan Leung1:06:29

Uh uh Mayor Tobias, it's a great question by Councillor Matson.

Ivan Leung1:06:32

And um uh our answer to that is there are no there's no precedence.

Ivan Leung1:06:35

We take this on a case by case basis.

Ivan Leung1:06:37

Probably 99 out of a hundred times, I would probably say no.

Ivan Leung1:06:40

Uh and simply because there is uh the the urban forest canopy is very, very important to view royal, especially in the hardware precinct, there is a drive to um to have two driveways here to eliminate the need to widen the existing driveway and affect the trees.

Ron Mattson1:06:57

My only other thought is maybe we need to have a a look at this, especially given our rezoning of all the properties in town to allow four houses at a minimum.

Ron Mattson1:07:09

I so I any just uh a thought that something we'll need to look at in the future.

Sid Tobias1:07:17

Thank you, Councillor Matson.

Sid Tobias1:07:18

Councillor Rosen.

John Rogers1:07:19

Yeah, this uh you know very familiar with the the house and um and the property, you know, this is one property that has an enormous amount of on-street parking potential.

John Rogers1:07:29

No trees have to be removed on Besborough.

John Rogers1:07:32

The uh, you know, where there's a lot of cars parking on Besborough already, there would be uh the availability of on-street parking for um access to that secondary suite.

John Rogers1:07:42

So that's um um yeah, I I I'm I'm opposed to two garages or two uh um uh driveways.

John Rogers1:07:49

Um the one of the the other challenges is not only um the message that it's gonna be okay, just come in council and they'll approve it.

John Rogers1:07:57

Um the uh the other message is that when um if this lot would be totally redeveloped into a four-unit, now it's a four-unit with two driveways.

John Rogers1:08:07

Can you take any driveway out if they're going to uh you know make a four-unit um um development here?

John Rogers1:08:14

You could?

John Rogers1:08:14

Would that be a condition of it?

John Rogers1:08:17

Hmm.

John Rogers1:08:18

I would be interested in that actually being in writing.

John Rogers1:08:21

So a future staff and a future council would remember that.

John Rogers1:08:26

Yeah.

John Rogers1:08:27

So it's um, unless there were those kind of conditions that um uh the um the f uh uh future owner would just say yahoo, two driveways works for me, and uh then capitalize on that without anyone else being aware and and uh being in detail on a covenant or on the the property title or something like that.

John Rogers1:08:47

So I I think we'd have to cover the basis pretty well.

John Rogers1:08:50

But um I I appreciate the the the existing driveway, the existing carport is very limited.

Sid Tobias1:08:59

Uh and just a question uh Ivan, the cost for connecting up to Peaceborough Avenue would be covered by uh the folks that are uh uh building it.

Ivan Leung1:09:09

Uh Mayor Tobias, that's correct, it'd be 100% covered by them.

Sid Tobias1:09:13

Council.

Gery Lemon1:09:16

Uroil Avenue is comparatively a a busy street, and backing in and out of there is going to be more problematic than backing in and out of Bessboro.

Gery Lemon1:09:29

I'm I'm perfectly fine with a driveway in Bestboro.

Gery Lemon1:09:33

It's a it's a neighborhood street, it's um it's it just it makes sense to me.

Sid Tobias1:09:40

So any other questions, comments, uh comments now.

Sid Tobias1:09:46

Go ahead, Council McKenzie.

Alison MacKenzie1:09:48

Thank you.

Alison MacKenzie1:09:49

So I think there seems to be more positives than negatives in not following the bylaw in this case.

Alison MacKenzie1:09:58

You know, in terms of positives, we're potentially protecting trees and we're also potentially avoiding parking on the street.

Alison MacKenzie1:10:07

And then for the negatives, really, there was just the uh addition of a new culvert.

Alison MacKenzie1:10:13

I had to Google that term when I was looking at.

Alison MacKenzie1:10:16

Um, I don't really see what the negative of having an additional uh driveway is, and it's more convenient for uh the applicant.

Alison MacKenzie1:10:27

So for that reason, I would actually I guess I could raise a motion to you might have to help me with the wording, but that an additional or two driveway accesses be permitted, with one being on Bestboro Avenue.

Ivan Leung1:10:46

Yeah.

Ivan Leung1:10:47

Yeah, Mary Tobias, it's um uh through Councilor McKenzie.

Ivan Leung1:10:50

The uh option number two may be written that supports your motion.

Alison MacKenzie1:10:56

Let me read that then.

Alison MacKenzie1:11:01

Okay, yes.

Alison MacKenzie1:11:02

Option two then.

Sid Tobias1:11:04

Uh and you're seconding, Councillor Brown.

Sid Tobias1:11:07

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:11:07

Um uh Council McKenzie, do you want to motivate?

Sid Tobias1:11:10

You have done a little bit, but uh you're good, Councilor Brown?

Don Brown1:11:14

No, what my colleagues have said it makes sense, especially Councilor Lemmon, it makes total sense to me.

Don Brown1:11:18

So I think it's the way to go.

Don Brown1:11:19

Yeah.

Sid Tobias1:11:20

Yeah, I I'm I'm I don't have a problem with this if it saves some uh trees and uh and provides potentially the homeowners some opportunity for a suite and a garage, which is always required when you own an golden car.

Sid Tobias1:11:38

So yeah, completely happy with that.

John Rogers1:11:40

I propose an amendment.

Sid Tobias1:11:42

Uh yes, you can.

John Rogers1:11:45

So and and further that um um if and when the um the property is uh totally redeveloped with a new house or houses units, uh, that um uh the second driveway uh be removed, be it View Roll Avenue or Best Borough, but it would go down back to one.

Sid Tobias1:12:06

So I'm just trying to to shorten it up a bit, Councilor Rogers, to make it make sense.

Sid Tobias1:12:11

Are you is your motion to put a covenant on the second driveway?

John Rogers1:12:18

Whatever staff thinks is the most effective so that future staffs and future counselors are going to not forget the uh the commitment um by this council and this uh the staff okay uh do you have a seconder councilor mattson you're seconded and it's over to you councilor rogers to motivate me council yeah it's um I I see the merit on the current situation because the the the property the difficulty in the property um the front door for the main house is is gonna serve as one and then then the they put proposed the back this is an old house it won't be here in 50 years and so um I would hate to see the um you know us and and even what staff may uh future staff may do but uh I think it's um um the the rule of thumb for one driveway is is pretty obvious we want one driveway because we don't want a whole bunch of driveways going in in and out of uh um uh dwellings so it's um I I think it uh allows the flexibility for the current owners and also um ensures that it goes back to a um um you know the standard uh once this difficulty is remedied with a new dwelling councillor rogers Council Matts yeah just uh to ensure that it happens because I know uh on Besbro many years ago uh council of the day allowed a second driveway to go in uh on one of those very small lots on governor's point uh because of the of health conditions of the uh of the wife of the owner so we gave the approval they put it in and within six months the people had moved out and they still have the two driveways so having a um policy in place or a covenant in place, however, staff thinks it's most effective to ensure that it's gone, I think would make me feel a lot better.

Sid Tobias1:14:26

Okay, thank you.

Sid Tobias1:14:27

Uh so we got a mover and a seconder.

Sid Tobias1:14:29

Anyone else want to speak to it?

Sid Tobias1:14:32

Uh sure, Council McKenzie.

Alison MacKenzie1:14:37

So the way that this motion is written, if they do not develop a detached garage with suite above, they would not be permitted to have a second driveway, correct?

Ivan Leung1:14:47

Yeah, that is correct.

Sid Tobias1:14:50

And that it would uh have a also a covenant on it.

Sid Tobias1:15:01

But but it would go down to one and that would be recorded.

Sid Tobias1:15:07

Okay, so that's the motion on the floor.

Sid Tobias1:15:10

We've got a mover and a second or all those in favor of the amendment.

Sid Tobias1:15:14

The motion carries.

Sid Tobias1:15:14

All those opposed.

Sid Tobias1:15:21

So that's for the amendment.

Sid Tobias1:15:24

Now we go back to the original motion.

Sid Tobias1:15:27

And that is to allow a second driveway.

Sid Tobias1:15:30

We've got a mover and a seconder.

Sid Tobias1:15:33

So all those in favor of a second driveway as amended.

Sid Tobias1:15:36

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias1:15:38

Any as amended?

Sid Tobias1:15:39

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias1:15:41

Seeing none opposed, that motion carries.

Sid Tobias1:15:44

Thanks, Ar.

Sid Tobias1:15:45

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:15:54

And you're fine to leave if you want to.

Sid Tobias1:15:56

It may be riveting for you.

Sid Tobias1:15:58

You might feel uncomfortable leaving, but uh yeah, you're okay.

Sid Tobias1:16:13

Yeah.

Sid Tobias1:16:14

Sure.

Sid Tobias1:16:17

Uh so I think that downs to request for decision early transportation project commencements for 2026.

Sid Tobias1:16:26

Ivan, they've bundled you to be all of your stuff in one place now.

Ivan Leung1:16:30

Yeah, I've taken too many steps today, so it's good for me to just stay up here.

Ivan Leung1:16:33

So uh but thank you, Ivan Young, Director of Engineering, still here.

Ivan Leung1:16:36

I also have uh Ben Luberzo, our direct deputy director of engineering here, uh that knows more about the details um about these.

Ivan Leung1:16:43

But generally speaking, um the requests for decision are for two key operational projects.

Ivan Leung1:16:44

Uh one is for uh our um bridge rehabilitation project and one is for a traffic signal renewal project.

Ivan Leung1:16:55

They're both fairly important uh assets that we have.

Ivan Leung1:16:59

And um they were supposed to be done last year, however, there were some unforeseen circumstances that prevented us from doing so.

Ivan Leung1:17:06

Uh for example, the Craigflower Bridge expansion, uh when the initial budget was based on a order of magnitude cost estimate that was the it was an estimate that we're that we brought forward the council to the best of our abilities, but upon doing a class A B estimate, which is almost an exact uh cost estimate, it was uh quite a bit different, subs uh quite a bit larger.

Ivan Leung1:17:25

And so uh in part I showed Sanich, it was decided to postpone that work to 2026.

Ivan Leung1:17:29

Um, for the Highland South Bridge repairs, uh, it was basically shelf ready.

Ivan Leung1:17:36

However, um the we're prevented from doing it because of the environmental fish window.

Ivan Leung1:17:42

So essentially, if it were to do worse within the fish window, it's actually kind of illegal to do that.

Ivan Leung1:17:46

So uh we had to postpone that as well.

Ivan Leung1:17:49

Um, the traffic signal renewal program, uh, it is shelf ready as well.

Ivan Leung1:17:53

Um, it has been uh awarded per se, but they could not start in the work uh until 2026.

Ivan Leung1:18:00

So again, shelf ready, but not done.

Ivan Leung1:18:03

Um staff is recommending a carry forward and to have the work started right away, partly because it is shelf ready.

Ivan Leung1:18:11

So we want to get this done so that when it comes to the new budget season, that we have boots running ready to go with the next slew of projects.

Ivan Leung1:18:24

One being for uh let me see here.

Ivan Leung1:18:30

For the Highland Self Bridge, uh, we're actually recommending to amalgamate the 2026 and the 2027 works together.

Ivan Leung1:18:39

Uh it would actually make economic sense because we only have to mobilize once to actually get cost savings.

Ivan Leung1:18:44

And based on the cost that the redone cost estimates for those two projects, there's actually it's actually cost less for us to do it that way to do it in one go.

Ivan Leung1:18:51

So we're recommending to do that.

Ivan Leung1:18:53

Um for the crackflower Bridge program, our project let me just go to here the works are shelf ready uh um new information that's caused the budget escalation from the original to go from fifty thousand dollars to 120 000 so there is a uh financial impact to doing the works uh but overall when you combine those the the bridge rehabilitation project uh program you've emalgated all of those bridge projects together it's actually less cost than what we initially brought forward to council last year so there is no financial impacts really.

Ivan Leung1:19:32

It's uh we're actually better off.

Ivan Leung1:19:34

Um for the traffic signal renewal program, um, basically just a straight carry forward uh because the the the the contract's already been committed and so there's no change there.

