This site is in beta — data may be incomplete and features are still being added.
Back to Meetings

Council Meeting

Tuesday, June 18, 2024
Council
AgendaMinutesVideo
Updated 1 week ago
Connecting to video

Meeting Overview

Council held a meeting focusing heavily on housing, development approvals, and tenant advocacy. Key decisions included the final adoption of the 339, 341, and 345 Island Highway rezoning and approval of the associated height variance (6 stories). Council also adopted zoning bylaws necessary for implementing Small-Scale, Multi-Unit Housing (SSMUH) provincial legislation. The majority of the evening was dedicated to hearing from residents of Christie Point regarding the proposed 'Additional Rent Increase for Capital Expenditures' (ARIC), resulting in three separate motions passed under New Business advocating to TAPS, the Minister of Housing, and UBCM to address the impacts of the provincial legislation.

Key Decisions

  • To take a brief recess.
  • Adopted the rezoning for the Island Highway development.
  • Adopted zoning amendments to implement provincial mandates for small-scale multi-unit housing.
  • Adopted OCP amendments to regulate the appearance and form of new SSMUH and garden suites.
  • Approved the requested variance to allow the Island Highway development to increase height to 6 storeys (20.7m) in exchange for preserving greenspace.
29
Agenda Items
25/25
Motions Passed
2h 37m
Duration
32
Participants

Transcript

1278 segments
Sid Tobias0:00

And I'll call the uh Town of View Royal Council meeting to order for Tuesday, June 18th, 2024.

Sid Tobias0:11

And that we've read a territorial acknowledgement in the recent uh public hearing.

Sid Tobias0:18

Uh can I get an approval of the agenda, please?

Sid Tobias0:26

Councilor McKenzie, did you have an addition or deletion that you wanted to see or will you second?

Alison MacKenzie0:31

Um no, I had a comment.

Alison MacKenzie0:32

I was just wondering, since we have such a large contingent here, instead of them waiting for the correspondence, I don't know if we can bring it up so that they don't have to listen through the rest of the meeting.

Sid Tobias0:41

We we can certainly do anything council wishes.

Sid Tobias0:45

So if we want to adjust the agenda to move the uh the correspondence issues to the top, uh we can certainly do that.

Sid Tobias0:54

Um supportive of that, Council Roger.

John Rogers0:57

Um, I wonder you were should we if uh we could make it uh right after public participation, giving so those uh I guess well it still would be on the agenda, so yeah, okay.

John Rogers1:08

That's great, thank you.

Sid Tobias1:11

So so what I'd recommend we do is uh after our petitions and delegations, we have it just before the public participation period.

Sid Tobias1:18

Uh and then uh we can go through that and uh I assume most of the folks want to talk about that this evening.

Sid Tobias1:24

Um okay, uh I think we can do that.

Sid Tobias1:29

Um Sarah's not yelling at me, so I think we're good to do that.

Sid Tobias1:33

So with that amendment, uh, do we have a mover and a second?

Sid Tobias1:36

Moved by Councillor McKenzie, seconded by Councilor Matson.

Sid Tobias1:40

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias1:42

Any opposed, seeing none opposed, motion carries.

Sid Tobias1:46

Uh, can I get receipt and adoption of the minutes for the uh June 4th?

Sid Tobias1:52

Adoption.

Sid Tobias1:53

Second.

Sid Tobias1:54

Moved by Councilor Rogers, seconded by Councilor Matson.

Sid Tobias1:57

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias1:59

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:00

Seeing none.

Sid Tobias2:02

Uh motion carries.

Sid Tobias2:04

Um don't have much of a mayor's report tonight except to say that uh I've talked to some residents from Christie Point.

Sid Tobias2:12

I think I understand uh the circumstances around it.

Sid Tobias2:16

I also just want to make it clear that the town is very limited in what it can do, but it can advocate for uh for your cause.

Sid Tobias2:24

As I understand it, this is a uh provincial matter with the residential tenancy board.

Sid Tobias2:31

Um hopefully you've reached out to your member of Legislative Assembly, um uh Mitzi Dean, who has an office in View Royal as well.

Sid Tobias2:41

Um, but Council is is uh has approved a number of apartment buildings, and we're eager to hear your perspective and and learn from your experience.

Sid Tobias2:51

Um and I think with that it brings us down to petitions and delegations.

Sid Tobias2:57

Uh Mary, can I invite you to um provide um your petition for uh uh urban Food Resilience and initiatives society, please.

Mary Brooke3:16

Good evening, Mayor and Council.

Mary Brooke3:17

Thanks for this opportunity to introduce you to the newest gig in town.

Mary Brooke3:22

We're a nonprofit society, Urban Food Resilience Initiative Society.

Mary Brooke3:26

My name is Mary Brooke, and I'm the executive lead for the group.

Mary Brooke3:30

We just started in January and we're excited to be making the rounds of the different municipalities in the West Shore for starters to discuss about how municipalities can foster food resilience, which seems to be more than timely given the economic circumstances that most of us are living in right now.

Mary Brooke3:53

Next slide.

Mary Brooke3:55

So our group is about growing healthy food in urban spaces.

Mary Brooke4:02

And so, you know, we all, if we have a yard, which not everybody does anymore, a lot of people who did like gardening would grow food.

Mary Brooke4:10

But the goal of our organization, the main thrust of it is to advocate that people think about growing food regardless of what sort of housing they're in, and that it also be a process that can be available in commercial and industrial spaces as well.

Mary Brooke4:26

I'll get to that in a minute.

Mary Brooke4:28

So, of course, a key component would be education.

Mary Brooke4:32

We've already got a lot of interest in workshops, courses, and events, and we do information booths about how to grow food.

Mary Brooke4:40

We're not a gardening group per se.

Mary Brooke4:43

I want to emphasize that.

Mary Brooke4:45

We're trying to work at the municipal level to encourage foods, food being developed by people at their in their own homes.

Mary Brooke4:56

The development of urban food garden community gardens is a part something that we contribute to as well.

Mary Brooke5:04

Improvement of regional soils, that's a whole thing we could get into.

Mary Brooke5:07

You know, there's all the talk about the ALR, and if there's land in a park that seems to be arable, people get excited about that.

Mary Brooke5:14

But soil um regeneration and building fresh soil in areas that aren't being gardened right now is um shouldn't be an amazingly new idea.

Mary Brooke5:26

Like the people put soil in their gardens all the time.

Mary Brooke5:29

So seeing that as um sort of more embracing that across urban areas.

Mary Brooke5:35

Um we're speaking to municipalities about that when you have any building permit or development permit that there needs to be um a line item that that requires food growing capacity in in whatever's being built.

Mary Brooke5:52

So whether if for single family that's pretty straightforward, townhomes they still have small yards.

Mary Brooke5:57

When it comes to condos and apartments, that might mean ensuring that the um the buildings have food growing capacity on balconies, like don't just have a bare balcony, but have infrastructure for planting and irrigation that would be safe for the building and be ready and able for people to start growing.

Mary Brooke6:18

And emergency preparedness, and that's in a minute we'll get into the bigger project.

Mary Brooke6:35

Next slide.

Mary Brooke6:38

So as I mentioned, that we're taking a regional lens and facilitating food growing by by households.

Mary Brooke6:47

And in asking that councils that you ensure that all development permits specify suitable requirements for food growing infrastructure.

Mary Brooke6:54

So residential, that's straightforward as we've covered.

Mary Brooke6:58

Industrial, so if a commercial building goes up, there could be vertical gardening indoors.

Mary Brooke7:03

This doesn't have to be in ground.

Mary Brooke7:05

And then also institutional schools and hospitals.

Mary Brooke7:09

Again, a lot of there's been transition in the region to be using local foods in school kitchens, like at Royal Bay High School, they use local food.

Mary Brooke7:18

But to make sure that every new building that is constructed has that capacity as an expectation from the municipality.

Speaker_147:25

Next slide.

Speaker_147:28

Yeah.

Mary Brooke7:32

Okay, so our group launched in January 24 of this year.

Mary Brooke7:36

We've been doing various presentations and booths and workshops, gathering data already.

Mary Brooke7:41

What do people grow?

Mary Brooke7:43

And people are quite excited to provide this.

Mary Brooke7:44

Oh, I grow broccoli and carrots and beans and so on.

Mary Brooke7:47

And we're going to develop a database to see what does grow well in this area or what people like to grow.

Mary Brooke7:53

Our board is presently three people myself, Rob Martin, and Dean Ross.

Mary Brooke7:58

And we're keeping our activity as a board at a really high business level, making these decisions about what sort of projects and grants to apply for and so on, and then engage our volunteers and supporters.

Mary Brooke8:11

And in just six months, we've gathered gathered 75 people now on our list of people who are ready and waiting to be assigned something to do.

Mary Brooke8:21

We've received two municipal grants so far.

Mary Brooke8:23

I want to emphasize we're not asking for anything, there's no financial ask tonight.

Mary Brooke8:28

We've received a grant from the city of Langford, a grant from the District of Souk for two different types of things.

Mary Brooke8:35

And our only ask tonight will be that you respond back to us with the feasibility for the project that we're now going to get into.

Mary Brooke8:43

And I just wanted to mention also collaboration, sorry for the typo there, that we're we see our organization fitting in with existing networks already.

Mary Brooke8:53

So there are already community gardens, food, food distribution networks, local farmers, and suppliers.

Mary Brooke9:02

And by suppliers, I mean more the technical, like solar, for example, for make for supplying energy.

Mary Brooke9:09

Okay, moving along.

Mary Brooke9:11

Next slide.

Mary Brooke9:12

So the municipal um food storage idea that we're bringing forward tonight is that, and we've looked to the royal because of the way you guys are organized as a municipality, as maybe trying this out first, to have emergency storage food storage freezers in a building that would be a nondescript building.

Mary Brooke9:33

And you know, similar to how BC Hydro will have a local generating transformer station, and it looks like a house from the outside.

Mary Brooke9:41

And in there would be a freezer storage of food for real emergencies, not for like the food banks take care of it when people need food, but this would be in the case of earthquake or pandemic, something where the supply chains are completely collapsed.

Mary Brooke9:56

So this would come, and then because this would be a significant financial investment, of course, the suggestion is that there be a learning center or workshop center attached to this, like the front of the building, and the that could be like a rec center revenue generator for the municipality.

Mary Brooke10:15

So you'd have your one-time capital cost, and then it would be part of your municipal facilities budget.

Mary Brooke10:20

And it just so happens today, the provincial government announced something called drift, D R I F.

Mary Brooke10:27

That's the disaster resilience and innovation funding.

Mary Brooke10:30

And the deadline is September 15th for local governments to apply for funding for something precisely like this.

Mary Brooke10:37

Next slide.

Mary Brooke10:40

So if you were to decide to go ahead with that, of course, as you well know, phase one would be land design and construction.

Mary Brooke10:47

So again, when I'm at we're looking for feedback from your municipality as to would you have land for this, would you have capacity to develop a design?

Mary Brooke10:59

There would be then the next step would be collaboration with the food sector to fill the freezer.

Mary Brooke11:04

That could be probably grocery stores working with them, local farmers, and establish a food rotation strategy.

Mary Brooke11:11

And so this is where our group could be contributing as a consulting service to, you know, you'd put out a expression of interest or RFP for that and get people to organize, you know, how to take care of what's in the freezer.

Mary Brooke11:25

And then operate a front-end household resilience activity center, as I mentioned.

Mary Brooke11:29

So, because obviously the use of the freezer is not going to be that often.

Mary Brooke11:35

So you want to make use of your building that you've that you've built.

Mary Brooke11:39

Next slide, please.

Mary Brooke11:43

So this uh we've got a picture of an earthquake there.

Mary Brooke11:47

Um that's the big emergency we're talking about.

Mary Brooke11:50

Um you've probably heard in the news that the big one is like we're 384 years or something since the last one, 324.

Mary Brooke11:57

Um, and um so nobody likes to be frightened about these things, but as you well know, your emergency response um community is very active in well all the municipalities in the region.

Mary Brooke12:10

Um so we would like to fit in with that and work with the first responders um that there be an execution strategy so you know decide when this would be used and then how it would be used and then be responsible to organize the event team that would um be ready if if anything needed to happen so um looking forward to your questions and thank you for hearing our idea thank you mary appreciate it thanks for taking the time out of your evening to come and address council on uh your food initiative uh council Mackenzie please thank you for your presentation so I am aware that we already have a earthquake food storage um kind of container up in in Eagle View, at least.

Alison MacKenzie12:57

I don't know if staff or counselors know more about it.

Alison MacKenzie13:00

I'm not sure whether it's refrigerated, but I was wondering to what extent is the refrigeration kind of the the required requirement.

Mary Brooke13:10

Okay.

Mary Brooke13:10

Well, we did speak to one solar energy provider who you'd probably want to speak to a few that could provide um information.

Mary Brooke13:19

Solar panels.

Mary Brooke13:20

That's why I had the picture of the building with the solar panels to keep your energy costs fairly low and then have a generator in the building that would be used when the the electricity isn't being fed into the system by BC Hydro.

Alison MacKenzie13:35

Sorry, just to uh expand.

Ron Mattson13:37

Uh but is there a need if it's like uh non-perishable goods, or then it might not need that refrigeration okay well the idea is that these are perishable the these are um stemming off from we're growing natural food it's mostly going to be vegetables um and fruit counselor Matson yeah just for simply for space and for cost wouldn't dehydrated foods be much easier to store and less costly you wouldn't have to recycle them etc and anyways it just seems like a better option than having huge freezers that you have to keep rotating the food in the I think that would be a community preference.

Mary Brooke14:22

You know, do you want to rehydrate food?

Mary Brooke14:24

Plus in a serious emergency water for rehydration might be an issue.

Mary Brooke14:29

So I think this this is going hand in hand with the growing of of food and but you know I have point taken.

Sid Tobias14:38

Counselor Lowen please.

Gery Lemon14:40

Thank you.

Gery Lemon14:42

Mary you you don't see this as a strictly a municipal um undertaking you are your you and your colleagues are prepared to work with groups of community people?

Mary Brooke14:57

Definitely the reason we're going to the municipalities is because the the these pro these buildings and properties would be municipal assets.

Mary Brooke15:04

And so we're starting with that but um definitely, you know, I've even mentioned like the provincial grants.

Mary Brooke15:10

I mean, we're it's this is a a provincial, well, this is a across the country issue, really.

