Back to Matters
Standing Committee Membership
First seen: February 13, 2024
Last seen: February 20, 2024
Lifecycle Timeline
February 20, 2024Council
Full RecordingStanding Committee Membership - Councillor MacKenzie
A motion seeking to introduce guiding principles for diversity in committee appointments failed, with opponents citing the Mayor's prerogative for standing committees.
"Councillor MacKenzie advocated strongly for implementing guiding principles on inclusivity and diversity for all committee appointments, including Standing Committees. The Mayor and other Councillors opposed the motion, citing that selecting Standing Committee members is the Mayor's prerogative under the Community Charter and worried the motion would fetter the Mayor's discretion or be impractical given low volunteer rates. The motion was defeated."
Formal MotionFailed
"THAT staff develop best practices to assist with the selection of all committee members to ensure a diverse representation of neighbourhoods, demographics, and perspectives."
Moved by: Alison MacKenzie
Seconded by: Damian Kowalewich
Sid Tobias
Don Brown
Damian Kowalewich
Gery Lemon
Alison MacKenzie
Ron Mattson
John Rogers
February 13, 2024Council
Full RecordingStanding Committee Membership - Councillor MacKenzie
"Councillor MacKenzie argued that the recently appointed Standing Committee lacked diversity (e.g., 50% from the same neighborhood, single woman, similar viewpoints). Debate centered on the balance between actively recruiting diverse perspectives and appointing qualified volunteers, especially given the rapid formation required for the housing legislation committee. Mayor Tobias and other Council members expressed support for the principle going forward, but noted difficulties in volunteer recruitment."
FormITEM(S) TO BE ADDED TO AGENDA - Standing Committee MembershipOtherBackgrounder: Resolution on Best Practices for Standing Committee Selection
Formal MotionPassed
"THAT the Committee recommend to Council that staff develop best practices to assist with the Mayor's selection of standing committee members to ensure a diverse representation of neighbourhoods, demographics, and perspectives."
Moved by: Alison MacKenzie
Seconded by: John Rogers
Sid Tobias
Don Brown
Damian Kowalewich
Alison MacKenzie
John Rogers