Ivan Leung1:19:45

So the recommendation before you is that council pre approve the following capital renewal projects for the 2026-2030 financial plan.

Ivan Leung1:19:54

Bridge rehabilitation project carry forward remaining 2025 budget and move ahead a portion of the planned 2027 work to 2026, establishing a 2026 budget of $225,000 to complete the Craig Clower Bridge and Highland Bridge self repairs.

Ivan Leung1:20:09

And traffic signal renewal project C 186 carrying forward the remaining 2025 budget to increased the 2026 budget to 138,020 to complete the 2025 traffic signal renewals.

Ivan Leung1:20:22

So the reason why um the traffic signal renewal project is increasing is because every year we're doing a traffic signal project.

Ivan Leung1:20:28

So technically speaking, this year we'd be we would be doing two projects.

Ivan Leung1:20:32

That's it.

Ivan Leung1:20:33

Happy to take questions.

Ivan Leung1:20:34

Thank you, Mayor Tobias.

Sid Tobias1:20:36

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:20:36

I have questions.

Sid Tobias1:20:37

Council Matson.

Ron Mattson1:20:39

Yeah, I've just I don't maybe my timing's up, but the Craig Flower Bridge seems to be a relatively new bridge, and I'm just curious as why it's falling apart and needs repairs.

Ron Mattson1:20:49

So that's one question.

Ron Mattson1:20:50

And the other one, in terms of the the Highland bridge, I mean, I remember years ago, I think Dick Cheek's pictures over there somewhere, the second one in or third one in, uh somehow talked the council of the day into allowing Highlands to incorporate into View Roll.

Ron Mattson1:21:06

And we did it under the strict requirements that it would never cost us any money, and it was just a paperwork exercise.

Ron Mattson1:21:14

I'm just wondering if we can give it back because it's gonna cost us nothing for money in the future.

Ivan Leung1:21:19

Um yeah Mayor Tobias for the the last question uh I I wish that was the case.

Ivan Leung1:21:24

I don't think asset management was a thing back then.

Ivan Leung1:21:27

So uh life cycle costs was certainly something that uh wasn't brought to the table.

Ivan Leung1:21:32

Um so that's certainly our asset that we need to um that we need to maintain and replace.

Ivan Leung1:21:37

But that's it I'll I'll pass it on to Ben with respect to Craig Flower Bridge.

Ben Lubberts1:21:42

Yeah absolutely so Craig Flower Bridge was uh construction was completed about 10 years ago.

Ben Lubberts1:21:46

Uh I've explained this uh scenario to many people.

Ben Lubberts1:21:50

So even though it's a young structure uh we want to give it the best leg forward.

Ben Lubberts1:21:54

And so what happens with these sophisticated structures is they do uh they age and they move in sort of a particular breaking in phase.

Ben Lubberts1:22:06

So call it maybe the juvenile phase of the asset.

Ben Lubberts1:22:10

And that's what we're discovering with the bridge.

Ben Lubberts1:22:12

So after it's constructed, we now have recognize some cracking that's that's showing itself through thermal expansion, not to get into any of those details.

Ben Lubberts1:22:24

So by us getting in there and actually sealing up the deck and also treating the expansion joints ahead of time, we're gonna be saving ourselves a lot of cost, potential cost down the road uh by preventing the the deck from going untreated and the more uh significant structural members from deteriorating too quickly.

Ron Mattson1:22:43

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:22:43

A couple of questions.

Sid Tobias1:22:45

Council Lemon, then Council Rudd.

Gery Lemon1:22:50

Um the Highlands Bridge.

Gery Lemon1:22:52

I've been sitting here and I didn't want to, and it was when Councillor Matson said when we when we um took on the Highlands, and I thought, oh, up there.

Gery Lemon1:23:02

Is it the bridge that's way up and over?

Gery Lemon1:23:06

Is it Mackenzie Creek?

Gery Lemon1:23:07

Is that the bridge we're talking about?

Ben Lubberts1:23:10

So th through the mirror, forgive me, I don't remember what the name of the waterway is, but there are two significant bridges on Highland Road within Thetis Lake Park.

Ben Lubberts1:23:19

Right.

Ben Lubberts1:23:20

So this is the southern of those two bridges, which is the older of the two bridges.

Ben Lubberts1:23:24

Okay.

Gery Lemon1:23:25

Good.

Gery Lemon1:23:25

Thank you.

Gery Lemon1:23:26

Second question on Craig Plower Bridge, which is it, yeah, I was at that opening.

Gery Lemon1:23:32

That doesn't seem long ago at all.

Gery Lemon1:23:40

Are we going to annoy people like people are going to be annoyed next month with the Bay Street Bridge?

Gery Lemon1:23:48

Are we going to be shutting down lanes and and and and holding up traffic and redirecting traffic and be annoying?

Ben Lubberts1:24:00

So through the mayor, uh relative to the Bay Street Bridge, this is very quick work.

Ben Lubberts1:24:05

So we expect it to take uh maybe a month at most, and uh it'll be done outside of peak hour traffic.

Ben Lubberts1:24:12

So um there is one tricky area on the sandwich side where they're gonna have to single lane traffic because of the median in the middle, but otherwise the bridge is actually wide enough that we can pretty much keep traffic moving, and we always try to avoid working or shutting down lanes within the morning and the afternoon peak hours.

Gery Lemon1:24:29

So really only only sandwich will be annoying.

Ben Lubberts1:24:33

I don't know the motorists understand the the boundary there, so we might hear it, they might hear it.

Ben Lubberts1:24:38

But either way, it it'll be uh fairly routine in terms of uh impacts to to traffic.

Sid Tobias1:24:47

Thanks.

Sid Tobias1:24:47

Jerry, Council Rogers, please.

John Rogers1:24:49

Thank you.

John Rogers1:24:50

Um on the traffic signal renewal, um, so we're halfway through this and just finishing it off in 2026.

John Rogers1:24:55

Is that the idea?

Ivan Leung1:24:57

Yeah, uh, Mayor Tobias, I would say 90 percent of the work is done in the sense that it took a while to get the design up.

Ivan Leung1:25:03

Uh this is, you know, once the budget was approved in in May, kind of thing, we had to spend some time designing and then awarding.

Ivan Leung1:25:11

And so uh everything that's been done, including the award, it's just as we did we didn't have time to put boots on the ground.

Ivan Leung1:25:17

So uh should council decide to move forward with the staff recommendation, then it could be is pretty much shelf writing could be done fairly soon.

John Rogers1:25:25

Great, thank you.

John Rogers1:25:26

Just uh um so an explanation are you simply we renewing or putting in new traffic lights or uh actually involve uh changing of the signalization coordination?

Ivan Leung1:25:37

Uh Mayor Tobias is the signal cabinets.

Ivan Leung1:25:39

They're aging out.

Ivan Leung1:25:40

So we uh especially with all that's happening in the call and interchange area, it's very important to make sure we have uh reliable uh signal cabinets.

John Rogers1:25:52

Second.

Sid Tobias1:25:53

Moving a second or any other comments?

Sid Tobias1:25:57

Don't think we need a whole lot of motivation.

Sid Tobias1:25:59

Ivan, you've done a good good job uh explaining.

Sid Tobias1:26:01

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias1:26:03

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias1:26:04

Anything non-opposed, much curious.

Sid Tobias1:26:06

Thanks, Ivan.

Sid Tobias1:26:07

And I think you've got the next one as well, right?

Ivan Leung1:26:09

Thank you, Mayor Tobias.

Ivan Leung1:26:11

Yes.

Ivan Leung1:26:11

Um, so this is the Chancellor Park Playground Equipment Award.

Ivan Leung1:26:14

Um council will recall that uh this um was tabled at the at last week's committee at the whole meeting.

Ivan Leung1:26:21

Um I believe it was at tie three three.

Ivan Leung1:26:23

So now that we have seven council or a mayor and seven six council here, I think that was one reason why it was it was tabled.

Ivan Leung1:26:29

I'll just go over I'll explain things in two phases.

Ivan Leung1:26:35

I'll I'll briefly explain the project again.

Ivan Leung1:26:39

Um and then the second half, I'll explain to uh mayor and council uh the um additional conversations I've had with the playground designer on what we can do to fit the playground equipment within the existing space to the best possible and the financial implications, sort of financial savings, I should say.

Ivan Leung1:27:02

Uh so council will recall uh last week that um staff brought forward three options based on a budget of $300,000, of which $125,000 is grant funded for the playground equipment.

Ivan Leung1:27:14

Staff recommended option one, which is the Smart Play Venti with a Wii go round.

Ivan Leung1:27:21

And so the um the WIGO round is a specialized spinner product that is 100% accessible for folks living in wheelchairs.

Ivan Leung1:27:30

The caretakers can be there with them.

Ivan Leung1:27:47

And that's it right there.

Ivan Leung1:27:48

So uh council will notice in the bottom right corner of the slide that the addition of a spinner and playground equipment will require an expansion of the playground area.

Ivan Leung1:28:00

Uh the expansion has been specifically designed to uh make sure there's still enough room in the park for others to play, that's um, or others to read, uh, with picnic tables nearby and benches.

Ivan Leung1:28:13

And also it is to is to make sure that it's not um impacting uh neighboring residents.

Ivan Leung1:28:19

So you'll notice that there's still the space uh to there's a property to the east of this playground, and there is a space there that's still maintained green space for the purposes of uh not um not shifting the play area closer to that residence.

Ivan Leung1:28:36

Um also because Habitat was the one that installed the swing in the first place.

Ivan Leung1:28:44

Uh they have since confirmed that uh they can save costs by just keeping that swing there.

Ivan Leung1:28:50

Uh next slide, Carl.

Ivan Leung1:28:54

And this is the second option, which is the uh treetops, uh smart play treats treetops.

Ivan Leung1:29:01

Um same idea in that uh it has a a spinner that's not like the Wii go round, it's a cheaper version.

Ivan Leung1:29:09

Um however, a person that lives in a wheelchair uh is unable to just roll into it.

Ivan Leung1:29:14

Uh the swing is also relocated to the south due to the size of that playground structure.

Ivan Leung1:29:19

Uh next slide.

Ivan Leung1:29:22

This final one is called the Smart Play Volo, it's the newest one.

Ivan Leung1:29:26

Um I won't go into too much detail here because it is quite a bit over budget.

Ivan Leung1:29:30

Uh 325,261, and that's even excluding um the need to expand the playground.

Ivan Leung1:29:38

Uh next slide.

Ivan Leung1:29:42

And this was the financial implications of the recommended option, the playground equipment being 267,000 approximately, and then uh $70,000 to do the playground area expansion, which includes an element of contingency.

Ivan Leung1:29:56

So with this uh recommended option, there would have been a requirement to amend the financial plan to cover the additional $37,000 um in the budget.

Ivan Leung1:30:07

Next slide.

Ivan Leung1:30:11

And this the recommendation was the to uh go with option one and that the financial plan uh be amended to have a total project budget of 337,025 NEV GST.

Ivan Leung1:30:24

So council through deliberation, um, from what what I understood, there were concerns about uh the expansion of playground being too much, and that what uh what we wanted to do was to better balance the Playground area, still leave a lot more room for green space uh for folks that um don't need to use the playground to use the the the park space as they please.

Ivan Leung1:30:49

And the metric that was given back to staff was essentially what can we do to install the playground equipment in the existing area uh to the best of my ability, to the best of the ability and so my answer at that time was that we could probably get done there might have to be some expansions a little bit to make sure that there's safe space and so I brought forward that to the playground designer and uh the quick answer is that's exactly how it would be um for option one still would be the better option in the sense of space savings so doing some quick math and some quick uh looking at the design uh there would be an 80% reduction expansion in one side and a 50% in another.

Ivan Leung1:31:33

So it would basically be a uh if I was to say encroachment deeper into the park would only go by about one meter.

Ivan Leung1:31:41

And then to the side will be about three meters, but that was because of the slide that goes there.

Ivan Leung1:31:46

Um so it's quite substantially a lot less space.

Ivan Leung1:31:49

I would say in total, probably 80% less uh area being used for the playground space.