Mary Brooke15:15

And uh one of our longer term projects actually is asking, and we've already talked to the both the provincial and federal government about having a food tax food growing credit.

Mary Brooke15:24

So if somebody can prove that they're industrious about growing food on their property, there would be some sort of you know small tax credit.

Mary Brooke15:31

It's an incentive.

Gery Lemon15:33

So if a large group of area residents, like those at Christie Point, wanted to establish perhaps a community garden or get some instruction on how to you know put their patios or their or their their decks or whatever to work, you could help.

Mary Brooke15:54

Yeah, we we would facilitate and advocate for that.

Mary Brooke15:56

Um I would also mention we do have the grant we got from the district of Suk is for a neighborhood pod people we'll pick a couple of streets at a time for people to organize that they can all use their collective lands base and skills to grow food.

Mary Brooke16:12

And so um that would and then that would be um once we have that pilot project done that would be portable to any number of communities.

Mary Brooke16:22

Food that's developed from those sorts of enterprises um there might be some left over to put in the freezer but I mean it's mostly about the psychological resilience as well.

Mary Brooke16:32

That's why we're talking about the we're we're using the word resilience quite specifically that people feel good about the security of having something to eat.

Mary Brooke16:40

You know, might only be for a couple of days but we'll get people through the worst of an emergency.

Mary Brooke16:46

Thank you.

Sid Tobias16:49

Thank you, Mary.

Sid Tobias16:51

Councilor Rogers, please.

John Rogers16:52

Yeah thank you.

Mary Brooke16:53

Uh certainly innovative ideas have um do you know of any places um in BC or throughout Canada that have uh already started uh this kind of initiative no as you well put this is innovative and um this actually stems from my interest in nutrition originally I have a Bachelor of Science in nutrition which had a very strong community education component and this was long ago, but we were already talking about how does a family that's on a tight budget uh do well.

Mary Brooke17:21

And and I think that the time has come.

Mary Brooke17:23

I think there's been no resistance to this, the ideas of what we're talking about.

Mary Brooke17:27

And I think that's because of the times we're living in with economic um challenges to every household.

John Rogers17:33

If I may another question.

John Rogers17:45

I'm part of the Regional Water Supply Commission and the initiative in the last three years to build blue hydrants, install blue hydrants throughout the region.

John Rogers17:55

So with the drop kits and and the mobility uh hardware, if you like, infrastructure, so that uh when there is an earthquake, um people can go to places like uh Canadian Tyre and hook into the blue hydrant, uh drop kits would be available, and the distribution of water would be available to residents.

John Rogers18:13

So the CRD's already taken that initiative on one side that is an essential water, um, it is also doing a great deal of work in terms of food resiliency and food security.

John Rogers18:23

So I I would encourage you to approach uh the CRD on the emergency services.

Speaker_Unknown18:29

Okay.

John Rogers18:30

That was just a 911 call.

John Rogers18:34

Um at any rate, um, I strongly suggest you go to the CRD, and I I think it's a worthwhile pitch to make.

Mary Brooke18:41

Thank you.

John Rogers18:42

Thank you.

Mary Brooke18:42

Okay.

Mary Brooke18:43

So again, our ask is that you guys maybe consider it as a municipality and um have a staff report or something as the feasibility of having one of these centers.

Sid Tobias18:53

Thank you again, Mary.

Mary Brooke18:54

Thanks.

Sid Tobias18:56

So as uh as promised, we'll um push the correspondence up next before the public participation and uh 10-1 was for action and it was uh two emails dated uh May 30th and June 18th from Jay Ritchie and I Leach.

Sid Tobias19:22

Did anybody want to uh bring them up or receive and then Councilor Mats?

Sid Tobias19:35

And seconded by uh Councilor McKenzie.

Sid Tobias19:38

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias19:41

Um, so that brings us to the public participation period.

Sid Tobias19:47

So if you uh approach the mic, activate it so we can hear.

Sid Tobias19:52

If we could get a bit of a lineup to hear uh your concerns, you have five minutes uh to speak on the issue, and um and just start with your name and where you live.

Conan20:11

Hi, uh I'm Conan.

Conan20:13

Uh I have the privilege of representing the residents of Christie Point today.

Conan20:20

I'm sure if you're familiar, they're a 160 plus unit complex here in View Royal, built in the 60s-ish.

Conan20:31

What we're here for today is there is a the current landlord has applied to impose a fairly significant rent increase of 150 plus dollars a month to select buildings for the repair of the roof.

Conan20:53

This is a new legislation called the ARIC additional rent increase for capital expenditures.

Conan21:02

Which, I mean, to be honest, it's uh it's a tough pill to swallow for people who rent and are expected to pay for a roof that they'll never own.

Conan21:13

If this goes through, it's likely that every single major repair that any building complex in the city, in the region, in the province, is gonna get passed on to the landlords.

Conan21:28

This increase is in addition to the regular annual rent increases, in addition to vacancy increases.

Conan21:36

And as we all know, rents are already prohibitively expensive in the region.

Conan21:42

If you were to rent a two bedroom suite at Christie Point today, the vacant one is $2,450 a month.

Conan21:51

A lot of them don't have a bathroom fan.

Conan21:58

Or a hood fan in the kitchen, or a lot of things.

Conan22:02

Now, we do absolutely understand this is a provincial issue.

Conan22:09

What isn't a provincial issue is who View Royal decides to do business with.

Conan22:30

Community that is taking advantage of vulnerable residents.

Conan22:36

A lot of people don't have the opportunity, don't have the means to move to live anywhere else.

Conan22:44

They're, and they don't want to.

Conan22:47

People shouldn't have to move just because their landlord wants them to pay for absolutely everything.

Conan22:55

So what we're looking for is any sort of support.

Conan22:58

We are we have 150 signatures here from residents against this rent increase.

Conan23:08

We're looking to fight the actual legislation itself because it doesn't make sense.

Conan23:16

The other part of it is it's imposed to pay for a capital expenditure, but it doesn't end.

Conan23:22

The rent increase stays on after the expenditure is paid off.

Conan23:26

So it just you just get the privilege of paying more rent for something you already paid for.

Sid Tobias23:34

Can I ask a question?

Sid Tobias23:36

Um, have you uh sought legal counsel?

Conan23:39

Uh we have spoken to the Tenant Resource Advisory Committee, as well as uh I know some residents have spoken to Together Against Poverty Society seeking legal counsel.

Conan23:52

As we said before, Christie Point residents, a lot of them are fixed income seniors, small families, single parents, don't have the means to afford a lawyer, so we have to find other ways.

Sid Tobias24:10

But yeah, it some of the advocacy societies have been forthcoming and offering help so how can we help you knowing that we don't um we don't make the legislation uh and we can we honestly can't regulate uh how that um what businesses use that legislation within the town because that's so how can how can council help you out if we in the best case scenario what can we do council can advocate for us um with the provincial legislation with the support of council, if we take a motion to our MLAs and the housing minister and the residential tenancy branch with the backing of council supporting that this legislation unfairly targets tenants, it may help us have a little backing.

Sid Tobias25:07

And uh are you aware of this legislation for your networks being utilized anywhere else in Victoria?

Conan25:14

Uh not in Victoria that I know of.

Conan25:17

I'm sure there are oh, there we go.

Conan25:18

Yep.

Conan25:21

Yeah.

Speaker_1425:22

Pacific Village.

Speaker_1725:42

Okay.

Speaker_1725:43

Who's next?

Speaker_1725:43

Your time is up.

Speaker_1725:44

But thank you for for questions.

Matthew Arnold25:57

So another thing I would like to add.

Matthew Arnold25:59

So my name is Matthew Arnold.

Matthew Arnold26:00

I'm a resident at uh Christie Point in Willow.

Matthew Arnold26:03

Moved, thank you.

Matthew Arnold26:04

Uh moved there last summer.

Matthew Arnold26:06

Um another thing I would like uh to make the council aware to fight on our advocate is um at least in our building, we have 15 units.

Matthew Arnold26:17

One person is apparently moving out.

Matthew Arnold26:20

So instead of dividing that cost by 15 units, they are effectively billing only the 14 units.

Matthew Arnold26:27

And when you are an owner of a property and a unit is not rented out, that burden falls on the owner of the property, not the remaining tenants.

Matthew Arnold26:37

And that's all I would like to add.

Speaker_1426:40

Thank you.

Speaker_0527:05

And when I moved in, I cannot recall the name of the real estate investment team that owned the property at the time, but they were nearly begging us to move in, proming promising us.

Speaker_0527:21

No, it was after boardwalk and before RealStar.

Speaker_Unknown27:25

No.

Speaker_0527:29

Okay.

Speaker_0527:29

Here's, here's, here's, there we are.

Speaker_0527:32

Um Lynn Cheryl, I think her name were.

Speaker_0527:37

At any rate, we were uh nearly, I don't want to say begged, but we were basically warned that we would likely not be living there within a year.

Speaker_0527:49

We were told that our moving expenses would be covered, and that our uh transfer of any of our services would be uh covered, and that right, we were really taking our own risk to move into this building because the intention was to sell and redensify.

Speaker_0528:13

And uh it was sold, purchased by RealStar.

Speaker_0528:17

I believe, sorry, no, no, it was RealStar.

Speaker_0528:21

I believe her name was Heather Wolf Gray or Gray Wolf that stood in this room a few years ago with all their very specific and beautifully presented drone coverage and very detailed how gorgeous these units were.

Speaker_0528:41

While they tripled or quadrupled the density, they did not take into consideration any of the issues of um buses and safety and accessibility to but um real star certainly knew what they purchased, they were very convinced, um as as was Boardwalk when I moved in 2017, that this was a done deal.

Speaker_0529:07

It's a building that was built in 1963 and it is at the end of its life.

Speaker_0529:16

They did not uh and then quickly sold to kill them.

Speaker_0529:20

I will say I sold real estate in the early 2000s, and at that time it was in Alberta, not in bc um but i got a real lesson in um what they call reserve funds and reserve fund studies and while that may be very specific to a strata and an owner occupied building um i will suggest that a real estate investment company when they come in uh they know what they're buying they certainly have had uh uh assessment what's the word i'm looking for where they have looked at the life of the roof.

Speaker_0530:03

They have looked at the life of the paint.

Speaker_0530:05

They have looked at the life of a boiler.

Speaker_0530:08

They have looked at the life of a sewer.

Speaker_0530:10

And all of that was failing back in 2017.

Speaker_0530:15

How on earth can us as tenants be responsible to pay for their investment?

Speaker_0530:23

My husband and I have had a chat.

Speaker_0530:27

If that's put in a kilom investment and uh part of the uh ownership because what they're asking for, in my opinion, is a co-op ownership.

Speaker_0530:37

And uh I'm offended.

Speaker_0530:40

I'm offended and I'm sorry.

Speaker_1730:43

I pushed the button.

Speaker_1430:49

Thank you.

Speaker_0930:55

I want to speak as a tenant of 13 plus years at Christie Point.

Speaker_0931:03

There are people here who have, and we know of people who have lived for 35 years or more at Christie Point.

Speaker_0931:13

We consider this our home, and it was where we intended to spend the rest of our lives, hopefully.

Speaker_0931:23

Our concern is that there is no evidence that Killum, or even Real Star was carrying out routine annual maintenance of roofs and other parts of the system.

Speaker_0931:46

To my knowledge, we have flat roofs, and so whether it was shells or there are a lot of big old trees on the property, so there was all kinds of branches and everything landing on the top.

Speaker_0931:59

Those were not cleaned, the drain pipes weren't cleaned out, they were plugged with cones and stuff.

Speaker_0932:04

They've never been cleaned out.

Speaker_0932:06

So the water backs up onto the roof.

Speaker_0932:09

And my comment is if you don't look after your own property that you own and hopefully want to make a profit from, why is it right for you to go to the people that help you make a living to pay for something that you did not look after?

Speaker_2632:24

That's my concern um I've been there for over 20 years now very happily um and I did um own houses before I came out west and I just want to double check that when you buy a house in BC you are supposed to do due diligence is that correct so due diligence was then never done or he would have been they would have been told that nothing had been done to nothing big has ever been done uh since I have been there and um the other thing is that they asked us to they've asked for the us to pay for the road and um sort of an interesting situation because um it was a dreadful job a dreadful job and I remember asking the rental manager when it's the potholes came back up within a year uh could he not call back whoever did it you know and say you didn't do a good job and um no no we couldn't call these people but presumably because they were, of course, the cheapest guy uh and so they won't do anything.

Speaker_2633:50

So we've been asked to pay for the road and for the entry into um Hemlock and in in Hemlock.

Speaker_2633:58

So I'm sort of supposing now as we go along, when we've paid for the road, can we put a toll road on both sides of Hemlock so that people are not going over roads that we've paid for?

Speaker_2634:18

And that would include Prime, Canada Mail, whatever.

Speaker_2634:23

I'm just supposing.

Speaker_2634:25

But the residents, oh obviously the residents, yeah, because only certain people have been asked to pay for this total thing.

Speaker_2634:35

And I guess in a way that maybe you can't help us, that perhaps you could offer a little guidance and thank you for listening.

Speaker_1734:45

Thank you.

K. White34:53

Hi, my name's Alison White, and I also live on Christie Point.

K. White34:56

What I do have to bring up to you is relevant to something to do with you because you brought in the tenant assistance program.

K. White35:02

Fantastic for rezoning future ones.

K. White35:05

We're rezoned when they've nickel and dimed us all out of Christie Point, what happens to us?

K. White35:11

So I've actually emailed twice and had no response from staff regarding that question.

K. White35:16

So I would like um some answers to that in the future, please.

Sid Tobias35:21

So what just to be clear, your question is what happens now that it's not developed, right?

Sid Tobias35:27

And it was rezoned to be a bigger thing.

Sid Tobias35:29

Well, the rezoning sticks to it.

Sid Tobias35:30

It was the increase in density.

Sid Tobias35:32

What happens with that?

K. White35:36

No, I understand it sticks, but what I'm saying is when somebody chooses to redevelop it, now it's rezoned and can have greater density, the tenant assistance program doesn't apply to us because it's already happened.

Sid Tobias35:51

Oh, I I see what you're saying.

Sid Tobias35:53

So that yeah, the the the it wouldn't apply to you in that because they're it came in after the rezone.

Sid Tobias35:59

Correct.

K. White35:59

Yeah.

K. White36:00

Yeah.

K. White36:00

So what security do we have as tenants once they've nickeled and dimed us out completely?