Ivan Leung1:31:56

Um, the Volo came into better play based in that situation because the Volo is a better standalone product for accessibility.

Ivan Leung1:32:04

Um also based on the cost estimate we received, it would still fall within existing budget.

Ivan Leung1:32:11

So by going with the reduction in the playground in the playground equipment, uh the town would be saving about 95 to 100,000.

Ivan Leung1:32:19

So that would put both of those options within our existing budget.

Ivan Leung1:32:22

So that's for consideration, should council wish to consider the alternative option of going forward with uh the the smaller space.

Ivan Leung1:32:29

Um thank you.

Ivan Leung1:32:30

Um but that's it happy to take questions.

Sid Tobias1:32:35

Ivan uh quick question uh the uh point that I brought up is if uh council's looking at any of the pictures there um in back of their uh the park it it goes down in quite a significant bank uh not usable for kind of playing or whatever it becomes a mudslide in the in the winter is it possible to move seeing how we're redoing everything, move it closer to the goose and I'm gonna say this for a couple of reasons.

Sid Tobias1:33:05

One for accessibility.

Sid Tobias1:33:08

It would give people potentially pushing a wheelchair and it's not always hard and dry in the summer.

Sid Tobias1:33:14

Uh it would be closer to the uh the thing you can't see here is there's a paved parking lot and then there's an access to the goose and then you'd follow along the goose to get to the there's still a significant amount of lawn that you have to get into the playground.

Sid Tobias1:33:33

Is it possible to move the whole thing closer to the goose for that reason?

Sid Tobias1:33:37

And the other reason is a lot of families go there as well and somebody wants to kick a ball well that's now out of the picture because you've got some really structured stuff around.

Sid Tobias1:33:48

Um, so for those families that just want to go hang out, kick a ball, play frisbee or whatever, it still gives them opportunity to do that.

Sid Tobias1:33:57

And it's not completely broken up by the basketball/slash hockey thing as well as this.

Ivan Leung1:34:05

Uh yeah, thank you, Mayor Tobias.

Ivan Leung1:34:06

Carl, if you can go to the first slide, please.

Ivan Leung1:34:12

Thank you.

Ivan Leung1:34:13

Uh I'll like to point your attention to the uh snippet to the far right.

Ivan Leung1:34:18

And you may notice that there are some uh yellow lines.

Ivan Leung1:34:22

I'll just point them.

Ivan Leung1:34:29

So those lines are important because uh shifting the paragon closer to the goose is not possible simply because that portion of the land belongs to the the uh this the capital regional district or the BC Transportation Finance Authority.

Ivan Leung1:34:44

And generally speaking, they don't allow any structures whatsoever on their property.

Sid Tobias1:34:44

So, how do we get a way of putting the other structure on their prime?

Ivan Leung1:34:51

Mayor Tobias has a very good question.

Ivan Leung1:34:55

I have a feeling that um as soon as we start doing other things to the park, they're going to request us to remove that.

Sid Tobias1:35:06

Could nudge it a little bit within the yellow lines.

Ivan Leung1:35:10

Uh Mayor Tobias, um, we certainly could, and uh I'd like council to consider that most accessible parks have a surrounding path around it, like a Eugene's asphalt um that goes around to improve accessibility for those living in wheelchairs.

Ivan Leung1:35:25

So that space is set aside for in the event that that may be something that may be brought up as part of a parks and trails master plan, that there is room to install that there.

Sid Tobias1:35:38

Or we could go to CRD and say, hey, do you mind us doing this?

Ivan Leung1:35:45

Mayor Tobias, I wish I had a crystal ball that can say yes, that can get done.

Ivan Leung1:35:49

Um generally speaking, they've been pretty hard on uh physical assets.

Sid Tobias1:35:54

Okay, thank you.

Sid Tobias1:35:55

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:35:55

Yeah, my only concern here, folks, was not about accessibility, it was about getting to the accessible um uh playground.

Sid Tobias1:36:03

That and that's we've got more than 10 percent of the people of View Royal living in probably a kilometer of the hospital right now.

Sid Tobias1:36:12

Right.

Sid Tobias1:36:13

And we probably have the least amount of park space and and i'm all for accessibility playgrounds what i see every day when i'm going by there is there's uh i don't know what you call it a jungle gym but uh uh some rings on it and it's not just kids that are using it it's people that are working out that are doing pull ups on it or stretching out or whatever i to be honest with you i'm really concerned about both the quality of the playground equipment i just see this as an operational nightmare going forward and replacing netting and plastic and all of the other things.

Sid Tobias1:36:47

And what is there now may not be as CSA approved, but it has lasted a long time.

Sid Tobias1:36:56

People are still using it.

Sid Tobias1:36:58

And not just kids are using it as well.

Sid Tobias1:36:59

I can't see so many adults getting anything out of interacting with it.

Sid Tobias1:37:00

But when I look at what's being proposed, it's like just for kids.

Sid Tobias1:37:10

As well as it really eating up real estate where I used to see people just go hang out for a picnic.

Sid Tobias1:37:17

It's now just turned into kind of a kids themed park, which is great.

Sid Tobias1:37:23

But on some very rare real estate for people that live in apartments that want to get sun on their face for a day and go out on a nice summer day, we've just just be conscious of that.

Sid Tobias1:37:34

We've taken on a lot of that away from now.

Sid Tobias1:37:39

And I know there's plans for Little Road that are years down, but Irksken Lane is open now right all of those apartments are are open now as well as the other one that uh uh is on the corner of uh a spire that's on the corner of burnside and helmkin that's uh renting now as well so that's hundreds of more people with less green space to go out and just hang out yeah uh let's start with uh counselor matsen and then counselor McKenzie and then Rutherford so one of the things we talked about last week was it last week?

Ron Mattson1:38:16

Yeah.

Ron Mattson1:38:17

Was the the we go around and the fact that looking at this thing, it's gonna be a it's gonna be disaster in terms of either damage or or just cleaning up.

Ron Mattson1:38:29

And I can just see in the evening the people who will be staying in in the in that little place, sitting around having a beer or doing whatever kids do nowadays.

Ron Mattson1:38:40

Um it's just the wrong structure for something that's open to the goose with so many people around it.

Ron Mattson1:38:47

I just whatever we do, I think with the week the we go round just has to go.

Sid Tobias1:38:54

Thank you, Counselor Watson.

Sid Tobias1:38:56

Council Mackenzie.

Alison MacKenzie1:38:58

So kind of to the to the contrary, I in the interim between the committee of the whole and and now I did go and and watch the videos, the manufacturer's videos on each of the equipment.

Alison MacKenzie1:39:10

And the we go round really seems to be the one only one to cater to individuals in wheelchairs who can go there and use it independently from a carer.

Alison MacKenzie1:39:22

Um I think we received this grant in order to make an accessible park.

Alison MacKenzie1:39:28

And this location is the perfect place for it given the proximity to the hospital.

Alison MacKenzie1:39:35

And so I think we should go all out on this.

Alison MacKenzie1:39:39

We should make it a destination, um, really be a leader in the making accessible park.

Alison MacKenzie1:39:46

I think if we do that, it will be popular and maybe deter some of the concerns that uh Councillor Mattson had.

Alison MacKenzie1:39:55

Um I think if it's well used, that people won't loiter around and and use it for other purposes.

Sid Tobias1:40:04

Thanks, Councilman Kenzie.

Sid Tobias1:40:05

Councillor Roderick.

John Rogers1:40:06

Yes, thank you.

John Rogers1:40:07

You know, looking at the big picture of the map from the air, it it does seem like there is a other green space available for those that want to sit and read the book or something like that.

John Rogers1:40:19

The uh given that the um the regal round is for handicapped individuals, uh wheelchairs and so forth, is it going to be a hard surface uh pathway to that structure uh so that they don't get stuck in the muddy grass?

Ivan Leung1:40:36

Uh Mayor Tobias, that's correct.

Ivan Leung1:40:38

It'll be hardscaped.

Ivan Leung1:40:39

Um and then there will be um select rubber surfacing as well.

Speaker_Unknown1:40:43

Okay.

Ivan Leung1:40:43

Um I noticed there's a few benches right now will there be more benches for parents to be able to sit around and and watch their children on the uh playground structure uh mayor to bias is not part of this plan however we recognize that there will likely be a need for more so um whether it's through the recommendations of the parks and trails master plan or through ops that's something that we can certainly look into and provide in the future.

John Rogers1:41:09

And thank you yes I concur with counselor uh McKenzie any other comments?

Gery Lemon1:41:16

Councilor Lemon I concur with Councillor McKenzie.

Gery Lemon1:41:20

I I think if we're um if we're developing an accessible park, we need to make it accessible and available and a place that children will want to go.

Gery Lemon1:41:32

And I look at that thing and I don't see people hanging out at night.

Gery Lemon1:41:37

I see children from uh Denise Place or whose parents are in Denise Place, but children who are getting treatment, um, children who live in the neighborhood making their way there and having something that is theirs.

Gery Lemon1:41:53

And just across the overpass, like just feet away, there's the McClennon McClennon Trail.

Gery Lemon1:42:01

Is that what it's called, John?

John Rogers1:42:03

Jenny's place.

Gery Lemon1:42:04

No, no, right across the there's a trail into P Royal Park, which is which is, you know, it's acres and acres to lay out a blanket and have a picnic.

Sid Tobias1:42:14

You got your microphone on Councilman.

Sid Tobias1:42:18

Any other comments?

Sid Tobias1:42:19

Don.

Sid Tobias1:42:21

Oh, sorry.

Speaker_Unknown1:42:22

Don.

Don Brown1:42:23

Yeah, it's interesting what uh Councillor McKenzie says, uh making it a uh uh place to go to.

Don Brown1:42:29

Um and I'm thinking about the Sarah Beckett Park in in Langford by the soccer stadium there.

Don Brown1:42:35

Um you know, Sarah Beckett of course got killed.

Don Brown1:42:38

Uh RCP constable got killed in the car crash, so I'm not a drunk ran into her.

Don Brown1:42:42

But anyway, uh I have grandchildren and I don't even know how they knew about it, but they said, let's go to Sarah Beckett Park.

Don Brown1:42:48

So little kids, and they're they're six and five, I think, at the time I took them there, and and they always want to go to Sarah Beckett Park because it is they they recognize it.

Don Brown1:42:58

And that's not that close from from Atkins Road to Sarabeka Park.

Don Brown1:43:02

But uh I like that comment about making it a destination park for young kids.

Alison MacKenzie1:43:13

Uh just sorry.

Alison MacKenzie1:43:15

Um I also think that there's only like one other place in this that has that we go round.

Alison MacKenzie1:43:20

Like it's not a common piece of equipment.

Alison MacKenzie1:43:22

But that wasn't sorry, that wasn't my main point.

Alison MacKenzie1:43:24

Um I do agree though, like it would with mayor to bias if we could move it.

Ivan Leung1:43:30

And I know you said that that would probably not be favorable, but I wonder given the accessibility side of it, like could we not I think it's worth the ask still, like to the CRD to see if we could move it up no uh merit of bias I I wouldn't recommend that um I kind of know the answer already but I don't want to make any assumptions I just know that through previous discussion especially with the uh the Waucas Park um the new Waukes Park they basically just drew a line in the sand and said thou shalt not put anything I think it actually says no playground equipment in in that agreement so it'd be very difficult to come across that same win simply because it might be precedent setting in their minds.

Ivan Leung1:44:19

Um, however, should it be council's wish, uh, we can certainly make that ask and then come back to council.

Sid Tobias1:44:26

And just a question before we go to councillor Quelowich about this.

Sid Tobias1:44:29

Now part of this plan will be some access point, like a path that would be wheelchair accessible to the goose, because the goose is connected by uh asphalt pass to the parking lot.

Sid Tobias1:44:43

But is that included in the plan?

Ivan Leung1:44:45

Uh Mayor Tobias, yes, that's included in the plan.

Ivan Leung1:44:47

We've already talked to the BC Um Transportation Finance Authority about it, and they are on board with that.

Sid Tobias1:44:53

Well, because that gets pretty soupy, that would be unaccessible without a path or half year.

Sid Tobias1:44:58

Counselor Quowicz.

Damian Kowalewich1:45:00

Yeah, that's actually what I was going to talk about.

Damian Kowalewich1:45:02

I uh I have some some issues with the location itself of this, if it's going to be uh a destination park for people uh that have wheelchairs and perhaps are slower uh moving for various reasons.

Damian Kowalewich1:45:18

And I really don't think this is probably the ideal location to be quite honest with you.

Damian Kowalewich1:45:22

The Galloping Goose has a history of high-speed collisions with cyclists, uh uh e-scooters that are not regulated through the Motor Vehicle Act.

Damian Kowalewich1:45:32

Uh I would I would recommend that if we're going to build a destination park, that it be somewhere that has a parking lot that doesn't cross a busy thoroughfare of uh people that are moving at high rates of speed.

Gery Lemon1:45:48

Well, I'm gonna move staff recommendation.

Alison MacKenzie1:45:52

Second.

Sid Tobias1:45:58

You're allowed to motivate Councilor Lemon and uh followed by Council McKenzie.

Gery Lemon1:46:03

I I think I have indeed last week um I'd be very proud to have this as a destination park.

Alison MacKenzie1:46:10

Council McKenzie your opportunity to you don't have to I think I've said all so far thank you.

John Rogers1:46:16

Councilor Rogers very good point.

John Rogers1:46:24

You know the um considering the speed of um um cyclists and other vehicle, yeah, whatever, bikes and so on.

John Rogers1:46:35

Is is that would that be a potential risk that we're exposing um handicapped children uh to uh that would be uh wanting to access the park?

John Rogers1:46:44

Is there any way that we can uh ensure their safety as they go excitedly to this playground?

Ivan Leung1:46:52

Um Mayor Tobias, we can probably work with the capital regional district about additional signage, uh potentially additional pavement markings on the goose to provide better uh information to those um traveling on the Gallup and Goose that there is an accessible park nearby.

Ivan Leung1:47:11

Uh certainly something that we can we can look at.

Sid Tobias1:47:17

Councilor Matsu.

Ron Mattson1:47:19

Yeah, I you know, I hadn't thought of that, Damien, but you know, um, I walk along the goose every day with my dog, and I constantly get people on bikes zooming past, which my dog has a tendency to want to go jump at them.

Ron Mattson1:47:34

But there's they're inconsiderate enough not to, you know, on the left, a bell, nothing.

Ron Mattson1:47:39

And a 10 speed, you don't hear them at all.

Ron Mattson1:47:43

Uh an e-bike, you can hear them, but they go so quickly, uh, they're they're silent.

Ron Mattson1:47:49

And I just think it if we're bringing a lot of children into that area or people on wheelchairs right along the goose, it's you know, I don't like what we're doing here for other reasons.

Ron Mattson1:48:00

I think, but but I think that's a significant enough reason to we should consider, you know, if we're gonna do a park and it's gonna uh for that purpose, it should be in a place that's better suited.

Sid Tobias1:48:13

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:48:14

Uh Councillor McKenzie.

Sid Tobias1:48:16

Is this a question already?

Sid Tobias1:48:20

Uh okay.

Sid Tobias1:48:21

No, I think we're good.

Sid Tobias1:48:23

Um so anybody else, first timers happen to get a chance to speak.

Sid Tobias1:48:27

Uh Councilor Quatsch.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:30

Technically, I think it could be still my first time because we're now we're supporting the motion.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:35

So, anyways, I'll continue to carry on.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:37

The um I feel pretty strongly about this.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:40

I think uh I think my colleague should really think on this one before you put your hand up here in the next few moments.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:46

And signage is is one thing I can tell you.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:50

I travel on the goose every day.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:52

I have a public safety background.

Damian Kowalewich1:48:54

Uh I think we already are at a level of negligence with the basketball court and the hockey asphalt there, to be quite honest with you.

Damian Kowalewich1:49:02

I spend a lot of time at this park with my kids over the years.

Damian Kowalewich1:49:08

Balls regularly bounce from the basketball court onto the goose, almost causing collisions.

Damian Kowalewich1:49:14

We don't have fences there.

Damian Kowalewich1:49:16

Adding people that are mobile in wheelchairs and that are moving at different rates of speed with that is a lot of risk.

Damian Kowalewich1:49:24

And I certainly don't want to slow down this project.

Damian Kowalewich1:49:27

I just think if we're going to do it right, and I think Councillor McKenzie certainly I know how much you want to champion this, and I'm with you on that.

Damian Kowalewich1:49:34

But if you really want to do this right, then we should consider alternate locations.

Sid Tobias1:49:45

Council McKenzie, I'll allow you to rebound because it now just gets interesting.

Alison MacKenzie1:49:50

No, it's just in relation to the the ENN and I I do understand that there's concerns uh with crossing it.

Alison MacKenzie1:49:57

I would argue though that that for a somebody using a wheelchair to get to the park using the EN is probably far much far more safe than them trying to get there via road um and sidewalks and and things like that.

Alison MacKenzie1:50:18

They can commute from quite a long distance on along the ENN and uh without the risk of cars and the impacts of a collision with a you know cyclists or things like that is much has a lower risk than uh a vehicle.

Alison MacKenzie1:50:36

So I think it's actually safer to to have it in this location.

Sid Tobias1:50:42

Okay, I'm gonna call debate now.

John Rogers1:50:46

Uh I wish to make an amendment.

Sid Tobias1:50:50

Make an amendment?

John Rogers1:50:51

Uh certainly yeah.

John Rogers1:50:58

Sorry again.

John Rogers1:50:59

And further that uh staff work with the CRD to um place the necessary signage, warning signage, safety signage to ensure that um all children um are gonna have they can make it concise.

Sid Tobias1:51:13

Will have safe egress uh to and from the park across the goose i think you can just stop it at signage because we can't that's right yeah safety signage yeah give them a crossing guard uh safety signage has an amendment to it do you have a seconder that motion was defeated so on the main motion unless nobody has anybody has an amendment uh and that is did the who's the mover again was uh councilor uh did you put the option that you were moving uh yeah option option one okay so all those in favor of option one uh from ivan's report all those in favor uh one two three so uh all those opposed uh so we've got councilor brown council qualich um myself and counselor mattson opposed the motion does not pass uh ivan i'm not sure where that leaves us and that probably isn't a good enough um direction to you it's yeah I mean basically the the project is we wouldn't be moving forward however um just for councillor's information we did receive a grant of 125 thousand dollars specifically for uh accessible playground equipment here so we would also be losing that okay how long would that be good for the grant uh i believe for another two years specific to the playground okay so specific to the park so we could come up with another plan and another location and utilize that grant if it was approved or did they have to approve that it like drawings and stuff like that or are they no drawings but the location's fixed so it'll have to be at Chancellor Park.

Sid Tobias1:53:17

Thank you, Ivan.

Sid Tobias1:53:18

Much appreciated uh and I think uh I think you're done for the evening now, Ivan.

Sid Tobias1:53:24

Is that enough okay uh and is this over to you, Leanne, for consideration of vacation rentals.

Leanne Taylor1:53:45

Good evening, Mayor Tobias, members of council.

Leanne Taylor1:53:48

This evening I am going to be presenting a verbal report on consideration of vacation rentals.

Leanne Taylor1:53:54

So the purpose of this report is to provide council with information, analysis, and recommendation on permitting vacation rentals during the period of June 1st to July 31st, 2026, in support of the 2026 World Cup Soccer.

Leanne Taylor1:54:12

At the council meeting on December 2nd, 2025, so just last month, Council passed the motion that reads as follows that the proposed motion regarding a moratorium on enforcement of the zoning by law pertaining to short-term rentals during the period of June 1st, 2026 to July 31st, 2026, be referred to staff for consideration and impact to the town.

Leanne Taylor1:54:39

And that the following motion be tabled to the January 25th, 2026 council meeting, which is tonight.

Leanne Taylor1:54:46

And that there be an amnesty of enforcement of the zoning bylaw pertaining to short term rentals during the period of June 1st, 2026 to July 31st, 2026 during the 2026 World Cup World Cup of Soccer, and that was in response that's the motion that was in that the notice of motion.

Leanne Taylor1:55:08

So I'm just going to give council a bit of background information before I dive into some considerations.

Leanne Taylor1:55:14

So on November 15th, 2022, Council adopted a bylaw to amend the zoning bylaw to prohibit vacation rentals or short term rentals as a principal or accessory use in a dwelling unit, building or land, except specifically listed as permitted uses in a zone.

Leanne Taylor1:55:35

But these would only include bed and breakfast, hotel, motel, campground, or hospital hotel.

Leanne Taylor1:55:42

Over the years, staff has understood, so even before my time, that the intent to prohibit vacation rentals in the town of View Royal are to prevent the displacement of residential units by commercial non-residential rental uses and prevent neighborhood disturbances like parking and noise from non-residential uses in residential zones.

Leanne Taylor1:56:06

Following the council meeting on December 2nd, staff explored permissible options to allow vacation rentals for a restricted period in accordance with council's motion.

Leanne Taylor1:56:17

The two options available to the town are adopting a zoning bylaw to permit a time-limited use or undertaking a temporary use permit process.

Leanne Taylor1:56:28

The opportunities and challenges of each option were reviewed and summarized in the staff report that is in front of you this evening.

Leanne Taylor1:56:36

So I'm going to speak about the time limited use first because the temporary use option that is described in the report, I am not going to get into it because it is not an option that I believe we should entertain.

Leanne Taylor1:57:01

So I'm going to focus my presentation on the time limited use, which is a zoning bylaw amendment as a permissible option to allow this to happen here.

Leanne Taylor1:57:10

So the benefit of this option is that it would permit what is not currently permitted or prohibited in the zoning bylaw.

Leanne Taylor1:57:19

The argument of whether the expiry of a time limited use results in a non-conforming use protection would likely not apply as a zoning bylaw would only include a time limit limited clause for the value use of the land.

Leanne Taylor1:57:33

So what that means is that if we adopt a zoning bylaw with a time limited use, we wouldn't have to do another zoning bylaw amendment to amend that particular bylaw because it just will it it expires essentially.

Leanne Taylor1:57:53

So some of the factors that staff did consider as part of this option, and and it's important that we do, are consistencies with the town's official community plan because technically we can't you know have a zoning bylaw that's inconsistent with an OCP.

Leanne Taylor1:58:11

Other requirements such as principal residence, number of vacation rentals on a lot, and parking, and the process for adopting a zoning bylaw to permit a time limited use.

Leanne Taylor1:58:22

So in the town, most vacation rentals would be located on properties that are currently designated small small small scale multi unit housing, which permits single family dwellings.

Leanne Taylor1:58:31

Commercial non-residential rental use is not identified as a supported use in this land use designation.

Leanne Taylor1:58:39

However, given the temporary nature of this proposed use, we one could argue that it is not inconsistent with the OCP because it would just be a very short, short time frame.

Leanne Taylor1:59:05

So the usual place where they make their home.

Leanne Taylor1:59:08

And this provincial requirement would apply if vacation rentals were permitted in the town for a time limited period.

Leanne Taylor1:59:17

Yeah.

Leanne Taylor1:59:18

And then also one thing to consider is parking.

Leanne Taylor1:59:21

So the parking requirement for bed and breakfast currently is two additional off-street parking spaces.

Leanne Taylor1:59:26

And so if council were to pursue this option, then staff is also recommending that a parking requirement be added.

Leanne Taylor1:59:50

So you know, technically a vacation rental would be considered a home based business.

Leanne Taylor1:59:55

So we would um under this option, we would um you know require business licensing because when they when a short-term rental provider registers a short-term rental with the province, they must provide a business license number to the province.

Leanne Taylor2:00:14

So we would uh we would need to do that process as well.

Leanne Taylor2:00:20

And uh our current business license fee is $100, and staff is recommending to increase that to $150 due to the administrative costs associated with something like this, and that is also consistent with other places.

Leanne Taylor2:00:36

So as I noted, um there is provincial regulations and licensing.