K. White36:07

The p some people that can't afford to stay through these additional rent increases, and then everybody else that's left when they decide, oh, we're gonna knock down these buildings because they're definitely we can't repair them anymore, and we can't make you pay for them anymore.

K. White36:14

So we're gonna redevelop it.

K. White36:20

You've got no tenant assistance program to help you because it's not in place.

K. White36:24

It came in after.

Sid Tobias36:26

Uh I think uh there's some clarity on that and would go from when it uh the it's actually approved.

Sid Tobias36:34

So it's gone through rezoning, but yeah, I think it really kicks in for construction.

Sid Tobias36:40

Leanne, can you help me out on that one?

Leanne Taylor36:42

Uh through um Mayor Tabais.

Leanne Taylor36:44

And actually, can I cut your name first?

Leanne Taylor36:46

Because I want to go back to you mentioned you emailed the town.

K. White36:50

Yeah, I emailed twice.

Leanne Taylor36:51

You have to Alison White.

Leanne Taylor36:53

Okay.

Leanne Taylor36:53

I'm just gonna write your name down just to s go back to see if I could yeah, track down that email and and send a formal response to you.

Leanne Taylor36:59

Um, but um I'll provide a verbal response right now as well.

Leanne Taylor37:06

So at the time of rezoning of Christie Point, um, there was a covenant that was registered on title that secured tenant assistance.

Leanne Taylor37:15

And that uh was done when the the land was rezoned several years ago.

Leanne Taylor37:20

So it kicks in when uh the property owner applies for a building permit.

Leanne Taylor37:27

So they will have to demonstrate that they have provided tenant assistance to the tenants that have been affected by the um the demolition and would have to be relocated.

Leanne Taylor37:39

So that has been secured in a covenant.

K. White37:41

Thank you.

K. White37:42

That's the answer that I was looking for because I was scared if they don't that didn't exist, what was going to happen next.

K. White37:47

So I appreciate you putting that in place.

Sid Tobias37:49

Thank you.

Sid Tobias37:49

And and since that time as well, council did pass a policy to provide a similar uh reassurance for tenants being uh displaced because of uh redevelopment.

Sid Tobias38:04

Um there are others that would like to address council.

Sid Tobias38:08

There's no limit.

Sid Tobias38:09

You can all talk.

Sid Tobias38:10

Go ahead, sir.

Speaker_0338:12

Thank you, Mayor.

Speaker_0338:13

Thank you, counselors, for giving us the time of day and evening.

Speaker_0338:18

Um there was a very specific idea that I that came to my mind in terms of how you could advocate for for the tenants, and it has to do with one of the regulations that the uh residential tenancy branch is having to enforce or administer.

Speaker_0338:37

And that regulation requires that whatever capital expenditures have been totaled up would be amortized over a period of 10 years.

Speaker_0338:52

And so this roof, which represents 80 per 88% of the of the uh the uh expenditures of the capital expenditures, uh the uh roadway work, the paving work represents 12 percent.

Speaker_0339:09

Um and and so this is specifically with uh the building I'm residing in, which I've been residing in for over 12 years, the uh address being 2951 Craigowan.

Speaker_0339:21

Uh in that building, um the roofing uh hasn't been done in 62 or whatever years since the building was was erected.

Speaker_0339:33

There's just been a little bit of patchwork done over the years.

Speaker_0339:38

I've personally requested uh that some problems be addressed in terms of the roofing, and nothing was ever actually done about it.

Speaker_0339:47

And uh I have some emails and so forth to back that up.

Speaker_0339:52

Um in any case, uh a roof that has served the building for 60 years is now going to be the cost of repairing it is being amortized over 10 years.

Speaker_0340:09

And I believe that's highly in unfair to put that burden of that cost on the uh the small number of tenants occupying this building.

Speaker_0340:25

So I would like to suggest that you could advocate for us in seeking to change that regulation to allow us, for example, to amortize it over, say 50 years, which would be more realistic in terms of how long that this recent roofing repair job is actually going to serve the building that being the case we'd be paying the the the request would not be to raise the rent for 150 dollars a month but a fraction of that amount and that would be uh certainly one consideration that um I think you uh your your input would be uh beneficial thank you thank you for that I should reiterate that I really appreciate your giving us an audience with the Royal Town Council.

Speaker_1941:33

The absurdity of a rental contract resulting in capital cost contributions is it's it's ludicrous.

Speaker_1941:47

If I rented a car and you know drove it, returned it in the condition I I rented it in, and then got a bill for the tires that it had two years before, that would be insane.

Speaker_1942:04

This is a 60-year-old building that the current tenants are being asked to pay the deferred maintenance costs.

Speaker_1942:14

This is this is ridiculous.

Speaker_1942:17

It doesn't matter that the BCNDP passed a law that says this is acceptable.

Speaker_1942:27

This is an end around.

Speaker_1942:29

This law that allows Christie Point and other real estate investment trusts to essentially renovict their tenants.

Speaker_1942:41

It's an end around.

Speaker_1942:44

So my beautiful wife spoke earlier.

Speaker_1942:48

We signed on uh seven years ago.

Speaker_1942:52

And so our rent, if we moved out tomorrow, the rent for the place we're in would increase by $1,300 a month.

Speaker_1943:02

There is no incentive with no renovations, no maintenance, no nothing.

Speaker_1943:08

So I know a lot of the people that are in the buildings that are affected by this.

Speaker_1943:14

I'm not in an affected building, but I feel passionately that a rental agreement, you rent a house, you rent a property, you rent it because you don't want to take on the maintenance costs.

Speaker_1943:31

That is the entire if if there is an advantage to being a renter, it's if if if if there is one advantage to being a renter, it's that you don't own a bolt inner, right and you know the dishwasher breaks that's your landlord's cost so it's just an absurdity right um if you bought a plane ticket you you know you're you're getting a service that's what renting is it's a service it's it's you know and you agree to occupy your seat and when the time comes leave your seat the airline doesn't send you a bill two years later because the plane needed maintenance.

Speaker_1944:20

That's not how it works so um that's that's more or less my point is like this this like and so I think the people here from Christie Point would like for the council from View Royal to say to the morons in the legislature, this is impossibly stupid.

Speaker_1944:49

And this is yet another turn of the screw.

Speaker_1944:53

It is it's it's obscene, and it and it just can't continue.

Speaker_1944:57

I think that you people I I I genuinely feel that you people are listening to us.

Speaker_1945:02

We're registering with you.

Speaker_1945:04

This is this is the thin edge of the wedge.

Speaker_1945:07

And if these real estate investment trusts are allowed to defer costs and pass them down and do this passive rent eviction, a lot of these people that I've met have had tears in their eyes telling me that their rent going up by $150 a month to repair a roof that they didn't live under for 40 years of its existence.

Speaker_1945:33

This is a deal breaker for them.

Speaker_1945:35

Like this is really a deal breaker.

Speaker_1945:38

When we moved into Christie Point, it was they the real star was deliberately suppressing the rents because they wanted to push through the rezoning.

Speaker_1945:48

They're saying, Oh, we can't get market rates for this place.

Speaker_1945:52

And it was an utter falsehood, and it served their narrative.

Speaker_1945:58

This I think I think you counselors can advocate for the people of View Royal and really look like stars.

Speaker_1946:07

If you go to bat for us against the provincial government on this, on this issue, this is nonsensical.

Speaker_1946:16

It really is.

Speaker_1946:17

Thank you.

Speaker_Unknown46:51

Thank you.

Annika Fairholm46:59

Hello, Council.

Annika Fairholm47:01

My name is Annika Fairholm.

Annika Fairholm47:02

I am another renter at Christie Point, who would have guessed.

Annika Fairholm47:05

And I will be, I will have been living there for five years this summer.

Annika Fairholm47:10

I want to echo a lot of the points that my other speakers have mentioned today in, but by bringing my perspective on the uh provincial legislature as in specific, in the fact that rental uh the cap on how much rent could be raised each year was an intentional step to protect the tenant and address the rising cost of living in major cities such as Victoria, which um, if I'm not wrong, is the third most expensive city to live in in Canada at this point.

Annika Fairholm47:41

And um the uh ability for the expect the expectation for um the landlords, as we have established, is to maintain the property in which they have ownership.

Annika Fairholm47:55

And as we have mentioned, the uh the tenancy is a rental, you have you're not gaining benefits from the increased property values.

Annika Fairholm48:04

You are um as soon as you move out, they can increase the rent of a unit to market value once again, regardless of the rent cap.

Annika Fairholm48:13

Um, and the ability for them to pass on the cost of repairs, which they are already expected to be providing just as a basic insurance to the tenant.

Annika Fairholm48:25

It is expected that the maintenance of the property will be maintained, that this will be a suitable place of living.

Annika Fairholm48:31

And in order to pass on those expenditures to the tenant, is as has been mentioned, a circumnavigation circumnavigation of that rental cost.

Annika Fairholm48:39

I don't know if there is any limit to the amount of uh cost that can be implemented in this go around, but it effects effectively negates the benefits that we tenants gain from the cap on uh on rent every year.

Annika Fairholm48:56

And I just want to point out that um, yeah, as has been mentioned, many of the tenants within Christie Point are seniors on a fixed income, are young families with children.

Annika Fairholm49:07

Uh, myself, I am a university student already dealing with over $20,000 of student debt.

Annika Fairholm49:13

Um, and as soon as I get a job, I'll finally be able to have a living wage in Victoria.

Annika Fairholm49:18

And so I would like to urge the council not necessarily to oppose the uh the provincial legislature as a whole, but just to address the blatant inequalities and the lack of insurance that we as tenants have in securing our future within uh the province as a whole, or at least within the Greater Victoria area.

Annika Fairholm49:40

Thank you.

Speaker_0149:55

I wanted to thank the council for the opportunity to speak here.

Speaker_0149:58

It's really important for us to be heard on this topic.

Speaker_0150:00

It's fantastic that you may be willing to advocate for us.

Speaker_0150:04

I was here in 2017 when Realstar was hoping to redevelop the property.

Speaker_0150:24

It would be impossible for us to stay if we were not able to persist on the lower rent that we've been grandfathered in on.

Speaker_0150:29

And there are specific provisions in the covenant for long term residence.

Speaker_0150:36

This concerns me because it feels like we might not be able to access those provisions and might be renovicted in a different way than is relevant to the covenant before they decide to properly redevelop the property.

Speaker_1450:49

Thank you.

Sid Tobias51:00

And that's why council moved I guess it was almost a year ago now to uh try to push uh for uh at least a a council policy that we would um uh and we can afford it to you if you would like to leave us your email and and you could distribute uh but it's probably similar to the package uh that was initially proposed and that would uh allow uh funds to compensate based on the length of time that you've lived in the residence uh relocation services if possible um but it's hard right I get it I I started out here as a young sailor making uh 14,000 a year the below the poverty line uh and it it seemed like it was yesterday, but it was 30 years ago now.

Sid Tobias51:50

Um and and you know, I survived my first little bit by having older places to to rent like you guys are in now.

Sid Tobias51:58

Now I will say this much, Christie Point is probably the most beautiful part of Uroil.

Sid Tobias52:04

Um it it uh if somebody was to ask me why it hasn't been developed, I think Council Rogers brought to my attention the uh sea level rise predictions over the next 50 years.

Sid Tobias52:16

Christie Point is gonna be three islands essentially in 50 years.

Sid Tobias52:21

Uh so it it's gonna be, you know, difficult, and that's probably one of the things weighing on a large bit of investment.

Sid Tobias52:28

Um so I I think council has heard you tonight.

Sid Tobias52:31

I think all of us are are feeling a little helpless ourselves for two reasons.

Sid Tobias52:37

One is uh the the the power to make these decisions is not our are at our level yet it's affecting directly the residents that we uh that that that vote for us that participate in these uh elections um uh so I I think that that's where my concern is now we'll what will happen now after we've heard from you all is we'll go away and likely talk about this under new business um and whether we we will advocate for you um I I'm pretty sure that that's going to be supportive um and and uh it would determine the level of that.

Sid Tobias53:19

Um the other thing we can also do is is the the level of advocacy that we can do not only to the legislation uh or to the to the legislature here in BC, we can also use venues through um through the federal uh union of municipalities as well as the uh BC Union of Miss Municipalities uh to exercise that.

Sid Tobias53:42

I would strongly encourage that you um speak to the MLA.

Sid Tobias53:47

Ironically, this is an election year.

Sid Tobias53:49

It's surprising what happens during election years, especially this close to them.

Sid Tobias53:54

Um so I I would I would uh very much encourage you to do that.

Sid Tobias53:58

The other thing I would encourage you to do, if you haven't thought about it already, is uh it's probably a story that would have great media interest.

Sid Tobias54:07

Right, right?

Sid Tobias54:08

And and uh a number of perspectives.

Sid Tobias54:11

Uh during the day I have a different job uh and and I work for the provincial government on environmental assessments.

Sid Tobias54:18

And one of the hardest things to do is when you're a decision maker and preparing issues for decision makers is to find out what that thing really impacts you as people, as humans.

Sid Tobias54:33

Like uh, like what does that proposal do?

Sid Tobias54:36

So thank you tonight for doing an absolutely brilliant job of helping us understand because I think it is.

K. White54:52

Thank you, counselors, for your time.

K. White54:53

My name's Jeff White.

K. White54:54

I'm also another Christie Point resident.

K. White54:56

Um, I just want to point out that your advocacy will go a lot farther than the word of one of us when it comes to the provincial level.

K. White55:05

So it would be very appreciated and thank you if we could have that.

Speaker_1755:15

Councilor Rogers.

Speaker_1455:17

So uh we're gonna be adding um uh the Christie Point matter on to new business uh for a motion.

Speaker_1455:22

Okay.

Speaker_1455:26

Thanks, folks.

Speaker_1755:31

You can stick around for an exciting night of bylaws if you want to, but if you got better things to do, then we understand.

Speaker_1455:42

Oh, five-minute break.

Sid Tobias55:46

Council, can I get a motion for a five-minute uh bio break?

Sid Tobias55:50

Some of moved by counselor rogers, second by counselor every in favor by everybody.

Sid Tobias55:56

So I think where we left off council was the public participation.

Sid Tobias56:01

And uh on the topic of Christie Point, we had many uh representations.

Sid Tobias56:07

So I think that brings us to eight, which is bylaws, and we have three of them in front of us.

Sid Tobias56:16

Uh staff, did you want to introduce these?

Sid Tobias56:20

These are at I think first.

Sid Tobias56:27

Yeah.

Leanne Taylor56:28

Oh through the mayor.

Leanne Taylor56:30

Um, 2014 amendment bylaw number 1128, 2023 for the properties at 339, 341, and 345 Island Highway is on for final adoption.

Speaker_1756:44

Move adoption.

Sid Tobias56:48

Mover and uh seconder uh any questions for staff or comments seeing how it's uh been dealt with.

Sid Tobias56:56

I would think it would be rare.

Speaker_1757:01

Motivation.

John Rogers57:04

Indeed, uh, we've um we've uh and it's this is this simply a uh uh change in the zoning to um uh mixed residential, so in in support of that.

Don Brown57:14

Seems like a long time coming, but thank goodness we're there.

Don Brown57:15

Councilor Brown?

Sid Tobias57:21

Council McKenzie, you had a comment or question?

Alison MacKenzie57:23

Oh just to clarify, were were we moving 8A through C?

Alison MacKenzie57:27

Or were we doing that?

Sid Tobias57:28

Uh just one at a time, seeing how they're uh I I didn't think they'd get passed, so I wouldn't I I didn't move them.

Sid Tobias57:34

So we're just talking about uh Alpha, which was the um zoning bylaw with respect.

Sid Tobias57:40

Now you'll see this same uh property, I believe, come up under the variant section later on in the agenda, but we're just dealing with this one as was passed before.

Sid Tobias57:54

Um any other comments or questions?

Sid Tobias57:58

Uh all those in favor uh to amend the zoning bylaw with respect to 339, 341, and 345 Island Highway.

Sid Tobias58:07

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias58:09

Uh all those opposed.

Sid Tobias58:12

Uh noted that councillor Matson and Mayor Tobias opposed.

Sid Tobias58:16

Uh motion carries.

Sid Tobias58:19

Um that brings us down to zoning bylaw 900.

Sid Tobias58:24

Land.

Leanne Taylor58:27

By law, uh a bylaw, pardon me, I'll start that again.

Leanne Taylor58:30

Uh zoning bylaw number 900, 2014, amendment bylaw number 1135, 2024 is to introduce the small-scale multi-unit housing zoning regulations and it's on for final adoption.

Leanne Taylor58:44

This is to meet Bill 44 housing legislation.

Sid Tobias58:51

Thank you, Lynn.

Sid Tobias58:52

Do I have a move or move adoption?

Sid Tobias58:54

Second or move by Councillor Lemon and seconded by Councilor Mattson.

Sid Tobias58:59

Um motivations.

Gery Lemon59:05

We have to do this and we have a deadline.

Gery Lemon59:07

And um if we and if we uh don't pass this tonight, um we'll be further up on the province's naughty list.

Sid Tobias59:18

Always concerned about Tucla and Elephants, Councilor Lemon.

Ron Mattson59:22

Uh Councillor Mattson.

Ron Mattson59:24

Yeah, I I agree with a lot that that gentleman said this evening.

Ron Mattson59:28

But as my colleague said, we have to do this.

Ron Mattson59:32

And uh I think we did a good job at mitigating the types of things that he'd mentioned.

Ron Mattson59:36

And so as unhappy as I am about having this forced upon us, I think where we ended up was as best we can given the situation.

Ron Mattson59:46

So I will be supporting.

Sid Tobias59:48

Thank you.

Sid Tobias59:49

Further comments?

Sid Tobias59:51

Council McKenzie.

Alison MacKenzie59:53

I'll be voting in opposition to this change purely because of the maximum floor area for a site standard and the fact that uh regardless of the lot size, um I wasn't going to repeat all my arguments, but I feel like it's it would be useful for people listening in, maybe for the first time.

Alison MacKenzie1:00:13

Um so I I just don't think that this is necessary first of all to set a floor space um floor area maximum because we have many other mechanisms to ensure that new buildings do not negatively impact our neighbors and and the trees.

Alison MacKenzie1:00:31

So first it's unnecessarily inflexible.

Alison MacKenzie1:00:34

But there's also I believe unintended consequences it's going to discourage the building of houses that are long term homes.

Alison MacKenzie1:00:44

If we have a floor area that is sparse, no one is going to want to build homes that have larger rooms to be accessible for wheelchair users.

Alison MacKenzie1:00:56

And families are going to have to move out if they want to take up any outdoor activities, because we've said garage space is including that.

Alison MacKenzie1:01:04

So where are people going to store their snowboards, paddleboards, bikes?

Alison MacKenzie1:01:08

I also anticipate that it will contribute visually to greater impact and density, contrary to the intention.

Alison MacKenzie1:01:17

And this is because it doesn't make sense for a developer to purchase the largest lot in a site standard package when they're restricted to a build the same floor area as they would in the smallest lot in that site standard package.

Alison MacKenzie1:01:35

So all the smaller lots will be where these SMUS, these smaller uh homes are built.

Alison MacKenzie1:01:43

And therefore, where you already have density and less green space, there's going to be even less by uh implementing this floor floor area maximum.

Sid Tobias1:01:58

Thank you, Councillor Mackenzie.

Sid Tobias1:02:00

Councilor Brown.

Don Brown1:02:02

Yeah, I like the idea.

Don Brown1:02:03

It gives people more of an opportunity to for entry-level housing.

Don Brown1:02:07

Um, you know, particularly older people like my friends are downsizing.

Don Brown1:02:12

I think it's going to provide some opportunities.

Don Brown1:02:14

I don't I can't see hundreds and hundreds of applications for these types of building.

Don Brown1:02:19

I think I can see some of them.

Don Brown1:02:20

I know some that are coming to council soon would be very would fit quite nicely.

Don Brown1:02:25

I won't mention the properties themselves, but um I think it's a good a good start.

Sid Tobias1:02:32

Councilor Brown, anything else?

Sid Tobias1:02:34

Uh so we got a mover and a seconder on the floor.

Sid Tobias1:02:38

Uh all those in favor of zoning bylaw 900 2014.

Sid Tobias1:02:45

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias1:02:47

Noting councillor McKenzie is opposed.

Sid Tobias1:02:49

Motion carries.

Sid Tobias1:02:52

Uh official community plan bylaw 811, Leanne.

Sid Tobias1:02:57

Or actually, it's uh 1139.

Leanne Taylor1:03:00

Yeah.

Leanne Taylor1:03:01

Yeah.

Leanne Taylor1:03:01

Thank you, Mayor Tobias.

Leanne Taylor1:03:03

That's correct.

Leanne Taylor1:03:04

Um, official community plan amendment bylaw number 1139.

Leanne Taylor1:03:09

This is the amendment by the bylaw that is dealing with the amendments to the development permit areas for small-scale multi-unit housing by introducing them into the mixed residential development permit area, as well as introducing a new development permit area intensive residential garden suite.

Leanne Taylor1:03:28

This bylaw is on for third reading and adoption.

Sid Tobias1:03:32

Third and adoption.

Sid Tobias1:03:34

Moved uh by councillor Mutz and seconded by seconded by Councilor Brown.

Sid Tobias1:03:42

Um motivation.

Ron Mattson1:03:46

We've talked about this forever.

Ron Mattson1:03:48

Staff did a great job in terms of this document and um by having a development permit area gives us an opportunity to get staff an opportunity, depending on how we do it, to ensure that the form and character are are appropriate with the neighborhood.

Speaker_171:04:06

Thank you, Councilor Brad.

Don Brown1:04:09

Well written.

Don Brown1:04:10

I support it 100%.

Sid Tobias1:04:12

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:04:13

Uh comments, Councillor Rogers.

John Rogers1:04:17

Yes, I certainly appreciate the quality control uh aspects of uh this bylaw.

John Rogers1:04:22

Um as we were discussing um the question um from the public hearing, um my concern is we're um homeowners will have uh the ability to have a garden suite, a secondary suite, and rent a house.

John Rogers1:04:38

So we will have some interesting challenges, I think, with respect to bylaw, enforcement, noise and um uh uh unkept residences and premises and so forth, those sort of challenges, uh parking as well.

John Rogers1:04:53

Um so it's um we'll I'm voting in in support, but with caution, and I hope that um uh we will be doing due diligence to ensure the the carriage to quality and and respect um of uh assessed property owners in in the community.

John Rogers1:05:11

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:05:15

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:05:15

I d just one comment.

Sid Tobias1:05:17

Will will this have uh second-order effects on the neighborhood?

Sid Tobias1:05:21

It will.

Sid Tobias1:05:22

In my neighborhood, there is one household that uh has uh two kids, adult kids living at home, and they've got a suite, and it displaces seven vehicles to the road every day.

Sid Tobias1:05:29

And uh every house with a suite does the same.

Sid Tobias1:05:36

And and the driveways full too, right?

Sid Tobias1:05:39

So will this have impacts on our communities and parking and walkability and all those?

Sid Tobias1:05:44

There is absolutely no question in my mind.

Sid Tobias1:05:46

However, uh I I am very much in favor of opportunities book garden suites in uh areas, particularly in situations where you've got aging folks that want to want to take care of their house and want to live in something smaller and want the kids to either uh rent the house or somebody else.

Sid Tobias1:06:04

So I I think it it leaves lots of room for that.

Sid Tobias1:06:08

Uh so with that, I think we can push to a vote.

Sid Tobias1:06:12

All those in favor of bylaw 1139.

Sid Tobias1:06:14

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias1:06:14

Any opposed.

Sid Tobias1:06:20

Seeing none opposed, motion carries, and I'll put it over to 91 staff for development variance permit uh 2024.

Sterling Scory1:06:38

Thank you, Mayor Tobias.

Sterling Scory1:06:40

Uh purpose of tonight's uh report and presentation on the development variance permit for 339, 341, and three four five is for consideration of uh the development variance permit.

Sterling Scory1:06:51

Uh the applicant is requesting a total of two variances, and those variances are to increase the total number of stories permitted in the mixed residential land use designation from four to six stories and increase the maximum permitted building height in the RM3 zone mixed residential from 13.5 to 20.7 meters.

Sterling Scory1:07:14

The subject sites 345 uh or sorry, yeah, 339, 341, and 345 Island Highway are shown on the screen in in red uh next to uh the public safety building and uh at the corner of Prince Rapper Drive.

Sterling Scory1:07:32

This is an image showing the uh conceptual rendering of the the site and the uh the proposed building.

Sterling Scory1:07:39

Um it's uh on a corner site across from the uh Fort Victoria and uh as I said is uh cornering on Prince Robert Drive and Island Highway.

Sterling Scory1:07:51

The next images show uh additional uh conceptual renderings of the buildings.

Sterling Scory1:07:57

Uh the top image is a south elevation uh drawing.

Sterling Scory1:08:01

So this would be the uh side yard or uh Hedel Park if you were looking from Hedel Park into the site.

Sterling Scory1:08:10

The bottom image is showing the north elevation.

Sterling Scory1:08:14

This is the uh perspective from Island Highway.

Sterling Scory1:08:19

And the last two images here show a elevation from the west, which is from Prince Robert Drive.

Sterling Scory1:08:24

This would be the front yard based on the definitions and the zoning bylaw, and then the final image on the bottom there is of the east elevation which is taken from uh public safety building or the the fire hall.

Sterling Scory1:08:42

With respect to discussion for this application the proposed building is designed to be built with the natural slope of the site and the design elements incorporated into the design of the building are seeing opportunities for the perceived height of the massing of the building to be reduced given the articulations and stepbacks that are incorporated into the building.

Sterling Scory1:09:04

The total height of the building will be roughly eight meters uh less than the uh the existing uh foundation of the building's uh single family homes located on Prince Robert Drive.

Sterling Scory1:09:17

I've added a bold black line on the screen.

Sterling Scory1:09:21

I'll see if I can get the laser pointer to work.

Sterling Scory1:09:25

And I cannot unfortunately but there's a dark black line showing the uh the bottom uh foundation of the single family homes on Prince Robert Drive in respect to the uh the building uh that's being proposed by the applicant with their height variance um and like I said uh a difference of about eight meters the proposed uh proposed variances can be um can be uh supported by staff because the uh the building is stepped back from the uh the neighboring properties the applicant has the uh worked with the site uh and the slope in consideration of uh how it uh how it slopes up towards Heddel Park and uh that's reflective of the uh the applicant's design and uh in staff's opinion the the total height requested is uh is not going to have a negative impact on the neighboring properties staff's recommendations uh as shown on the screen there's two of them the first is that the development variance permit application be approved um and then the second is that the uh development variance application include the following variances uh the first being the total number of the uh total number of stories permitted uh the m mixed residential land use designation area uh in the official community plan the increase from four to six stories and second that the increase uh of the maximum height be 13.5 meters to 20.7 meters in the RM3 zone mixed residential if there's any questions I can uh answer them uh I'd like to just address council too and just saying that the uh applicant is uh in the audience as well and uh if there's any additional questions that I can't answer they may they may be able to yeah we'll go to questions first uh councilor Lemon thank you um a refresher please sterling or audience um i'm i'm trying i'm trying to it's been a while since we saw the images for this so i'm trying to picture it but it was graduated was it not one of the buildings or both of the buildings were graduated from six to four through the mayor yeah you'll see in the images on the screen there the the uh the building is stepped back from island highway to Heddle Park um the building is uh six I'm thinking about before.

Gery Lemon1:12:08

When we first saw this project at the rezoning stage, was it presented as four stories, four stories going up to six?

Sterling Scory1:12:24

Through the mayor, uh just to clarification, are you talking about the initial application?

Sterling Scory1:12:30

Um, like the the the first version that was presented to council, or are you talking about the what's shown on screen?

Gery Lemon1:12:38

I'm thinking the version around um second third reading.

Sterling Scory1:12:46

For for clarification, then the the images shown on screen are consistent with what was shown as uh part of the public hearing, and there's been no changes to the application or the uh the applicant's drawing since public hearing.

Sid Tobias1:12:59

So n nothing has changed with the application.

Gery Lemon1:13:00

Okay, good.

Gery Lemon1:13:01

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:13:01

Yeah, just uh to clarify, Sterling, that's a good point.

Sid Tobias1:13:07

It's just our process.

Sid Tobias1:13:08

We had to do the rezoning first and then the height variance, but the plan remains the same as presented, correct?

Sterling Scory1:13:15

That is correct, Mayor Tabas.

Sterling Scory1:13:17

Good.