Leanne Taylor2:00:40

So under the provincial legislation, a short-term rental host must register their um their with the provincial short-term rental registry and pay an annual registration fee to operate a short-term rental.

Leanne Taylor2:00:54

So the applicants would be required to apply, and they must have a valid business license to register.

Leanne Taylor2:01:03

And I heard today that the annual fee registration fee is around $450.

Leanne Taylor2:01:12

The recommendation in the report is that council does not proceed with permitting vacation rentals during the period of June 1st to July 31st in support of 2026 World Cup soccer.

Leanne Taylor2:01:25

And the reasons for that are several.

Leanne Taylor2:01:30

And uh there is to do to do this, um, there, you know, it there are, as I know, there's two permissible options to do this, with which is um through a zoning bylaw amendment or a temporary permit.

Leanne Taylor2:01:43

Um and uh there it would be a slightly a snowball effect because um we would also have to look at business licensing, provincial regulations and licensing and bylaw comp uh enforcement and compliance, and um just the amount of staff time and resources that would be required to initiate um something like this for two months.

Leanne Taylor2:02:03

So if council is really wanting to explore the idea of short-term rental, then they may want to keep you may want to consider um for a longer period of time given the amount of work that would go into it.

Leanne Taylor2:02:17

Um, if if council would like to entertain a pilot, a pilot project of some sort.

Leanne Taylor2:02:22

Um, but it's it's uh for two months, there's just it's it's a lot of time and and and resources for that sort of thing.

Leanne Taylor2:02:31

Um, however, there is an alternative option in the staff report that if council wishes to um temporarily permit short-term rentals during World Cup soccer, um, that's uh it's it's done through a zoning by law amendment with some some conditions attached to it, such as um parking, um only allowing one vacation rental on a lot as an accessory use to the dwelling unit, as well as uh charging a business application fee of $150.

Leanne Taylor2:03:00

Thank you.

Sid Tobias2:03:02

Thanks, Leanne.

Sid Tobias2:03:03

Uh can I get a motion to receive uh Leanne's report?

Sid Tobias2:03:07

So moved by Councillor Mattson, seconded by seconded by Councilor Rogers, all those in favor of receipt?

Sid Tobias2:03:14

Because really it's about the discussion now.

Ron Mattson2:03:15

We do have a question.

Sid Tobias2:03:16

Oh, yeah.

Sid Tobias2:03:21

Uh please ask questions while we have Leanne up here now, knowing that this is in response to a later agenda item that is Councilor Brown's previous notice of motion uh for short term rentals.

Sid Tobias2:03:35

So I don't want to talk about it in two places.

Sid Tobias2:03:37

I just want to talk about it in one.

Sid Tobias2:03:40

So if you have any questions for staff related to this, please ask Leanne now.

Sid Tobias2:03:44

Thank you.

Ron Mattson2:03:46

So thanks, Leanne.

Ron Mattson2:03:47

So I've never been able to determine what exactly the difference is between a short-term rental and a bed and breakfast.

Ron Mattson2:03:55

And can you like have a three-week bed and breakfast?

Ron Mattson2:03:59

And so what what exactly is a bed and breakfast compared to a short-term rental?

Leanne Taylor2:04:07

We def uh through the mayor, we define a bed and breakfast in our OCP and um they're not self-contained units.

Leanne Taylor2:04:13

Uh generally short-term rentals are self-contained units.

Leanne Taylor2:04:16

Bed and breakfast must be within the main, the principal dwellings, so shared space with the um with the principal um resident.

Leanne Taylor2:04:26

And uh it's only limited up to 60 days a year where you can operate a bed and breakfast.

Leanne Taylor2:04:31

So there is a maximum number of days.

Ron Mattson2:04:34

So my follow-up question in terms of self-contained.

Ron Mattson2:04:38

If you had a door open between the house and the other, you know what would otherwise be a suite if it was the door was locked is that still a bed and breakfast I'll have to go back and look at the exact wording but um a bed and breakfast and a short term rental are very different.

Don Brown2:05:02

Councilor Brown I don't believe there's another section I think this is my notice of motion here.

Sid Tobias2:05:09

No your notice of motion is I think on uh the agenda item 14 near the end, and that's uh short term rentals.

Don Brown2:05:21

That's not the one about the uh barriers, is it?

Sid Tobias2:05:24

No, that comes after that.

Sid Tobias2:05:26

14 uh yeah, 14 a1 is that and then because I do have a third option, but anyway.

Sid Tobias2:05:35

Just questions for Leanne for now.

Sid Tobias2:05:38

We good?

Sid Tobias2:05:39

Okay.

Sid Tobias2:05:40

So uh thanks, Leanne.

Sid Tobias2:05:42

Much appreciated.

Sid Tobias2:05:43

Uh so we've received uh Leanne's report.

Sid Tobias2:05:47

We're down now to correspondence with uh of which you should have a sheet for uh that's correspondence for this meeting.

Sid Tobias2:05:56

There's other correspondence, but that is under the Cal uh consent agenda, I think.

Sid Tobias2:06:01

Um so does somebody want to pull anything out of the three items of correspondence, or um does somebody want to move it as a block?

Sid Tobias2:06:19

Item nine.

Sid Tobias2:06:21

Yes, go ahead, Chair.

Gery Lemon2:06:23

I yes, I'd like to pull um nine A, please.

Sid Tobias2:06:32

Is there any other folks that want to pull it up?

Sid Tobias2:06:36

Pull 9B.

Sid Tobias2:06:37

9B.

Sid Tobias2:06:37

Does somebody want to pull 9C out and we can talk about each item?

Sid Tobias2:06:41

Or uh let's move uh move for receipt for uh number C, and then we'll deal with A and uh B.

Sid Tobias2:06:49

So somebody want to move receipt of second move by Council McKenzie, seconded by councillor Rogers.

Sid Tobias2:06:57

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:06:58

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:06:59

Nobody's opposed.

Sid Tobias2:07:01

Motion carries.

Sid Tobias2:07:03

Um Councillor Lemon, I believe you had uh A.

Gery Lemon2:07:09

Yeah, thank you.

Gery Lemon2:07:10

Uh this is the second letter we've received from certainly the Ashley Gate strata.

Gery Lemon2:07:18

Um and this letter is from Ashley Gate and Lyons Cove combined combined stratus.

Gery Lemon2:07:25

Um concerned and and and aggrieved by the uh lack of care of the properties on Elton Road, um 296, 294, and the corner property on 242 Helmcken.

Gery Lemon2:07:43

And they're in this letter, the the author is asking us to get involved because they've made their plea.

Gery Lemon2:07:51

I think a lawn got cut and and I do know the property owners seems to me they were here and said yes we will be good citizens, yes we will take care of those properties, yes we want everything to work.

Gery Lemon2:08:07

And that's not happening.

Gery Lemon2:08:10

So I I think this goes beyond you know having bylaw officer you know drop in on i they these these people are the the the people largely living there um they don't care you know they're they're here for short term construction jobs and and uh it's that there's no vested interest in the properties so i i think this calls for a perhaps a meeting a discussion a some strong words um a letter um a lawyer's letter to the property owners about the uh the oh i see the uh yeah let's uh give our uh yeah.

Gery Lemon2:09:01

Are you here to speak for that?

Gery Lemon2:09:02

Okay, well, I'll stop.

Paul Hurst2:09:04

Turn it over to you.

Paul Hurst2:09:05

Here we go.

Paul Hurst2:09:05

Good evening, Mayor, members of council.

Paul Hurst2:09:08

I I did read the letter with interest.

Paul Hurst2:09:10

Um, I asked my bylaw officer to pull some some numbers here for us just to give you an indication of what we're dealing with.

Paul Hurst2:09:20

Um in 2024, there were a total of 14 complaints on Eltham surrounding those properties.

Paul Hurst2:09:29

2025 there were 35 complaints.

Paul Hurst2:09:32

I'll give you a breakdown here.

Paul Hurst2:09:34

Um, in 2024, there were two complaints about property maintenance involving those three homes.

Paul Hurst2:09:40

In 2025, there were two complaints of property maintenance.

Paul Hurst2:09:45

Uh 294 Eltham uh has received a total of five complaints in two years.

Paul Hurst2:09:50

296 Eltham is two complaints in two years, and two four two Helmcken is two complaints.

Paul Hurst2:09:57

The majority of the complaints in 2025 were we directly related to construction workers from 258 Um Helmcken, the large condo project.

Paul Hurst2:10:09

There were 30 parking complaints on Eltham, and those were found to be construction workers.

Paul Hurst2:10:15

Um to date, we haven't had any complaints about parking on Eltham this year.

Paul Hurst2:10:20

So the majority of the complaints were surrounded around parking.

Paul Hurst2:10:24

Um and we've had a total of four, looks like four property maintenance complaints uh over the past two years uh for those properties.

Sid Tobias2:10:40

Yeah, go ahead, Gary.

Gery Lemon2:10:42

Thank you, Chief.

Gery Lemon2:10:43

Um, I I think the i hear often very very often um from people living in the it in the two stratus of their their frustrations and they don't they they don't take them to bylaw very often um you know they're they're the issue with rats for example um the it it it goes beyond just parked cars and they feel that um they're loop the the neighborhood is being run down and and the owner is not being attentive to the properties.

Gery Lemon2:11:35

So I uh I which is why you know I suggest that perhaps we the mayor staff with the we um go directly to the owner and say, look, we're getting these you you promised us you'd be a a good corporate citizen, and and you know, in many ways you are.

Paul Hurst2:11:59

We're we're we're seeing that in in other situations, but this, you know, we have many people living in these properties who are not happy, and this letter and previous letters have spoken to this got one first uh I'll go to you uh have we uh written a letter has bylaw written a letter for the owners yet or has this been like no this is this is the my apologies for interrupting sorry um only the bylaw complaints the the six or seven bylaw complaints we we haven't engaged the owner we've dealt directly with the the tenants on the property maintenance and dealt directly with the construction workers on parking but bylaw has not engaged the property owner this is the this letter that was received by mayor and council is the first letter that I've seen that outlines in detail uh the concerns of the neighborhood.

Sid Tobias2:12:51

Um from the letter, what would your recommended course of action ball be?

Paul Hurst2:13:00

Um I would be meeting with the uh owner of the three properties.

Paul Hurst2:13:05

I I did check with our our director of development services to understand where this project sits right now.

Paul Hurst2:13:12

I would hate to think that um we're allowing a piece of property to degradate to the point where it's a negotiating tool with council to say, well, it's such a mess, but if you give me this, then I'll make it better.

Paul Hurst2:13:24

I am curious as to why it hasn't proceeded with the uh the development.

Paul Hurst2:13:29

Um, but that could be a question that I would ask the owner.

Paul Hurst2:13:32

Um I don't know how far I'll get because we deal directly with the um with the the the tenants.

Paul Hurst2:13:40

Um we did engage the owner once on one property maintenance complaint and within the day the the property was cleaned up however we haven't engaged for probably about a year with the owner of that property so and normally by law uh takes care of that letter am I assuming correct under normal circumstances we yeah we would we would draft the letter and we would um we would um deliver it to or or arrange a meeting um but i would rely on the guidance of counsel on what your wishes are to do with this this particular complaint and this uh this three page document i'm i'm more than happy to uh to do whatever you need uh done thank you um Paul we'll go to uh councilor matzon you have a uh question or comment yeah i think Paul may have answered it but basically I what I guess I would like to see is is him take the letter down go discuss with the the property owner and then report back to us it well hopefully saying that yeah he said he's going to approve it but to hear back from him yeah that would be my recommendation as well that uh have bylack uh because as as soon like there's not nothing left after we do you know uh after counsel or I write a letter to the owner.

Sid Tobias2:15:01

There's no escalatory path beyond that.

Sid Tobias2:15:04

Then it uh then it then it turns a little bit differently.

Sid Tobias2:15:07

Um so I I think seeing how it hasn't been done for the owner yet and in the in the letter itself that uh I I think there needs to be we can't be picking them apart and writing a letter every month that until the time of redevelopment the expectation is is these um uh properties are uh maintained in accordance with our uh property bylaws um and and uh so uh that's what I would recommend for an uh uh an action now is let bylaw do its job and write the letter if that doesn't work then we can bring it back but or report back on kind of the status.