Sterling Scory1:13:17

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:13:19

Any other questions?

Sid Tobias1:13:22

Do I have somebody that would like to move staff's recommendation?

Speaker_091:13:26

So moved.

Sid Tobias1:13:28

Moved by Councillor McKenzie, seconded by Councillor Brown.

Speaker_141:13:39

And no, sorry.

Alison MacKenzie1:13:41

I thought this people were shaking hands.

Alison MacKenzie1:13:44

Um, we heard from the people uh behind this building, and uh they spoke positively about it.

Alison MacKenzie1:13:51

And since this variance is the same as what they would have seen and commented on, um they were very persuasive to me.

Alison MacKenzie1:13:59

So that's why I'm supportive of this.

Don Brown1:14:02

Thank you, Councillor McKenzie, Councillor Brown.

Don Brown1:14:06

Yeah, similar comment.

Don Brown1:14:07

The neighbors in behind uh were fine with it, the original one in the same souns.

John Rogers1:14:16

Yes, likewise, um uh there's uh no no difference uh with what we had seen with the uh uh the public hearing.

John Rogers1:14:23

And I I think uh going back uh recalling um how the applicant had worked uh diligently to to reduce the uh the height of the building uh before coming to public hearing.

John Rogers1:14:34

There was uh I think one level of parking and that got uh um down to two layers, which is uh brought the uh the building heights down considerably.

John Rogers1:14:43

And I don't think we should uh forget the fact that there's gonna be a considerable um uh revenue uh taxation, uh community amenities um uh from this, as well as the uh profound uh covenant that staff and applicant worked on.

John Rogers1:14:58

Uh I can't think of any other um uh proper application of uh of this magnitude that would uh had that that that much uh green space um uh protected.

John Rogers1:15:09

So I I think the only the one thing that um uh you know after this is said and done and assuming that the matter passes uh that I would really encourage staff to um quickly um begin a baseline traffic count uh for the harbor um prince Robert V Wall Avenue Helmakin so forth um to um understand and anticipate if there's uh um any um uh impacts and of increase of traffic but we won't be able to know that unless we have a baseline so um I I would encourage that to happen um if this motion is passed.

Sid Tobias1:15:48

Thank you, Councillor Rogers.

Sid Tobias1:15:50

Any other comments?

Sid Tobias1:15:51

Counselor mutson?

Ron Mattson1:15:53

Yeah, just my colleague, this is a variance to go from four stories to six stories.

Ron Mattson1:16:01

And I just take a look at the building sort of right across the street from Plawrite that's just being built, it's four stories.

Ron Mattson1:16:07

And it's a really big, you know.

Ron Mattson1:16:11

So just think of what that thing's gonna look like up the road with another two stories.

Ron Mattson1:16:16

It's gonna be huge.

Ron Mattson1:16:17

And so, you know, the OCP says four stories along the island highway, and now we're gonna do up to six on this one.

Ron Mattson1:16:25

It's gonna be enormous.

Ron Mattson1:16:27

Uh it's very nice that it doesn't go over top of the hill and the people behind can't see it.

Ron Mattson1:16:32

But everybody who drives past it is going to see this enormous six story building.

Ron Mattson1:16:36

Uh, whether you put four stories in front of it or not, it it really doesn't matter.

Ron Mattson1:16:40

It's the end of the day, it's still six stories.

Ron Mattson1:16:42

So, because of this and because it's a variance to go to six stories I'm not going to be supporting this motion.

Sid Tobias1:16:52

Thank you Counselor Matson uh yeah I'll just uh chime in uh I think the massing and intensity isn't what the OCP um was was designed the corridor to look like at all.

Sid Tobias1:17:06

Uh so I I'm not in support of that and the other part was uh would much rather have seen the first floor as commercial because uh I'm not saying it has to be a tattoo shop, uh counselor Rogers, but it could be a daycare uh or a coffee shop um and and I think we've got to do a better job in in looking at our community's needs and not just for housing to have places for people to actually get the services that they needed are closer nearby.

Sid Tobias1:17:29

Hopefully we can come to an agreement that we do need place here.

Sid Tobias1:17:36

Otherwise they're getting in their car and going somewhere else to do it, uh, which isn't what we want them to do.

Sid Tobias1:17:42

Uh so let's call the vote.

Sid Tobias1:17:45

We got a mover and a seconder.

Sid Tobias1:17:47

Councilor Sir.

Speaker_171:17:49

Oh.

Sid Tobias1:17:49

Sorry, we got you're right.

Sid Tobias1:17:54

Thank you, sir.

Sid Tobias1:17:55

Uh is there any comments from the public on this uh that are in the room first on this development?

Sid Tobias1:18:09

Just uh before you begin, um applicant Sarah, is it uh an opportunity for um the applicant to speak, or is it the public to speak now?

Speaker_141:18:22

Thank you.

Speaker_141:18:23

Go ahead, Mr.

Speaker_141:18:23

Ford.

David Ford1:18:26

Good evening, Mayor, Council.

David Ford1:18:28

My name is Doug Ford.

David Ford1:18:30

I think you all you all know me because we've been through this for the last two years.

David Ford1:18:34

I just wanted to review uh where we are and how we got here.

David Ford1:18:39

We uh made an application to rezone this property to RM3, which is consistent with the 2011 OCP.

David Ford1:18:50

So we weren't looking for anything, even any variances at that point, but it was brought to our attention that council and staff would like us to preserve some green space.

David Ford1:19:06

We've agreed to preserve over one third of the three acres that we have as green space.

David Ford1:19:13

It's been placed into a covenant.

David Ford1:19:16

We cannot build on it, we cannot use property, but we do maintain it.

David Ford1:19:23

In order to preserve one third of the site, we had to reduce what we could use for site coverage, which was 60% of the site could have been covered by buildings if we were going to build four story.

David Ford1:19:35

And we reduced that to 29% and moved to six-story in order to satisfy concerns of staff and council with regard to the green space.

David Ford1:19:45

So we're here looking for this development variance permit in order to allow us to build the building that is very consistent.

David Ford1:19:52

In fact, it's exactly the same building that we presented for the public hearing and that it's just been approved for fourth reading.

David Ford1:20:01

So there are no changes to what we've been working with all the way along.

David Ford1:20:06

Thank you.

Speaker_141:20:08

Any questions?

Speaker_171:20:12

Thank you're gonna ask a question to the uh podium, please.

Speaker_171:20:25

Thank you.

Speaker_041:20:27

Yeah, just asking if the building will have a commercial space underneath, like uh a coffee shop that you said, a little store to provide service for the community.

Speaker_041:20:37

Isn't that what the Viewer Royal would like to see when we build uh when they put up buildings like that?

Speaker_041:20:45

That's my question.

Sid Tobias1:20:47

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:20:47

I I think it's a little bit late for that because now we're in a height variance.

Sid Tobias1:20:50

It was just something that I would like to see.

Sid Tobias1:20:52

Uh, but in the rezoning, uh uh I think it was initially proposed, but but wasn't included in the final one that we did.

Sid Tobias1:21:01

Um anybody else want to ask a question or comment on the proposal?

Speaker_231:21:17

Well, good evening, Mayor and Council.

Speaker_231:21:19

Great to see you again.

Speaker_231:21:20

Thank you so much for all your time and staff as well.

Speaker_231:21:23

It's been a long road.

Speaker_231:21:25

We appreciate the discussions.

Speaker_231:21:37

For clarity, for everybody involved, we wanted to as closely tie what we presented at the public hearing with uh the the full intentions of of uh what we uh envision uh to develop and to build.

Speaker_231:21:52

And so really appreciate uh the possibility to bring those uh two together here.

Sid Tobias1:21:57

And as previously mentioned, it's the exact same plan as what was presented in the the zoning as uh the dvp so thank you so much thank you uh staff we didn't receive any correspondence on this correct i think now we're ready for a vote and we had a mover and uh so the phone right thanks Sarah could see your sign language Carl do we have any comments on the phone on the uh uh for the development variance permit for 339, 341, and 345 Island Highway.

Don Brown1:22:33

Mayor Tobias, we have no callers right now.

Sid Tobias1:22:36

Thanks, Carl.

Sid Tobias1:22:38

Now, Sarah, can we go to a vote?

Sid Tobias1:22:40

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:22:41

Uh so we got a mover and a second, or all those in favor of the variance for height.

Sid Tobias1:22:48

All those opposed.

Sid Tobias1:22:51

Uh noted that uh Mayor Tobias and Councilor Mattson opposed.

Sid Tobias1:22:55

Motion carries.

Sid Tobias1:22:57

Thank you, Council.

Sid Tobias1:22:58

Thank you, staff, and thank you, applicant, uh, for it.

Sid Tobias1:23:02

Uh Chancellor Park Public Engagement, what we heard report.

Sid Tobias1:23:06

Leanne, please.

Sid Tobias1:23:08

I'm assuming it's Leanne.

Sid Tobias1:23:09

It could be anybody, right?

Sid Tobias1:23:11

That's not Leanne.

Speaker_141:23:12

Okay, great.

Leanne Taylor1:23:27

Good evening, Mayor Tobias and members of Council.

Leanne Taylor1:23:32

Before we get into the presentation on the Chancellor Park Playground Engagement, I would like to introduce to you our new community planner, Leah Curtis.

Leanne Taylor1:23:42

I am thrilled to introduce her this evening to you all.

Leanne Taylor1:23:47

Leah has been with us since the end of March, and she prior to joining our team, she was with the town of Asoyez.

Leanne Taylor1:23:56

And Leah has a master's in urban and regional planning from Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario.

Leanne Taylor1:24:02

And we are just delighted to have her part of our team.

Leanne Taylor1:24:05

So now I am going to pass this presentation over to Leah.

Sid Tobias1:24:10

Thanks for joining us, Leah.

Speaker_141:24:12

We're privileged to have you.

L. Curtis1:24:18

Thank you, Mayor Tobias and Council, and thank you, Leanne, for the introduction.

L. Curtis1:24:22

I am very pleased to be here in the town of V Royal.

L. Curtis1:24:27

So as Leanne mentioned, I'm the new community planner, and the purpose of this presentation is to present to council staff's findings from the Chancellor Park Playground Public Engagement.

L. Curtis1:24:38

So in the 2024 capital budget, town allocated funds for construction of a new playground at Chancellor Park.

L. Curtis1:24:48

The proposed updates include universally accessible playground equipment that provides accessible play for all persons and abilities.

L. Curtis1:24:59

Accessible play spaces ensure that everyone can have the opportunity to participate and through the features, materials, and the layouts of the park designed.

L. Curtis1:25:08

So the goal of the public engagement was to raise awareness of the town's plans to update Chancellor Park, inform the community of the town's objectives in converting the existing play structure into a more universally accessible structure, and to obtain feedback from the community as to what they'd like to see in terms of features as well as play structures themselves, like what what type of equipment they'd like to see.

L. Curtis1:25:34

So the community was notified through 350 notices that were hand delivered to the surrounding hospital and eastern gateway neighborhoods.

L. Curtis1:25:43

Posters were placed in various positions around town and information was also posted on the town's website and social media web pages.

L. Curtis1:25:53

All right so the engagement process was undertaken from Monday, May 27th to Sunday, June 9th.

L. Curtis1:26:04

There was a mix of online engagement through a survey and two in-person open houses, the first of which was a drop-in open house held on Wednesday, June 5th at the Eagle Creek Village Quality Foods from 5 p.m.

L. Curtis1:26:18

to 7 p.m.

L. Curtis1:26:19

The second event was held at uh on site at Chancellor Park from 10 a.m.

L. Curtis1:26:26

to 12 on Saturday, June 8th.

L. Curtis1:26:29

Um, and through that, we had a total of 133 responses, 92 of which were um through the online survey, and 41 in the open house.

L. Curtis1:26:43

So I'm going to present to you the overall themes, which were um our findings from the responses that were received, both through the written questions on the online survey as well as what was heard um through the attendance of the open houses.

L. Curtis1:26:57

Uh so for the first participants were supportive of introducing a universally accessible playground equipment.

L. Curtis1:27:03

Um, many envisioned the park space for all ages and accessible levels and hoped that the park would become a destination with multiple activities and or features not exclusive to one type of group.

L. Curtis1:27:16

Survey respondents and attendees at both open houses indicated a preference for climbing structures, in ground trampolines, and swings as the top three playground features, and park furniture being chairs, benches, picnic tables, grassy open spaces, and shaded areas as the top three preferred features of the respondents and attendees.

L. Curtis1:27:38

With a note that they'd like to see more seating arrangements not entirely focused on the playground itself.

L. Curtis1:27:48

Sorry, I missed the last one.

L. Curtis1:27:50

Some respondents also noted that the park's proximity to the galloping goose trail also posed as a safety hazard, and they would have liked to see a fence installed, separating the playground from the trail, just that way there are no children are running out in front of cyclists or no balls are running underneath the tires of those bike bicycles.

L. Curtis1:28:15

While some expressed a desire for off-leash dog areas, others were strongly opposed to the idea and wanted to see signage, which indicated that dogs must really remain on their leash.

L. Curtis1:28:27

Other attendees were concerned about the possible reduction of greenhouse, uh, sorry, greenhouse green space currently available in the park.

L. Curtis1:28:36

Many park users stated how much they enjoyed coming to the park to throw a ball for their dog, um, to sit and relax in the sun, um, or just to run around on the green space.

L. Curtis1:28:50

Um, there were concerns from those who lived in closer proximity to the park regarding noise, and some expressed fear that the park would potentially be used for unwanted activities.

L. Curtis1:29:04

Several park users indicated a desire for public washrooms and additional lighting to be available on site.

L. Curtis1:29:10

Uh, yet others stated that having public wash washrooms become available on site may potentially bring more unwanted activities to the neighborhood and the park, and would possibly require additional monitoring and/or for the washrooms only to be available during the day.

L. Curtis1:29:29

Some of the park users would like to see a formal path connecting Cheltenham Street to the park.

L. Curtis1:29:36

Currently it is a dirt path, which means that it is money when it is raining, and it is icy when it is snowy, which is not great when you're trying to block from one area to the next.

L. Curtis1:30:00

Website.

L. Curtis1:30:03

So between both the open houses and the online survey, there were three overlapping questions.

L. Curtis1:30:11

The first of which which, sorry, being which equipment are you most excited to see being included in the playground?

L. Curtis1:30:19

For which, as I mentioned, climbing structures was number one with 64 people, in ground trampoline with 60 people.