Sid Tobias2:15:49

But if we jump all over it, I don't think we're allowing bylaw to do its job to do it or track it.

Sid Tobias2:15:55

Um would you support that Paul?

Paul Hurst2:15:58

I can I can have that letter drafted tomorrow and arrange a meeting with the uh the property owner as early as this week or next week.

John Rogers2:16:07

Sorry, and uh in the letter, would you be advising the uh the owner that uh council is aware from letters of concern and complaint um as well as the reported incidences?

Paul Hurst2:16:18

Yeah, if it pleases council, I can um I can indicate that I'm speaking on behalf of a complaint received by Mayor and Council and that um it's it's escalated to the point where it needs to be addressed immediately.

Gery Lemon2:16:31

Thank you, Paul.

Sid Tobias2:16:33

And I will just say this: I wish they overlooked some of the properties uh in different areas of town with equally as challenging properties.

Sid Tobias2:16:41

I think uh the these problems will continue to be very sensitive and topic or top of mind as we build higher buildings that overlook other buildings.

Sid Tobias2:16:53

This is going to be unavoidable in the future.

Sid Tobias2:16:56

And there's some subjective as well.

Sid Tobias2:16:59

Somebody could have a nice house that was built 20 years ago but needs some work or is overgrown because of age.

Sid Tobias2:17:04

So there's all kinds of other factors associated with this as well.

Sid Tobias2:17:08

So appreciating all that.

Sid Tobias2:17:09

Appreciate your work.

Sid Tobias2:17:10

So I think what we need to do is uh do you need uh uh motion, Paul, to make this happen?

Paul Hurst2:17:17

Yeah.

Paul Hurst2:17:17

Direction would be uh appreciated, and I'll I'll get on it tomorrow.

Sid Tobias2:17:20

So uh council Lemon, I think I can summarize your motion that by law write a letter to the owner uh of the properties, uh, and that the expectation is that those properties be maintained in accordance with their bylaw and that occur immediately.

Gery Lemon2:17:43

Sounds good.

Gery Lemon2:17:44

Um and and perhaps um separate separate from that.

Gery Lemon2:17:50

You would would you have the letter that it that we have on our agenda in hand, Paul?

Paul Hurst2:17:59

I do have that letter.

Gery Lemon2:18:01

Yeah, so so that you can show it to the owner.

Paul Hurst2:18:04

I'll uh I'll make sure that the correspondence that's going to the owner reflects the concerns of the neighborhood.

Paul Hurst2:18:10

Brilliant.

Paul Hurst2:18:11

Absolutely.

John Rogers2:18:12

So yeah, so we need to move.

Sid Tobias2:18:14

We need a mover in a second or so.

Sid Tobias2:18:16

Council Lemony, happy to move it.

Sid Tobias2:18:17

Uh Council Rogers second.

Sid Tobias2:18:19

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:18:20

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:18:22

An opposed motion carries.

Sid Tobias2:18:24

Okay, let's move on.

Sid Tobias2:18:25

Uh we've still got a closed meeting after this folks, so I'm trying to be efficient.

Sid Tobias2:18:30

Um and uh this is correspondence B.

Sid Tobias2:18:33

I think Councillor Rogers, you wanted to move this up.

John Rogers2:18:36

Yes, please.

John Rogers2:18:36

So uh this is Urskin Lane um that um was built long ago and and in a forested area and and uh so they had a lot of trees planted, and now those trees are are uh coming of age and becoming problematic as as we've s heard from older Smith Woods and Choco and so forth.

John Rogers2:18:55

Chef, have we um um the the alternatives and uh that they're proposing?

John Rogers2:19:01

Uh I wonder if there's any thoughts or suggestions on how um because it appears that the arborist is uh suggesting there doesn't appear to be much room.

John Rogers2:19:11

They tried to go to a uh um uh um a nursery, they can't buy any oak trees.

John Rogers2:19:20

Um so I wondered how we can um work out the six tree replacement um requirement thank you, Mayor Tobias.

Ivan Leung2:19:29

Um staff are actually in the midst of still working with the property owner on this, so um I would say that the discussions haven't got to a point where we would say if you don't like what we are saying, then go to council.

Ivan Leung2:19:43

We're not there yet.

Ivan Leung2:19:44

There's still a lot of room for us to work with them on this.

Ivan Leung2:19:47

Quite similarly as to what council has uh directed staff to do for a property in the Lund area.

Ivan Leung2:19:54

Similar, there wasn't a lot of space, so can we look at saplings and you know that kind of stuff?

Ivan Leung2:19:58

So uh we would be operating in the same way that way.

Ivan Leung2:20:02

So I would recommend that um this be deferred to staff for administering as part of the permit because we're not there yet in terms of a dead end.

John Rogers2:20:10

Let us know.

John Rogers2:20:12

Thank you.

Sid Tobias2:20:13

So we need a motion to receive counselor rogers.

Sid Tobias2:20:15

Move a shape.

Sid Tobias2:20:16

Seconded by Councilor Brown.

Sid Tobias2:20:19

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:20:21

Any opposed, seeing none opposed.

Sid Tobias2:20:23

Motion carries.

Sid Tobias2:20:25

That brings us to the consent agenda of which some things have been pulled out.

Sid Tobias2:20:31

Councilor Rogers, were you H?

Sid Tobias2:20:34

That is now A, I believe?

Ivan Leung2:20:37

Or is H up now?

Sid Tobias2:20:39

Uh well, yeah, that'll be up now, and that's uh 11.

Sid Tobias2:20:44

Well, let's just call it 118.

John Rogers2:20:47

So, yes, uh letter um from Mr.

John Rogers2:20:50

Arnd and the um uh climate coalition folks, um, and they're uh challenging the town to um meet with um a higher standard in the urban uh canopy strategy, uh not 30 percent but 40.

John Rogers2:21:04

And um uh it's interesting reading this, and and uh they certainly bring out um you know valid points that um why limit why limit ourselves to a net neutral um because there's uh a curious idea that we could request um a 1% growth solution.

John Rogers2:21:25

So it's it's you know 30 plus one plus plus plus to to keep the um the growth on on that minimum level.

John Rogers2:21:34

And I I I think we should investigate uh this a little further to see if we can't increase our ante.

Sid Tobias2:21:41

Uh thanks, uh Councilor Rogers.

Sid Tobias2:21:43

I think this has been pushed back to staff, and we're waiting for some options and a report back.

Sid Tobias2:21:50

Am I saying that right up?

Ivan Leung2:21:51

Uh Mayor Tobias, that is correct.

Ivan Leung2:21:53

Um, council directed staff to look at other scenarios.

Ivan Leung2:21:56

35%, 40% uh can't be coverage scenarios and the gap analysis on that.

Ivan Leung2:22:03

Um as part of that update, we will be comparing uh metrics of what the neighboring municipalities have done to give a little bit more context to council in a fair manner.

Ivan Leung2:22:16

Um, I would say that uh some of these items are not comparing apples to apples.

Ivan Leung2:22:20

So, like if one says 40%, well, it's based on not on an urban containment boundary.

Ivan Leung2:22:24

So we can say we're actually 20% better than 40%.

Ivan Leung2:22:27

So we want to make sure that we compare things apples to apples to make sure the council has a good understanding.

Ivan Leung2:22:31

Um, and also we're we want to deal with relevant um uh standards.

Ivan Leung2:22:37

So some of the standards in here are probably 10, 13 years old.

Ivan Leung2:22:41

So we want to make sure that we we deal with the current standards.

Ivan Leung2:22:43

Uh we're trying to feverishly get that towards council as soon as we can because it does have an element of OCP to it.

Ivan Leung2:22:50

So expect a report to council very, very shortly.

John Rogers2:22:55

So uh as it comes back, we can also consider the merits for the letter and and in that context of doing the best we can.

Sid Tobias2:23:03

Exactly the action.

John Rogers2:23:05

Yeah, sounds good.

John Rogers2:23:06

Move the shape.

Sid Tobias2:23:08

Uh okay, uh second or for the receipt.

Sid Tobias2:23:10

All those in favor, any opposed, seeing none opposed, motion carries.

Sid Tobias2:23:14

Uh then we had two letters on short-term rentals.

Sid Tobias2:23:20

Do we want to address those with counselor Brown's discussion, or do we want to deal with those now?

Don Brown2:23:32

We received a number of letters and mostly positive.

Don Brown2:23:35

I haven't seen any people saying we don't want.

Don Brown2:23:38

Can we uh my motion, if I could do it right now, is to um move this to a cow meeting uh for the cow meeting for for a wholesome discussion just on short-term rentals, period.

Don Brown2:23:52

Those two, yeah.

Don Brown2:23:55

Uh no, I want to keep mine.

Sid Tobias2:24:11

Uh we we can make a motion like that, uh, but I don't want to kick correspondence down the road that necessarily far.

Sid Tobias2:24:19

Your intent is to have a discussion about short-term rentals in general.

Sid Tobias2:24:23

Is that right?

Don Brown2:24:24

Yeah, to deal with the uh the two items, uh L and N, I think it was the uh the emails that came through.

Don Brown2:24:30

Um separate that and separate than my motion because uh I have um focused.

Sid Tobias2:24:35

Uh but you you want to preserve that.

Sid Tobias2:24:38

So uh yeah, if your motion was to bring up the topic of short-term rentals, include these two uh in general, include these two correspondence as part of that for the next council of the whole.

Sid Tobias2:24:53

Is that the motion?

Sid Tobias2:24:54

Yeah, that's correct.

Sid Tobias2:24:55

Uh, do we have a second over counselor uh Brown's motion?

Sid Tobias2:24:58

Seconded by Counselor Mattson.

Sid Tobias2:24:59

Uh it's going through Cat.

Sid Tobias2:25:06

Uh committee of the whole, with the exception of Councilor Brown's motion, which is focused on actual time.

Sid Tobias2:25:12

So this would be a general discussion at a council whole about short-term rentals.

Sid Tobias2:25:17

Um, so is there a need to motivate?

Sid Tobias2:25:21

Uh I don't think so.

Sid Tobias2:25:24

All those in favor of the motion to have it uh attached to a council of the whole agenda.

Sid Tobias2:25:29

All those in favor of that.

Sid Tobias2:25:30

Any opposed to that?

Sid Tobias2:25:32

Nobody's opposed to that.

Sid Tobias2:25:34

Okay, so uh those two uh pieces of correspondence and the short-term rental discussion larger than uh the focused motion that you have on the floor is there.

Sid Tobias2:25:46

We've already dealt with item P, which was 268 Helmcken Road.

Sid Tobias2:25:53

Um, that was included in our discussion uh as part of that.

Sid Tobias2:25:59

So uh can I have a motion uh to uh approve the consent agenda, seeing how everything was dealt with.

Sid Tobias2:26:10

Move by councillor Metzen, second by councilor Rogers, all those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:26:14

Any opposed, seeing none opposed.

Sid Tobias2:26:17

That motion carries, and I think that brings us down to question period for anybody in the room, which is just you.

Sid Tobias2:26:24

If you have a question for counsel, it it doesn't have to be related to the agenda.

Sid Tobias2:26:51

So everybody else can benefit, and then way we we won't forget about what your question was.

Sid Tobias2:26:56

So you so you got one crack at a question, could be questions, but they seem to uh whatever you want to ask does happy.

R. Irish2:27:03

I'm trying to send an email, which is just simply the the benefits of the Airbnb reports for the whole of BC.

R. Irish2:27:11

But I'm having challenges on my phone, but I promised I would give it to you.

R. Irish2:27:15

And if we could add it maybe to your discussion when I do get it to you, to support the whole short-term rental in this community.

R. Irish2:27:24

Abilities to get the business license.

Sid Tobias2:27:26

Thank you.

Sid Tobias2:27:27

Appreciate it.

Sid Tobias2:27:28

Thank you.

Sid Tobias2:27:31

And I think that uh brings us down to Carl.

Sid Tobias2:27:36

Carl, we got any questions online?

Sid Tobias2:27:39

Uh Mayor Tobias, we've had no call or no messages this evening.

Sid Tobias2:27:43

You were about to say callers.

Sid Tobias2:27:44

I know you were.

Sid Tobias2:27:45

I was.

Sid Tobias2:27:46

Uh motions and notices of motion.

Sid Tobias2:27:49

Counselor Brown, you have a uh a motion that was a notice of motion, uh, to allow short-term rentals uh from June 1st to July 31st.

Don Brown2:27:59

Well, first of all, my apologies for using the word amnesty was probably incorrect usage.

Don Brown2:28:06

My intent was to uh have a period of non-enforcement.

Don Brown2:28:09

So my motion would be to have a period of non-enforcement of the bylaws pertaining to vacation rentals during the period of June the first to July 31st.

Don Brown2:28:20

Under the BCE uh Supreme Court, they made a ruling that that municipalities can have short-term um non-enforcement of bylaws, providing it's in good faith and it's not for an indefinite period of time.

Don Brown2:28:33

It's in the BC Supreme Court.

Don Brown2:28:35

And uh I keep it simple.

Don Brown2:28:37

I'm sorry, I'd like to uh nothing against staff.

Don Brown2:28:40

I like to think we use the KISS principle.

Don Brown2:28:42

We don't need a whole new bylaw.

Don Brown2:28:44

All we need to do is say for that period of time we won't go issue tickets to people if if a complaint comes in August the first you go knock on their door that's that's my motion I hope I get someone second and have further discussion so uh you got a second councilor lemon um counselor matzen okay uh counselor mattson seconded um uh for motivation for this was that your motivation counselor the the reason for it, again, it's very simple.

Don Brown2:29:18

It's first of all, it's for a very short period of time.

Don Brown2:29:21

It's an opportunity for us to see if there's problems with short-term rentals, noise, parking, et cetera, et cetera.

Don Brown2:29:29

It also gives people an opportunity.

Don Brown2:29:31

There's a lot of people who are empty nesters.

Don Brown2:29:32

Their children are moved, they've got extra space in their house.

Don Brown2:29:36

People that have big mortgages, they may want a mortgage helper for that period of time.

Don Brown2:29:40

It's a very short period of time.

Don Brown2:29:41

It's also an opportunity to entertain and have people from all over the world.

Don Brown2:29:47

They're gonna come.

Don Brown2:29:48

This is the biggest event since the Olympics in Vancouver.

Don Brown2:29:52

Not only that, people are gonna come before the Games, after the Games, and they're gonna want to visit the Pacific Northwest, including Southern Vancouver Island.

Don Brown2:30:01

Um they're gonna come over here for sure.

Don Brown2:30:04

It's a big boost, a short period of time, but again, it's a big boost for the local economy, uh, for restaurants, bars, retail, um, entertainment, uh, golf, you name it.

Don Brown2:30:14

It's going to be again, it's a very, very short period.

Don Brown2:30:18

And not only that, thousands of people in Seattle have canceled their tickets to their games.

Don Brown2:30:24

They've canceled their travel arrangements to Seattle.

Don Brown2:30:27

And guess what?

Don Brown2:30:28

A lot of those people are going to come to Vancouver and they're going to come to Vancouver Island.

Don Brown2:30:32

This is a we are a tourist attraction.

Don Brown2:30:35

Tourists is big business.

Don Brown2:30:36

This could bring in potentially millions of dollars.

Don Brown2:30:40

Not only that, people are going to come, they're going to enjoy their stay here, and they're probably going to come back again.

Don Brown2:30:45

And again, all we have to do is say for that short period of time, we don't even need we don't even make a policy.

Don Brown2:30:52

We just say for that short period of time, our director of bylaws here, he just says to bylaw guy, we won't enforce it but hey guess what august the first you're not complying with the bylaw and that's all I'm asking for it's allowed on the the BC Supreme Court has made a ruling Vancouver has done something similar so to me it's it's it's the KISS principle sorry 40 hours of time I'm sorry we don't need to do all the motivation this is option number this is option number three uh councillor did you want to I think uh I'm I'm in totally in support of this, and I think we should do this because we don't want him to have another stroke um uh any other comments?

Sid Tobias2:31:44

Uh let's go with Councillor McKenzie first and counselor.

Alison MacKenzie2:31:48

So I I don't think we really need to take any action at all, to be honest.

Alison MacKenzie2:31:54

This, there are not going to be people who are not currently doing this illegally.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:01

Not many, if any, that would suddenly do this because of the amnesty.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:07

So, for instance, I'm not going to now say, oh, I can do this for two months.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:12

I think there's a lot that goes into doing an Airbnb or things like that.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:16

So it's likely gonna be those people who are already doing it illegally uh who will continue to do it.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:25

Um, I don't really see much benefit to specifically to the town of Vroyal in allowing it for this short period of time.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:36

I think there could be risks of you know complaints around the parking or things like that.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:41

A lot of confusion as well because people think, oh, I didn't think the neighbor could do this.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:46

So there might be a lot of calls that have to be fielded by staff for this.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:51

And again, for what benefit to the town and residents in that short period of time.

Sid Tobias2:33:01

Thank you, Councillor McKenzie.

Sid Tobias2:33:03

Uh councilor Rodriguez.

John Rogers2:33:05

Yeah, I didn't I I understand the the the point.

John Rogers2:33:08

I'm not sure how much of a a take up there will be.

John Rogers2:33:11

Um, you know, and um I'm I'm curious.

John Rogers2:33:14

Councillor Brown, do you know of the any other municipalities in the city of Victoria that are or the capital region that are taking a similar approach?

John Rogers2:33:21

I you hear speak of Vancouver, what about the rest here?

Don Brown2:33:24

Not that I'm aware of, but certainly Vancouver.

Don Brown2:33:26

As fact Vancouver did go to the extent of making a very extensive bylaw, including increasing the times for noise, noise, noise complaints, graffiti, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.

Don Brown2:33:36

Again, I'm trying to keep this as very, very simple.

Don Brown2:33:40

And as a bylaw officer, we often did did not enforce bylaws for certain periods of time.

Don Brown2:33:47

So it's not, uh it's been done, it can be done, it's been put uh debated in the Supreme Court and passed.

Don Brown2:33:54

So that as long as it's not indefinite, and it's and it's it's in good faith, which it is.

Don Brown2:34:00

And the the potential is huge for some people to put a few dollars in their pocket, and who couldn't use that, uh, and promote our area.

Don Brown2:34:09

Uh, not only our area, it would spill over to the other municipalities, obviously.

John Rogers2:34:14

So if I if I may, uh your worship, I'm wondering if um Chief Hurst, who has his thumb on in enforcement, uh would comment on uh this idea of uh uh not doing any enforcement uh in this particular time period for those that may wish to stay in Victoria for the those sixty days.

Paul Hurst2:34:39

More than happy to follow whatever direction counsel gives me in the enforcement or non-enforcement of your bylaws.

Paul Hurst2:34:45

And unfortunately I I can't make that decision as the as the officer, but if I'm given direction from counsel to uh not enforce our bylaws for a period of time then that's at your prerogative.

John Rogers2:34:54

So um I'm just wondering, you know however, you know I'm I'm I'm know that you will take whatever direction.

Paul Hurst2:35:01

But you know I would hope that if you also give us some um cautions that what because you got your finger on the pulse of uh enforcement in this town, um do you see that there could be any downsides to in even in this short time frame um to this suggestion if I'm if I'm going back in time and thinking about how many complaints we actually had in the town of Ural on Airbnb and short term rentals i i believe it would be very limited i mean i could research those numbers i don't recall there being when when suites were allowed and airbnbs and whatnot i don't recall you know um a lot of complaints in the neighborhood there were you know there were one or two there's always the one or two outliers but i never i never understood it as a problem and i see it as a as a cheaper form of accommodations in a province that is lacking in hotel rooms so if there's an opportunity i'm I'm more than happy to to follow direction and and do whatever you want me to do.

John Rogers2:36:00

Thank you.

John Rogers2:36:01

Um that that's what I need to hear.

John Rogers2:36:03

And be reminded of, because indeed VWOL has has had it ex a share of Airbnbs under the carpet.

John Rogers2:36:09

You know, you uh I think there were quite a few of them uh until we we shut it all down.

John Rogers2:36:14

But uh I never knew about the Airbnbs and uh aside from uh certainly it wasn't through bylaw.

John Rogers2:36:21

It was uh just through um word of mouth and discovering what was in coming up and through the internet.

John Rogers2:36:27

So um I I think for this short period of time it's um I I uh I concur with uh Council Brown.

Ron Mattson2:36:35

Okay.

Sid Tobias2:36:36

Uh other questions.

Sid Tobias2:36:38

I'm gonna make a comment uh of I I Googled short-term rentals from my house and two apartments in Eagle Creek came up.

Sid Tobias2:36:49

Right.

Sid Tobias2:36:50

Those uh those apartments could be long-term apartments that people are choosing to rent them out on short-term rentals.

Sid Tobias2:36:58

It it it opens up a bit of a can of worms.

Sid Tobias2:37:02

Yours was a very specific um uh you know time period um but already the amount of correspondence we've had on short-term rentals it opened up something that we've already got a bylaw and I'm not opposed to having a discussion about it but I don't think we're out of the woods yet for our housing affordability to be honest with you I we're not like opportunities yeah okay uh I'm more concerned about the folks that can't afford department, to be honest with you.

Sid Tobias2:37:33

Please hear me up, Councilor Brown uh I think uh you know, I'm not uh unsupportive of your um your thing, but I think it's a do nothing one.

Sid Tobias2:37:43

Like why even even mention it if the intent is to um is to support an amnesty of enforcement that we're really don't have the manpower to enforce right now.

Sid Tobias2:37:54

Um so that that's my own belief right now.

Sid Tobias2:37:56

I think I'm okay with our policy in place, um, and that it's there for a reason.

Sid Tobias2:38:02

And I think it's working slowly, but that's my concern right now that we are opening ourselves up for some broader questions about it where we're not prepared to answer right now.

Sid Tobias2:38:14

Go ahead, counselor.

Don Brown2:38:15

Just as a quick uh follow-up.

Don Brown2:38:17

First of all, um, it wouldn't be taking away long-term rentals from people first because it's a very short period, for one.

Don Brown2:38:24

Also, the vacancy rate is is is getting very high, probably seven or eight percent, maybe even more.

Don Brown2:38:29

It's not like the one percent like it was several months ago.

Don Brown2:38:29

So um again, it's uh uh again, a very short term.

Don Brown2:38:35

There may be people sitting there that haven't been able to rent their place and they can do it for two months.

Don Brown2:38:40

But but I'm I'm looking broader than that.

Don Brown2:38:42

I'm looking at the the social aspect um of people coming from all over the world that may come back again.

Don Brown2:38:48

And again, I know it's a very short period of time, but there's gonna be hundreds and hundreds of people coming here, guaranteed.

Don Brown2:38:55

And some people will come here and they'll get in a little fast ferry over to Seattle and watch a game, or they'll take the ferry across and go to Vancouver.

Don Brown2:39:02

There's seven games in Vancouver and six in Seattle.

Don Brown2:39:05

And I I I don't, I have nothing.

Don Brown2:39:07

FIFA is not giving me any money to promote this, and I don't have any intentions myself to rent my space out.

Don Brown2:39:13

And no no neighbors have been coming to me and saying, you know, can we rent our space?

Don Brown2:39:14

No, this is just because of what I heard what the city of Vancouver was doing.

Don Brown2:39:20

And it makes a lot of sense because um the hotel space will be very, very limited.

Don Brown2:39:25

In fact, some people are gonna say, Well my god, I can't even find a place in Vancouver, Seattle.

Don Brown2:39:29

So it's an opportunity, and it's a win-win.

Don Brown2:39:32

Um, people get a chance to try it out and see if this is something we would might like to do longer term, and we get to see if we get inundated with commitments.

Don Brown2:39:40

And if we get complaints, we can still follow them up on August the 1st.

Sid Tobias2:39:46

Yep.

Sid Tobias2:39:47

Uh nobody else has any questions or comments uh about Councillor Brown's notion.