L. Curtis1:30:27

And then there was the last, the swings with 49 people with slides coming in closely behind it at 47.

L. Curtis1:30:38

The second question was what features might you like to see in the spaces?

L. Curtis1:30:45

So park furniture had 77, um, grassy open spaces, 54, and shaded areas had 48.

L. Curtis1:30:53

And how best to keep you informed.

L. Curtis1:30:55

The majority of people, 59 uh said social media with 35 for park signage and 34 for website.

L. Curtis1:31:03

Um as mentioned, we had 92 people participate in the online survey.

L. Curtis1:31:08

Um, the following slides are those that have quantitative data shown.

L. Curtis1:31:13

So for the written response questions, please refer to attachment one.

L. Curtis1:31:18

Um they have all of the responses as they were given.

L. Curtis1:31:23

Um, so as mentioned, the majority of the people lived in the town of View Royal.

L. Curtis1:31:28

Um, majority of the people had in the neighborhood or had been in uh a resident of View Royal for more than 10 years.

L. Curtis1:31:40

Most lived within a five-minute walk of the park.

L. Curtis1:31:42

And as mentioned, most of them live nearby in proximity to the park.

L. Curtis1:31:48

So I feel like we've reached a number of people within the area through these different engagement methods.

L. Curtis1:31:56

And most people visited a few times of the year, but then we also had some people at the open houses who visited quite regularly every evening, every weekend, etc.

L. Curtis1:32:09

And most of the respondents for both the online survey, or in this case the online survey, excuse me, were between the ages of 30 to 49.

L. Curtis1:32:20

So um for next steps, um, public feedback will inform the draft design concepts for Chancellor Park Playground, and staff will present this design concept at a future staff meeting.

L. Curtis1:32:29

Can't excuse me.

Sid Tobias1:32:35

Thanks for the presentation.

Sid Tobias1:32:38

I thought it was uh good and I I stopped by, so it's in my neck of the woods.

Sid Tobias1:32:42

Uh I think folks have got a point about uh if you've ever walked through Chancellor Park and you it actually goes out the back way to um strode Cheltenham.

Sid Tobias1:32:52

Cheltim Road or is there?

Sid Tobias1:32:55

Um it's there's no gravel, there's no path, and so springtime it's probably got a 50-50 if you're gonna wipe out on the grass or not.

Sid Tobias1:33:05

Um uh just coming up there.

Sid Tobias1:33:06

So perhaps something it can be accessed from both areas uh uh around there.

Sid Tobias1:33:12

Um when before well the park was always there but before they put in the basketball hockey net kind of asphalty thing there it was always packed on a sunny day from folks from um uh the canoe and kayak apartments in Eagle Creek and the condos at Camden Green.

Sid Tobias1:33:33

Um but when they put the pavement in there wasn't as much place for people to space themselves out and read a book so that's just not being done.

Sid Tobias1:33:41

That's the only change I've really seen in the park positive or negative to it.

Sid Tobias1:33:45

It um it's never I don't see a lineup of kids trying to fight for playground stuff, but that there's at least one family there kind of you know throughout the day, just about all the day, so it's pretty consistent.

Sid Tobias1:33:58

But uh that was good.

Sid Tobias1:33:59

What what takeaways do you guys have for us aside from receive?

Sid Tobias1:34:03

I think you got a better response than the taxes did.

Sid Tobias1:34:07

So I think Don's not gonna be happy with that, but I'm just saying maybe could rub it in.

Sid Tobias1:34:12

Um but uh what takeaways do you have from that engagement?

L. Curtis1:34:18

Through the mayor, um most I would say everyone is excited to kind of see something being done with the area in terms of changing the play equipment that's there.

L. Curtis1:34:29

Um, some people would like the play structure to be accessible for all ages, whether it's through your infant ages to 12 or 18, so there everyone can continue to use the play structure.

L. Curtis1:34:41

Cool.

Sid Tobias1:34:43

Counselor Rogers and Councillor McKenzie, please.

John Rogers1:34:47

Yes, I I had attended the open house at uh Chancellor and um uh it's interesting one of the um uh ladies the parents who were there um really wanted to make sure that we did put um the access in behind to Cheltingham I think it is I think that's the street in the back um she says Gallop and Goose belongs to cyclists and she doesn't want to take her three year old along that dangerous path so uh she lives just in back.

John Rogers1:35:17

And as the mayor said, it's a home well it's not all season.

John Rogers1:35:22

So I think it's really important to be able to fix the problems first before we invest in new equipment.

John Rogers1:35:29

So access and so this is what we and one of the great opportunities we've had is to hear what's wrong with the park on top of how we can improve and change this part from a neighborhood park to a destination park.

John Rogers1:35:43

So one, yes, fix that.

John Rogers1:35:47

Two, get the fencing.

John Rogers1:35:49

It is uh uh a really I think a significant issue when kids are playing with the ball and that's gonna go in in uh front of the cyclists or whatever, and that's only gonna cause conflict, and that's what we're going to try and avoid.

John Rogers1:36:02

If this is going to be a destination park with an accessible structure that is the only one, $300,000 structure that is the only one in V Royal, then um, I guess two things.

John Rogers1:36:13

One, as we've heard in the comments, people want to make sure that it is going to be an accessible surface.

John Rogers1:36:20

Chips are not accessible.

John Rogers1:36:23

So that's that's another cost that we need to build in.

John Rogers1:36:33

So if we're going to uh make this the destination we're going to, and it's going to be for uh accessibility and uh handicapped mobility challenged individuals, then we would probably expect more accessible parking is going to be required, and indeed there is space to do so.

John Rogers1:36:50

The uh the parking looks like you can add two or three more stalls.

John Rogers1:36:53

So um it it did raise some very interesting uh points that we need to go beyond and um and make sure that uh this is going to be indeed um uh fit the bill on all fronts uh for accessible um aspects and the washrooms I think uh signages to where washrooms are located public washrooms are located uh I think is useful and quote unquote public Eagle Creek VGH hospital so I I think um that is getting with the times and and assisting individuals uh if they don't have an app on their phone that would tell them otherwise so let's help the folks out and and tell them where the amenities are.

John Rogers1:37:34

So I I um I look forward to seeing um uh a write up and and like I say, let's fix the problems first.

John Rogers1:37:42

Thank you.

Sid Tobias1:37:44

I'm assuming you're moving um receipt with after that comment.

Sid Tobias1:37:44

Yeah, moving.

Sid Tobias1:37:48

Should I come?

Sid Tobias1:37:49

Were you moving receipt with that comment?

Sid Tobias1:37:52

Uh Councilor McKenzie, please, and then Councillor Mattson.

Alison MacKenzie1:37:56

Can I verify whether this kind of project is tied to any sort of grant funding specific to X accessible equipment?

Leanne Taylor1:38:10

Uh through the mayor, um this project is part of the 2024-2028 financial plan as part of the playground replacement uh program.

Leanne Taylor1:38:20

And on the funding sources, uh Ivan's on the line, so correct me if I'm wrong, Ivan, but it's a combination of a few things.

Leanne Taylor1:38:27

And so development cost charges um casino and then I believe there is one other source of funding but it's not tax.

Alison MacKenzie1:38:39

Okay thank you my question was more um because a lot of the comments seem to not be related specifically to accessibility whereas the the title and and things seem to make it that that was the purpose of updating the park.

Alison MacKenzie1:38:55

So I'm glad to clarify that.

Alison MacKenzie1:38:57

Thank you.

Ron Mattson1:38:59

That's about I have a similar question.

Ron Mattson1:39:02

I may I attended the open or not the open house, but I was, yeah, I guess that was the open house.

Ron Mattson1:39:08

But I'm I'm still at a loss in what accessible uh equipment is for mobility challenged individuals and how it fits in at all with the items that were listed at, you know, they they seem to be more related to people who were who didn't have mobility issues than than did.

Ron Mattson1:39:26

And so uh and is is that supposed to be the overall objective of this park?

Ron Mattson1:39:31

Is we're it's gonna be a destination park for people with mobility challenges.

Leanne Taylor1:39:37

Through the mayor, uh it will be uh a destination.

Leanne Taylor1:39:40

Well, it'll be a park in the town of Uroyal neighborhood park.

Leanne Taylor1:39:43

It Chancellor Park is identified as a neighborhood park, and um but be because it's on the goose, it has really become a destination park.

Leanne Taylor1:39:51

I run by there quite frequently and um it's always busy with with people and you know, cyclists and kids um stopping off there to have to have uh a break eat eat their lunch a snack uh the an accessible playground is the base of that is that is for all ages and abilities and um many municipalities throughout North America now are designing playgrounds for all ages and abilities and um staff have done some research in this um they've been popping up across the region uh and been quite successful um my we I went out to uh be during the engagement process, uh my son and I, we visited a couple and he loved them.

Leanne Taylor1:40:38

He's almost 12 and um and really enjoyed the in-ground trampolines, the the slides, uh the ease play equipment um allow for mobility devices, so wheelchairs to access some of the play equipment.

Leanne Taylor1:40:52

So it's quite um it's uh they're quite beautiful playgrounds.

Ron Mattson1:40:59

Okay, so when this comes back to us, we will see examples of the equipment, et cetera.

Ron Mattson1:41:05

So I because I'm still I have to admit I'm sort of ignorant and what what it looks like, so I I really don't know.

Leanne Taylor1:41:11

Absolutely.

Leanne Taylor1:41:12

We will be um presenting council with a concept and um and we'll be sh sh you know providing more information once that's developed.

Leanne Taylor1:41:21

And I see that um Director Lung has his hand up, so I'll pass that over to him as well.

Leanne Taylor1:41:25

Thank you.

Ivan Leung1:41:27

Thank you, Director Taylor.

Ivan Leung1:41:28

Yeah, just to speak with respect to kind of ideas and examples of accessible and accessible playground structures.

Ivan Leung1:41:35

Uh Staticona Park in the city of Victoria, that's an accessible playground.

Ivan Leung1:41:40

And then um that was, I believe, was installed the fall of last year, and then just recently the city of Langford uh just installed their um accessible playground at Low Note Park.

Ivan Leung1:41:51

So certainly some examples nearby that uh if you're in the area, certainly worth checking out to see kind of what kind of examples of uh of playground structures there are available for uh the needs uh for people that need access.

Speaker_171:42:08

Councilor McKenzie.

Gery Lemon1:42:10

Um and may I ask um have we engaged with Access West Shore at all the uh through the mayor we did reach out to I believe what the is that IACTI now yes we did send them uh a letter counselor Lemon well that says to me that this is the lens we need to look through when we redevelop or add to any of our neighborhood parks going forward.

Gery Lemon1:42:48

And I'm seconding the motion.

Sid Tobias1:42:50

Thank you, Counselor.

Sid Tobias1:42:51

Uh Lemon, yeah, just a couple of comments uh from me.

Sid Tobias1:42:55

One is uh I I think it's a a great park, and really we're talking about replacing the equipment that's there kind of in the same footprint, maybe a little bit bigger.

Sid Tobias1:43:04

Um, so it is designated as a neighborhood park, correct?

Sid Tobias1:43:08

Uh, and and we'll continue on that designation.

Sid Tobias1:43:10

And for counselor Rogers, I I've only seen a few cars parking on parking lot, and those cars didn't have anything to do with um using the park at all.

Sid Tobias1:43:22

Um, so I think before we suggest we need more spaces, we should probably look at the parking we've got.

Sid Tobias1:43:27

Uh certainly accessible parking, if that's what what we're going to be toting for a large uh van and handicap zones and a place to offload and onload and get up the goose.

Sid Tobias1:43:38

But most of the folks that I've seen go there are actually transiting on the goose that are stopping.

Sid Tobias1:43:44

That it's actually a stop for them.

Sid Tobias1:43:44

Lots from outside there.

Sid Tobias1:43:47

So yeah, just before we call it a destination, I didn't think we're turning this into Disneyland, Councillor Rogers.

Sid Tobias1:43:53

I thought it was a neighborhood park.

Sid Tobias1:43:55

So I don't think we have the budget for Disneyland.

John Rogers1:43:59

Darn, I was wanting a castle.

John Rogers1:44:02

Um so um, but I I think the thing is that um uh accessible playgrounds are expensive.

John Rogers1:44:10

And I don't know if uh staff are intending to have uh one in each corner.

John Rogers1:44:15

You know, in uh, you know, we've got three, let's imagine we have three corners, right?

John Rogers1:44:19

Admirals and and uh Choco and um and so forth.

John Rogers1:44:24

Would we have three accessible structures in V Royal?

John Rogers1:44:30

I I guess my my question is, you know, it is um, and I guess it depends on the needs, and if, you know, who knows who, what accessible issues and and um youth uh live in the Choco area.

John Rogers1:44:42

So it uh this might be a model, but if it's not a model, if it's the only one that we intend to put in, then it will be a destination.

John Rogers1:44:51

And just like uh we're only gonna put in one um um uh sorry, the the uh the bike ramp structure in in View O Park, we're only doing one of those, I would imagine.

John Rogers1:45:02

So that, and that certainly has been a destination, and that certainly has uh increased the demand for parking uh so much that everyone's parking on Pheasant Lane.

John Rogers1:45:11

So it, you know, we have to anticipate that if you're gonna draw the people in, they're not always going to be using the goose.

John Rogers1:45:18

And uh so questions and and comments about an off-leash area.

John Rogers1:45:31

Now I know the park is very small, but I do want to make a point for the dog owners that um there are just as many dog owners as there are parents.

John Rogers1:45:41

And if we're going to have uh an area dictated by the province where we're going to have 10-story buildings and a heck of a lot more people, that probably are gonna have be uh more dog owners.

John Rogers1:45:51

And we'll find out how many people or how many dog licenses there are.

John Rogers1:45:55

But I the point I want to make is there are only five off-leash spaces in View Royal, and those were created back in 2002.

Sid Tobias1:46:04

I'm gonna keep us on topic, and this is uh this is no uh this is an engagement.

Sid Tobias1:46:08

What we were heard report, you're adding new stuff in there, so I'll get you to sum up, Councillor Roger.

John Rogers1:46:13

Indeed.

John Rogers1:46:14

So um we have heard, and and I guess my my concern was that uh like in Burnside Watkins, we did not acknowledge the the aspects of dog uh owner requests for off-leash.

John Rogers1:46:27

Likewise, here we didn't anticipate and consider the the need for off-leash in this space.