Sid Tobias2:39:53

All in favor of Councillor Brown's motion.

Sid Tobias2:39:55

All in favor, all opposed to Councilor Brown's motion.

Sid Tobias2:39:59

Councillor McKenzie and myself.

Sid Tobias2:40:02

So the motion passes.

Sid Tobias2:40:04

I'm not sure if there's any action after this that we have to say.

Sid Tobias2:40:08

We're doing an amnesty, but um yeah, so there's no other action for staff, I don't think, to undertake with this.

Sid Tobias2:40:17

Your motion just passes for an amnesty.

Sid Tobias2:40:21

Uh report and public engagement uh spending for proposed RCMP building, Councillor Leonard.

Gery Lemon2:40:29

Thank you.

Gery Lemon2:40:30

I I think this is particularly timely um given the rhetoric and the back and forthing in the media um and and the he said, she said, etc.

Gery Lemon2:40:44

So what I what I would propose is that we have probably a virtual town hall or a hybrid town hall in which we just invite View Royal and answer the questions.

Gery Lemon2:41:01

I think our CAO and our mayor will be the most um um prepared to answer those questions.

Gery Lemon2:41:08

And uh, you know, I know I in in the motion, the notice of motion calls for a report, but you know, I I do realize that we've got the Engaged View royal site with all the available information on there.

Gery Lemon2:41:22

Uh, perhaps for such an event as this, we could have just a you know, a one pager on on the uh on the the key points and the costs.

Gery Lemon2:41:37

So that's my proposal.

Gery Lemon2:41:39

And perhaps when things settle down, we could invite, we could have a super town hall with all three let's not munis poundies and the police and the RCMP or not.

Gery Lemon2:41:55

Okay, let's stick in with View Royal.

Gery Lemon2:41:57

That's my that's my motion.

Sid Tobias2:41:59

Yeah, I think uh I think we're fine with it.

Sid Tobias2:42:02

Uh I think each one of the communities is fine with it for whatever reason.

Sid Tobias2:42:05

There seems to be some stuff crossed right now.

Sid Tobias2:42:09

That um so just a little bit of clarity on your town hall.

Sid Tobias2:42:13

Would it be in conjunction with a council meeting like preceding it or or like what what do you envision for a town hall here?

Sid Tobias2:42:22

Um what kind of format?

Gery Lemon2:42:26

Well, hybrid.

Gery Lemon2:42:27

Right.

Gery Lemon2:42:28

Hybrid, but so most people will would probably be online and perhaps more with their questions.

Gery Lemon2:42:33

So it could be it could be in conjunction with a small agenda council meeting if there is such a thing.

Gery Lemon2:42:40

Because there's you know, there could be a lot of questions, or we could have a standalone.

Leanne Taylor2:42:47

I I would leave that.

Leanne Taylor2:42:48

Scott, what are your thoughts?

Gery Lemon2:42:49

I would leave that to start.

Sid Tobias2:42:50

If we're going to have one, would it be best to do it for a bit in a council of a whole for a half an hour to you know present essentially uh a deck on cost implications specific for View Royal and then entertain any questions, comments from the public?

Scott M. Sommerville2:43:10

Um, well, first I would suggest that we wait until the project is approved by all three owner municipalities before we go to the trouble of having a town hall meeting, because we may not have a project.

Scott M. Sommerville2:43:22

Um secondly, I mean I can certainly expand on the uh what seven slides or whatever we did at Committee of the Whole.

Scott M. Sommerville2:43:30

Um it's uh it's probably gonna be a short meeting.

Scott M. Sommerville2:43:35

Um and it I mean, aside from media cut coverage, it hasn't seemed to generate much interest from our residents, but we can certainly try to pin down some of the the figures that we have.

Scott M. Sommerville2:43:49

There's a lot still unknown.

Scott M. Sommerville2:43:51

We don't know long term operational costs, we don't know Machosen's lease rate, we don't know how much the province will be putting in.

Scott M. Sommerville2:43:59

Um so there's a lot still to be determined.

Scott M. Sommerville2:44:04

Um, and and this will be after council has made its decision to move ahead with the project.

Scott M. Sommerville2:44:12

So it's I think the term I like to use is putting the toothpaste back in the tube.

Scott M. Sommerville2:44:17

Um I I think the information is very important, and I appreciate the plug for the engage view royal website, which we're populating all the time, and we can pull stuff out of that, but uh I I would just suggest sometime hopefully February um possibly March uh to do a bit of a deeper dive into into the financial implications which might roll nicely into a budget meeting.

Sid Tobias2:44:45

Can you uh would you be happy Councilor Lemon with tabling that until we get a response back of the intent of all the municipalities to uh move forward with the project because I fear if we have it now it'll be about people not approving it instead of the implications for View Royal for residents um for it.

Sid Tobias2:45:08

Yeah yeah I'd I'd I'd be fine with that because if it's if if one municipality's not on it'll all be a a moot point so yes elan can we do that just to um and we'll take a vote on a sec but can we do that to um i guess it would be triggered by callwood's approval of uh of the um validation report and it would uh outline next steps and whatnot but that would trigger this showing up let's say at a a council of the whole or further progress without us having to come back and vote for it again.

Sid Tobias2:45:46

That could be able to do that.

Elena Bolster2:45:50

We can table this until March.

Elena Bolster2:45:54

March committee of the whole.

Elena Bolster2:45:55

March, sorry, our march council meeting.

Elena Bolster2:45:57

Yeah.

Sid Tobias2:45:58

Yeah, that would that would work.

Sid Tobias2:45:59

Uh providing that it has is still moving ahead at that point.

Sid Tobias2:46:06

Uh so uh that's councillors lemon's motion.

Sid Tobias2:46:10

I'll second it because I kind of created it.

Sid Tobias2:46:12

But all those in favor of tabling councilor Lemon's motion until the March Council of the Whole.

Sid Tobias2:46:19

Uh any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:46:22

Uh okay.

Sid Tobias2:46:24

Uh notice of motion, and this is something that Council Brown wanted to propose for same-day consideration.

Sid Tobias2:46:30

Councilor Brown.

Don Brown2:46:32

Yeah, the um part of the TCH that goes through View Royal, and of course the chief knows this very well.

Don Brown2:46:38

So do the police department and the ambulance, um, and of course the victims that get involved in all the accidents that occur in that stretch of highway.

Don Brown2:46:45

So my motion is to uh send a letter to the Ministry of Highways with the CC to uh Langford because my proposal would be to um ask them to install barriers on any sections of that highway from uh Millstream to um to McKenzie.

Don Brown2:47:05

And uh I I put I mean it's obviously up to them.

Don Brown2:47:08

I can't say what kind of materials they're just we're gonna get you to focus on that.

Sid Tobias2:47:12

And do we have a seconder for Councilor Brown?

Sid Tobias2:47:14

Uh so councilor Rogers is seconding it.

Sid Tobias2:47:17

And before you get into it, because that's normally what you just do, um, just ask for same day consideration and get a seconder for that if you don't mind.

Ron Mattson2:47:25

Second.

Sid Tobias2:47:27

No, that's okay.

Sid Tobias2:47:27

I think he did.

Sid Tobias2:47:28

Uh uh all those in favor, before we can really discuss it, all those in favor of same day consideration.

Sid Tobias2:47:35

Any opposing none opposed.

Sid Tobias2:47:37

Okay, Councilor Brown, now you can uh motivate as can uh counselor.

Don Brown2:47:42

Yeah, and even you know, there's a big grassy section there too, which is quite wide, but still it doesn't stop cars from careening across into the other lanes.

Don Brown2:47:49

And even even on the sides, there's I mean a guy who drove into a big hole there and and died, right?

Don Brown2:47:55

So um I wasn't even aware of cable uh barricades before.

Don Brown2:47:59

Actually, uh Scott brought that up, uh, mentioned it to me, and I did some research on it.

Don Brown2:48:03

Uh and wow, they have some in Chilliwack, apparently.

Don Brown2:48:06

And they're when you when you hit them, it actually put pushes you back into your uh back into your lane again rather than running into a concrete uh thing.

Don Brown2:48:15

Just for a point of interest, I'm not a mathematician, but I I figured out the cost of those concrete uh barricades, and this is not including the installation, maintenance of them, but look cost per linear foot.

Don Brown2:48:27

What it costs for those blink lanes, massive blink lanes for five or six people to take the bus every morning.

Don Brown2:48:34

They could buy enough concrete blocks to go from View Royal to Port Hardy and still have some left over.

Don Brown2:48:40

If they could float, they could put halfway to Prince Rupert.

Don Brown2:48:44

Just just to put just an aside.

Sid Tobias2:48:46

So uh you're uh intent with your motion.

Sid Tobias2:48:49

I'm just trying to make it crunchy, is that I write a letter.

Sid Tobias2:48:53

Uh uh and and I just might suggest a friendly amendment that we put something like barriers like cable type colon or whatever, put those instead of not solution for them, but just a barrier, but here's a good and and or cylinder.

Sid Tobias2:49:11

Yeah.

Sid Tobias2:49:12

Okay.

Sid Tobias2:49:13

And uh uh can I ask for a little bit of data, Paul?

Sid Tobias2:49:18

Like how many accidents have been caused in the past bit, particularly around the stretch that Councilor Brown's referring to by um vehicles leaving, and really that's gonna happen anyway, but really interfering with the other lane of traffic uh for uh frequency and and numbers.

Paul Hurst2:49:44

Thank you, Councilor Brown, for that uh that motion.

Paul Hurst2:49:47

Um I I'll get those numbers for you.

Paul Hurst2:49:49

I spoke with my director of engineering.

Paul Hurst2:49:51

He put me onto the ICBC data website, which is all public accessible information.

Paul Hurst2:49:56

The numbers, the numbers are quite the number of accidents, um, property damage or injury accidents between in the View Royal section is quite high.

Paul Hurst2:50:05

Um it doesn't break it down, it does break it down into uh property only damage where either we're not called or they they hit a deer, or there's an injury accident.

Paul Hurst2:50:14

But the numbers, the numbers in that section are disproportionately high.

Sid Tobias2:50:18

And and that would likely, you know, if we had, and it's happened a couple of times where somebody's jumped the median there, uh, that's closed it down on both sides pretty much, hasn't it?

Paul Hurst2:50:29

It does.

Paul Hurst2:50:29

The the the inconvenience of the the motoring traffic going north and south, it shuts the highway down.

Paul Hurst2:50:36

And that is one of the only links to Up Island.

Paul Hurst2:50:38

So when we have an accident down there and we close it for 20, 30 minutes, you'll see the traffic back deep into Victoria and all the way up into the Malahat.

Sid Tobias2:50:46

Okay, thank you for that.

Sid Tobias2:50:48

Um buddy got questions or comments before we oh uh Councillor Rogers, you certainly get a chance to motivate.

John Rogers2:50:54

Yes, uh the um as as um uh she first mentioned, this is uh I think the one-strip stretch where uh unique to uh to view oil and part of Langford where uh there's grassy medium without any any barriers.

John Rogers2:51:09

And so that's this is um uh well the grassy strip works, it needs to work better.

John Rogers2:51:14

And that's what we're proposing.

John Rogers2:51:15

And I think particularly given um again the geography where this is a long curve down a hill and uh rainy conditions, it it's uh it the whole setup is requiring additional work.

Sid Tobias2:51:30

Any other questions, comments?

Sid Tobias2:51:32

I think this is a no-brainer.

Sid Tobias2:51:34

Uh all those in favor of councillor Brown's motion.

Sid Tobias2:51:38

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:51:39

Seeing none opposed, motion carries.

Sid Tobias2:51:42

I think this brings us to a closed meeting resolution.

Sid Tobias2:51:45

Eleanor, do you want to read out the closed meeting?

Elena Bolster2:51:50

That there is a need to have a meeting closed to the public and persons other than the immediate members of council, officers, and employees of the town, and those identified under section 912 of the community charter shall be excluded on the basis of section 91e land and k municipal service thank you elna and can i get a uh motion to adjourn please so moved second moved by counselor lemon seconded by councillor rogers all those in favor any opposed motion carries thank you sir