John Rogers1:46:32

But the point is that people did raise the point, and if they're raising the question, then either they're gonna mobilize and um or they're going to uh they want to be heard and I guess that's my point.

John Rogers1:46:48

We've got a lot more dogs and we have not accommodated those residents needs.

John Rogers1:46:53

Thank you.

Ron Mattson1:46:55

I just Councilor Rogers can't help myself but this report was just what they heard not on what we'd like to have heard.

John Rogers1:47:03

It's what they heard.

John Rogers1:47:04

It's a comment in the in the thing off leash off leash.

Sid Tobias1:47:09

Okay so we got a mover and a seconder um all those in favor.

Sid Tobias1:47:16

Any opposed.

Sid Tobias1:47:18

Thank you very much.

Sid Tobias1:47:20

And Councilor Rogers, there might be an opportunity to bring up some of your concerns about added amenities, and that's for a piece of property the town owns up there that may not be associated exactly with this part.

Sid Tobias1:47:34

So uh Leanne, is this you for draft public engagement strategy and survey?

Sid Tobias1:47:41

Okay.

Leanne Taylor1:47:43

All right.

Leanne Taylor1:47:43

Uh good evening, Mayor and Council.

Leanne Taylor1:47:47

This is our last presentation of the evening, I believe, um, on the draft public engagement strategy and survey.

Leanne Taylor1:47:57

And what I'm going to do is um I'm going to take you back because um pardon oh.

Leanne Taylor1:48:09

So I'm going to be taking you back to last summer.

Leanne Taylor1:48:13

Uh you may recall that we had two OCP strategic planning council workshops to discuss the OCP process, and council provided some feedback on how they wished to move forward with the OCP.

Leanne Taylor1:48:31

And out of those two workshops, council passed two key resolutions.

Leanne Taylor1:48:38

The first one is that the town of U Royal adopts the International Association of Public Participation's Core Values as a general framework upon which to build its community engagement strategy.

Leanne Taylor1:48:50

And the second resolution is that an engagement tool be developed to seek feedback on the public's preferred official community plan engagement strategy.

Leanne Taylor1:49:02

So a lot's happened over the last, we're coming up to almost a year now, and now that council has passed the 2024 2028 financial plan.

Leanne Taylor1:49:15

Staff is now kickstarting this process.

Leanne Taylor1:49:18

And as part of the financial plan, there are two key non core projects that Council that the Development Services Department is leading.

Leanne Taylor1:49:28

One is the community engagement strategy, and the second is the official community plan.

Leanne Taylor1:49:34

And for the community engagement strategy, one key project objective is to understand what kind of engagement the community prefers and what modes of engagement should we consider using.

Leanne Taylor1:49:47

And with that, as well as the direction that we received from council at the council workshops, staff decided, well not decided, but staff felt that the best engagement tool in order to seek feedback from the community is through a survey.

Leanne Taylor1:50:09

And we have demonstrated that as part of the community, the Chancellor Park engagement strategy uh survey that we did for that project.

Leanne Taylor1:50:20

We we got quite a good uh response there, and through a variety of different channels, we're hoping to carry out a similar process.

Leanne Taylor1:50:32

We have engaged um Tvolas Tavola Strategy Group who were who was Katie Hamilton, who was involved with the OCP council workshops, and we have continued to engage her as part of this particular survey to ensure that we are um responding to council's wishes.

Leanne Taylor1:51:02

Is that I would like to quickly discuss is that we have prepared a draft public engagement survey that we would like to get feedback from council on tonight because we are wanting to launch the survey before the end of June, before we embark into the summer months.

Leanne Taylor1:51:24

The survey does reflect the International Association of Public Participation Core Values, and that is highlighted in the public engagement strategy, which is attachment three of the staff report.

Leanne Taylor1:51:38

And also in the strategy, it outlines how we are going to raise public awareness and promote the survey over the next six weeks.

Leanne Taylor1:51:50

And we will be doing that through media releases, ads in the Goldstream Gazette, social media, website, posters throughout the town, and sending letters to community groups.

Leanne Taylor1:52:02

In the strategy that is attached to the report, we have a list of community groups and nonprofit organizations that we would like to send letters to so that we can get feedback from them in terms of what type of interests people in our community have on public engagement, how they like to be engaged, what sort of projects do they want to be engaged on in terms of the OCP, the master master plans, and other projects.

Leanne Taylor1:52:29

So this is a this type of information is really going to help inform the community engagement strategy.

Leanne Taylor1:52:34

So it really kickstarts both projects for us.

Leanne Taylor1:52:38

I'm not going to read out the list of committee groups that we would like to reach out to.

Leanne Taylor1:52:44

However, if there's any that council can think of and that we should be adding to the list, it would be great to hear from you on that.

Leanne Taylor1:52:52

And then staff will come back in September with a what we heard report on the public engagement strategy, a survey, pardon me, to so that we can get the ball rolling.

Leanne Taylor1:53:10

So as I noted, I hope council has had an opportunity to review the survey of before well the strategy and survey before tonight's meeting.

Leanne Taylor1:53:19

And one I think a technique that quite worked quite well within the OCP workshops was that we just um went around council's table.

Leanne Taylor1:53:28

We started at one end we ended at the other end I think councilor brown started first last time and uh to give each council member an opportunity to ask questions and provide comment and what we will do is take that feedback and incorporate it into the survey um before we launch it uh next week so it is a quick turnaround however it's just really important that we get going on this that is my presentation and if mayor and council is is supports this idea of going around um the council table then we can we can do that so I'll leave it with Mayor of Tobais perhaps you can facilitate that.

Sid Tobias1:54:08

Leah thanks uh for that so really you're looking at two parts you're looking at um support for the strategy and then direct feedback on the questionnaire am I correct?

Leanne Taylor1:54:22

That's correct.

Leanne Taylor1:54:23

So if you turn to attachment three of the staff report it's um provides a an overview of the engagement strategy and under background it it provides a bit of a background of why we're doing this and then the uh the key topics and so key engagement topics and the level engagement as per the IAP too and then the engage, then we also have a summary of the engagement approach and so how we're going to raise awareness of the public engagement survey, the in and other various input channels, as well as a list of the community groups and nonprofit organizations that we would like to reach out to.

Leanne Taylor1:55:08

However, we do have a separate note here that we do want to reach out to the Songis and Esquimalt Nations, but we will be doing that separately, not as part of the survey.

Leanne Taylor1:55:20

We will be engaging them separately.

Leanne Taylor1:55:28

So we have a list of demographic questions on demographics.

Leanne Taylor1:55:33

And then we have um we go into survey questions.

Leanne Taylor1:55:36

So interest in public participation on town matters, topics of interest, what does meaning engage meaningful engagement look to you uh we have a mix of open-ended questions as well as uh selection random selection and also prefer channels to receive information so it's really important that we come up with an engagement strategy a part of our OCP which will be the sort of the first major project out of the gate to incorporate um or implement an engagement strategy and and also be used as part of the community engagement strategy which is actually affects all departments and all town business in terms of how we engage on master plans and projects.

Sid Tobias1:56:26

Great.

Sid Tobias1:56:26

Thanks, Leanne.

Sid Tobias1:56:27

Let's start on your end, Councillor McKenzie, if you're happy with that.

Sid Tobias1:56:31

But before I go to you, just a couple of general questions.

Sid Tobias1:56:34

One of which will be on the top of some people's minds right off the bat is this is already budgeted for, we've already kind of budgeted this part out.

Sid Tobias1:56:45

And the second part of that is that kind of a motivation for importance because with the new provincial legislation, this is the only time on the OCP that we really get to engage the public and get their feedback on anything with no public hearings being held on anything.

Sid Tobias1:57:06

So we can only get their opinions in advance of some of the decisions that we'll be making uh throughout it.

Sid Tobias1:57:13

So uh those are the two points it's been we we've decided on the budget we've already uh said it was in second part is it's more important now with this legislation because it's the only time we get to engage the public on on the town that they want to see in the future.

Alison MacKenzie1:57:28

Council McKenzie Thanks my comments relate uh more to the approach rather than the actual questions so I would I didn't see mention of it so I would like to see um kind of like a pop up survey or an interview so that you know perhaps with the um tablet that people can fill in on the spot because I think those have been useful and the approach currently I think will target those people who are already engaged in the community or in reading newspapers and things like that.

Alison MacKenzie1:58:01

So that's my only like how do we target the people who use our services and are in our town every day but um might not be paying attention to those like online and and things like that.

Alison MacKenzie1:58:14

And then I was also when I was when I was looking at the questions I did think we had the question whether you are a View Royal resident and I was thinking do do we want a lot of perspective like I don't want it to be weighted too heavily to non View Royal residents.

Alison MacKenzie1:58:31

So d do we want to restrict it to View Royal residents?

Alison MacKenzie1:58:35

I don't I don't know.

Alison MacKenzie1:58:36

That's thank you.

Speaker_141:58:41

That's a ratson, please.

Ron Mattson1:58:47

Yeah, I guess there's still a lot of people who really don't know what an OCP does or what it's for.

Ron Mattson1:58:52

And so I guess in terms of this document, start off with the definition of an OCP and and how it's used to sort of um you know in town planning and you know of what value it is to them and why it should be important to them.

Ron Mattson1:59:06

So I I thought that was missing and so I think that would be helpful.

Ron Mattson1:59:13

I don't know if this might sound a bit snarky but when you when you mentioned that the same person being used for this survey was also used in our last O C P draft that we just did.

Ron Mattson1:59:27

Oh in the workshop okay so then that's I take take back my comment um yeah no I'm the bigger issue would be just you know getting people to fill out the survey and so you know the questions all look fine and so how you do that is probably you know maybe it pay people pay residents to come down here and or or maybe we could have a couple of open houses where people just get to uh provide them full of goodies if they fill out the form.

Speaker_172:00:06

Thank you, Councillor Mattson.

Speaker_172:00:07

Councillor Rogers.

John Rogers2:00:09

Yes, thank you um a lot of concerns.

John Rogers2:00:13

If we're gonna put this out in um July and August, or sorry, June, July, parents are bailing.

John Rogers2:00:20

They're the only the only the main focus is they're closing up school and they're gonna hit the road as quickly as possible.

John Rogers2:00:27

And so in this time frame.

John Rogers2:00:28

I remember when we were trying to do a survey about the uh uh the bike schools park in summertime and the parents were gone the kids were gone so how are we going to get any response on on a uh uh a a playground on a park and so I I'm I'm really worried that we're gonna be doing a survey it's like doing a uh uh a public hearing on a major uh significant development and no one's around because it's summertime.

John Rogers2:00:53

Um so timing is everything and summer is never a good time to uh to have people switch their minds to uh you know something as as complex as this um particularly if you know we're looking at community groups like school packs will they be around I doubt it so um that's that's one of the worries I have um yeah the yeah it's interesting to see about raising awareness I think one of the uh interesting um awareness factors is um maybe folks like Christie Point have a Facebook page Choco has a Facebook page maybe Glenn Early has a Facebook page.

John Rogers2:01:32

Let's hook in.

John Rogers2:01:33

Let's find out who where those Facebook pages are and um try you know try to draw them in that way.

John Rogers2:01:39

And as long as they feel that they've got ownership, as fill as they've that they're uh they're really going to be heard.

John Rogers2:01:44

Um and I'm definitely it it's an interesting range of community groups that you've got.

John Rogers2:01:51

I would um put emergency our emergency volunteers.

John Rogers2:01:55

That is an important group.

John Rogers2:01:57

They're well connected, they know what's happening with the town.

John Rogers2:02:00

Uh you um I'm pleased that you got some um the green team, but I would uh uh suggest that you have the Habitat Acquisition Group, yeah, Gorgia Waterways uh initiatives.

John Rogers2:02:10

Those are good folks.

John Rogers2:02:11

I'm not so sure about our place society.

John Rogers2:02:14

I don't know how that that relates.

John Rogers2:02:15

Um that I've never had any involvement with them in in the town.

Leanne Taylor2:02:19

Um no, they run the um the recovery, the therapeutic recovery.

John Rogers2:02:24

Pardon me, you're right.

John Rogers2:02:25

Thank you.

John Rogers2:02:26

Um yeah, the question do you live in View oil i that's that's my expectation I don't want to hear from Colwood Isquamo Sanich I want to hear from residents I'm pleased that we're gonna have a a separate survey from for the uh First Nation First Nations that's important but the other municipalities no I don't want them involved I don't want their their um um you know because that's that's gonna be too distracting I'd be interested if a property owner someone who owns property in View Royal but uh doesn't live here I think they've they uh have a stake in this um the um yeah I would very much like to hear um and because I I'd like to turn our our our um because this is the last OCP this is before it gets cast into stone and um so I think our our neighborhood precincts um not just the harbor obviously Chilco um North Ruils um we need to somehow tell them what the problem is if they don't silence is consent and they may not be willing to uh when they see the uh the aftermath not going to be terribly thrilled with so we're gonna we have to hit them with blunt instruments to make sure they understand what uh so to say what topics you're interested in and good god select all that apply okay I'll check all 15 I would suggest that we probably would want to see the top five so that we understand what's really important to them in in this range i almost wondered if we could do that in in uh in a same question i don't know can i add something that i just missed quickly pardon me are you complete uh counselor rogers sorry yeah are you done no you want no i i'm i'm not done now if you want to i can go around you know you guys can but i'm not finished with this yet so my comment just as we describe what the OCP is if you could also just put in a map with the various precincts and ask them which precinct they they live in it would just be able to focus it down a bit because I at the end of the day I would think I would like to see comments you know when we do the OCP it get people from various precincts to comment on their precinct and their what they want their community to look like.

Leanne Taylor2:05:00

So yeah can I just add something to that um and I and I didn't mention mention this early but I just want to mention I mean staff really hope that council gets the word out as well um with the constituents and I you know staff will we're gonna do our very best to get the word out and get out to the go out to the people and and do what we can, but we also rely on on council to get the word out.

Sid Tobias2:05:25

Thank you.

Sid Tobias2:05:26

Um I'll I'll go around and Councillor Rogers, I'll come back to you.

Sid Tobias2:05:30

Um the agree with uh Counselor McKenzie and kind of a pop-up in those neighborhoods.

Sid Tobias2:05:36

Um, and I could look in different ways.

Sid Tobias2:05:38

I think the one was quite successful in Chancellor Park, um, and you know, kind of what to look for.

Sid Tobias2:05:44

Um, I think Councillor Rogers had a good point about you know the the topics you're interested in receiving information about, but you could drill it down, right?

Sid Tobias2:05:53

You could start with housing and land use and get down to you know another level of granularity within that, but starting with a smaller group, you could offset it.

Sid Tobias2:06:04

Um just from my own experience and being able to reach out, I think one of the other groups that's a little bit harder to understand or like strata association and Christie Point group.

Sid Tobias2:06:16

It's kind of an informal group of residents that once you find one person in there that can organize uh uh you know, getting a group of people together.

Sid Tobias2:06:27

Um, I think there's powers in surveys, but they're kind of limited.

Sid Tobias2:06:31

If you really want to hear what people think, you get them together as a as a collective, like as a strata uh or whatever.

Sid Tobias2:06:38

And then you can present your your uh questions verbally and and you get um you get a response and a bit of dialogue between people that is more actually the truth.

Sid Tobias2:06:51

Um, I hate to say it that way, that um people might not always tell the truth on surveys, but with their neighbors around, they're forced to tell the truth.

Sid Tobias2:06:59

Uh and and kind of uh gets you a better perspective.

Sid Tobias2:07:03

So any way we can reach out, and I'm sure we must have maybe a a list of stratas, councils that we correspond with on stuff, but a way in there is uh is is a good way in.

Sid Tobias2:07:16

Um that's just a thought.

Sid Tobias2:07:18

And I'll come back to you again, Councilor Rogers.

Sid Tobias2:07:20

Council Lemon.

Sid Tobias2:07:21

Um I'm just minding the time and that we get a closed meeting after this too.

Gery Lemon2:07:25

Great, thank you.

Gery Lemon2:07:26

Um actually I I had a list of points and most of them have been picked up by my colleagues.

Gery Lemon2:07:32

I I agree with with Councillor McKenzie.

Gery Lemon2:07:36

Many people aren't on social media, many people aren't receiving traditional media.

Gery Lemon2:07:41

Um and you know it's it's it's it's a complicated wor world and people often um choose to tune out.

Gery Lemon2:07:49

So anywhere we can grab attention um is is a good thing.

Gery Lemon2:07:56

And that might be the most popular way to go.

Gery Lemon2:07:59

And perhaps you know maybe we have a pop-up in Chancellor Park that seems to be a uh a a gathering spot.

Gery Lemon2:08:07

And I did Tabolo help with this um survey or do they come in later?

Leanne Taylor2:08:16

Through the mayor, they assisted in drafting the survey.

Gery Lemon2:08:20

Great.

Leanne Taylor2:08:20

Yeah.

Leanne Taylor2:08:20

Along with staff's input.

Gery Lemon2:08:22

Good, good um summers if you know, I'm I'm I'm in that bit, was in that business, and summer is a terrible time to get people's attention.

Gery Lemon2:08:33

They, you know, if they were not um plugged in through the year, they're certainly not plugged in in the summer.

Gery Lemon2:08:39

So that will be a real challenge.

Gery Lemon2:08:40

And and and that's when I think your the pop-up example will be perhaps the most successful way of of getting people in.

Gery Lemon2:08:50

That's the only time we have.

Gery Lemon2:08:52

Um, and I guess that's what I'm hearing, is that's the only time we have.

Gery Lemon2:08:56

It has to happen in July.

Leanne Taylor2:08:59

We can we can extend this to the end of August.

Leanne Taylor2:09:02

Um, that's not a problem because we will be coming back to council in September.

Leanne Taylor2:09:07

So we can, depending on the responses we're getting, we can we could extend it.

Leanne Taylor2:09:12

It's um and perhaps we extend it into the first week of September.

Leanne Taylor2:09:15

Well let's gate let staff will gauge it on how we're doing with it because we would like to hear from as many individuals as possible.

Leanne Taylor2:09:23

We really want to get the word out.

Leanne Taylor2:09:25

We really want to um, you know, hear, you know, more voices in the town and and getting people engaged and interested in the official community plan.

Leanne Taylor2:09:35

And so we will um, even though we said six weeks, it is a long time to have a survey uh out.

Leanne Taylor2:09:41

However, we'll uh we'll be monitoring it.

Leanne Taylor2:09:45

Um a survey, in a way, is sort of the biggest bang for the buck.

Leanne Taylor2:09:48

Council needs to know that we don't have a big budget for this, and we can't be spending it all on consulting.

Leanne Taylor2:09:55

We need to make sure that we are getting, you know, we're we're we're being mindful of of our budget, and we are getting the biggest bang for the buck, and we're trying to do most in-house.

Leanne Taylor2:10:07

However, you know, there's it's it is it is you know, it is work.

Leanne Taylor2:10:11

So um this is and you know, if we're not satisfied with the responses, then maybe we need to extend this a bit further.

Leanne Taylor2:10:21

But we are under some time constraints in terms of getting going on the official community plan.

Leanne Taylor2:10:27

It would we have to I'm getting a bit off track, but I think this helps emphasize the time constraints is that the province requires us to update our official community plan by uh the end December of 2025, and it to best utilize staff time and resources it's it's good to do it this all at once not in a piecemeal fashion especially an official community plan so this is why we're thanks Leanne I'm just gonna move us along a little bit um and and uh so uh maybe extend it out a little bit so I agree with uh there's a concern for summertime and I will have to say that's the only time I can really uh turn my attention to this so if you say September, people have got kids going back to school.

Sid Tobias2:11:20

They're not paying attention to anything else.

Sid Tobias2:11:21

They're they're in that mode.

Sid Tobias2:11:23

So I think everybody's got assumptions here.

Sid Tobias2:11:25

Uh, and no time is good time or or the best time.

Sid Tobias2:11:28

So I think once we get it out there, we can extend as necessary or uh whatever.

Sid Tobias2:11:29

We won't shorten it, but um but uh I I think the time of year is is busy all the time that people know.

Sid Tobias2:11:42

Uh did you have something else?

Gery Lemon2:11:44

Um I I think I'm uh oh one question.

Gery Lemon2:11:47

Will this um be a template for for engagement going forward?

Gery Lemon2:11:54

Oh, absolutely.

Gery Lemon2:11:55

So the yes, okay.

Gery Lemon2:11:57

Good, good answer.

Gery Lemon2:11:59

Thank you.

Sid Tobias2:11:59

And are there questions that we can reuse that were asked before so that we would have maybe a baseline?

Sid Tobias2:12:05

We've asked lots of surveys before.

Sid Tobias2:12:07

Are there some questions in there that we've got some historical data, maybe something that we could cross-reference older surveys that we've done?

Leanne Taylor2:12:15

Absolutely, we can we can look into that.

Leanne Taylor2:12:18

I yeah.

Sid Tobias2:12:22

If it's been a question asked before and we ask it again and get a new set of data back, it's always interesting to compare that.

Sid Tobias2:12:29

Counselor Brown.

Don Brown2:12:34

This is like being the last pick on the playground for sports team.

Don Brown2:12:38

Anyways, um yeah, there's several items that come up tonight.

Don Brown2:12:42

I would like to have more chance to speak.

Don Brown2:12:45

I hate the surveys when there's only a limited number of responses.

Don Brown2:12:48

So whatever we can do to maximize the number of responses, certainly uh the internet is is one.

Don Brown2:12:54

Uh if school's in, and of course it's not, I would prefer to see young people have a chance to fill a survey in.

Don Brown2:13:00

And as far as people from View Royal, um people work here, people play here, people send their kids to school here.

Don Brown2:13:07

Um you might have friends and families that live in View Royal, so you do have a stake in the game.

Don Brown2:13:12

So I have no problem with people from Collwood or or responding to uh to the survey at all.

Don Brown2:13:19

Um and as far as just just a comment about people um leaving the community because we have small scale multi-housing.

Don Brown2:13:28

My son has six children.

Don Brown2:13:30

They've already built onto their house twice.

Don Brown2:13:32

They got six bedrooms, they got six kids.

Don Brown2:13:35

They want all those children to stay in the community, and they will stay in the community.

Don Brown2:13:38

So to say that people are gonna leave just because of multi small-scale multi-housing, uh, I don't believe in that.

Don Brown2:13:44

And also older people moving back into the homes.

Don Brown2:13:48

So I didn't get a chance to say that before, so I'm putting that in there now.

Don Brown2:13:53

Also, landlords, and Councillor Rogers pointed that out.

Don Brown2:13:56

Landlords own property here.

Don Brown2:13:58

Of course, they should have a say in what the survey says.

Don Brown2:14:01

Teachers, business owners, everybody that lives at or destination parks, people come using our park and don't live in View Royal.

Don Brown2:14:09

Yeah, we want to hear what they have to say.

Don Brown2:14:11

So maximize it to the nth degree.

Speaker_172:14:18

Thank you.

Sid Tobias2:14:20

I think Councillor Brown, you brought up a good point instead of uh View Royal resident or not View Royal resident, maybe the question of what relationship do you have with View Royal?

Sid Tobias2:14:31

For instance, Don's point like, are you a teacher?

Sid Tobias2:14:34

Do you own a business?

Sid Tobias2:14:35

Do your kids go to school here?

Sid Tobias2:14:36

Uh what stakes?

Sid Tobias2:14:38

So we can understand, because just by saying you're resident, I don't think to your point is good enough.

Sid Tobias2:14:42

I mean you could own a business for 50 years here and not get a chance to comment on this, and I don't think that's fair either.

Sid Tobias2:14:49

Uh Council Rogers, we'll go back to you now.

John Rogers2:14:51

I agree.

John Rogers2:14:52

I want to hear from taxpayers.

John Rogers2:14:55

And uh, you know, if they if they live in Colwood and Esquamlo, they're happy to pay back taxes for View Royal, but they're not unless they own the businesses.

John Rogers2:15:04

So, yeah, businesses I think is is reasonable.

John Rogers2:15:07

Um, I I think you know, in one of the uh the survey questions on uh how interesting providing provide inter in input on the official community plan define it master plans define it projects like what um and I think one of the other interesting things that they want would probably give input on is development proposals I think that's why we had our advisory committees which we killed so um well speaking of which maybe we should ask sort of our advisory committees even though they're retired or on ice um I would certainly like to hear from from those good folks.

John Rogers2:15:44

And a question.

John Rogers2:15:46

Did you last did you participate in the last OCP?

Leanne Taylor2:15:50

I did not.

Sid Tobias2:15:52

Pardon mean I no C she answered your question, but that was a question you would like to add.

Sid Tobias2:15:57

Were you part of the survey or last time?

Sid Tobias2:16:01

It wasn't directed at you, it was for a question.

John Rogers2:16:03

I know.

John Rogers2:16:03

I know you were in word.

John Rogers2:16:05

No.

John Rogers2:16:05

So that's a question maybe one.

John Rogers2:16:06

If it's just about OCPs, then did you participate in the last OCP?

John Rogers2:16:10

How was it?

John Rogers2:16:10

I'd be curious to know what their their thoughts on that was.

John Rogers2:16:19

Yeah.

John Rogers2:16:20

Again, you know, with with the great long lists of uh choose all that apply, uh, I I would want to hear from you know what the top ten is.

John Rogers2:16:29

Um strengths, is is we gotta identify strengths and weaknesses.

John Rogers2:16:34

So what does the town do well in terms of communication engagement?

John Rogers2:16:38

What do we do poorly in engagement?

John Rogers2:16:42

I think we should ask the question.

John Rogers2:16:43

Let's be bold.

John Rogers2:16:44

Let's accept our folks and find out more.

Leanne Taylor2:16:47

Um we do have those questions under questions 10 and 11.

John Rogers2:16:55

Yeah, so you know, 10 is great.

John Rogers2:16:57

Let's let's do um let's do what we ask what we do poorly.

John Rogers2:17:04

And I do like the question um what currently prevents you from participating in in town uh engagement opportunities?

John Rogers2:17:10

That's that's a good question.

John Rogers2:17:11

I really want to hear that.

John Rogers2:17:13

And um that'll probably be a good indicator of uh how we're going to make sure we get these folks engaged.

John Rogers2:17:19

And when we had a really controversial issue, like waiving $900,000 in DCCs uh for a CRD project, that got the community engaged.

John Rogers2:17:31

And you know, we did have uh a flyer that went out, you know, to every every person, both the proponents and the opponents, you know, yeah, were keen to uh put their cases forward.

John Rogers2:17:44

So um flyer is terribly important.

John Rogers2:17:47

And um, I think we we recently had a uh a flyer go around.

John Rogers2:17:52

If you want counselors to deliver the flyers, you know, you haven't got big bucks, let me know.

John Rogers2:17:56

I'll be happy to get out there and and make sure that every doorstep is aware of this OCP and that they will have this will be their last chance.

John Rogers2:18:04

It's almost like Custer's last stand.

John Rogers2:18:07

Okay, thank you.

Sid Tobias2:18:09

Thank you, Councillor Rogers.

Sid Tobias2:18:10

Uh Leanne, I know we were planning on doing another one on advisory uh committees.

Sid Tobias2:18:16

And I don't know, you'll have to weigh it if it's too much for this, but a question, would you like to participate in an advisory committee on these general topics or whatever would be uh an opportunity that they could uh add their name to a list that they would be interested in?

John Rogers2:18:35

Good point.

Sid Tobias2:18:36

Um uh we often use it for uh the province for technical advisory committees in our surveys.

Sid Tobias2:18:42

Uh it's just the last question.

Sid Tobias2:18:44

Uh would you like to participate in in and a committee uh regarding this a little bit more?

Sid Tobias2:18:50

Um so I think uh Leanne, so that that's some feedback.

Sid Tobias2:18:57

And do you want us to receive or do you need permissions to go ahead that uh we provided feedback and that this feedback be incorporated into the survey or into the document it will be both because council provided some um feedback on the the strategy and also on the survey so it will be both.

Sid Tobias2:19:32

Okay, great.

Sid Tobias2:19:33

Can I get a mover and a seconder for that?

Speaker_142:19:36

Second.

Sid Tobias2:19:37

Counselor brown moved.

Sid Tobias2:19:38

Councillor McKenzie seconded.

Sid Tobias2:19:40

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:19:42

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:19:43

Seeing none opposed, motion carries.

Sid Tobias2:19:44

Or I think Sterling abandoned you, so the agenda.

Sid Tobias2:19:46

And I think that brings us down.

Sid Tobias2:19:47

Are you gonna stay up for this, Leanne?

Sid Tobias2:19:54

Uh delegation of small scale multi-unit housing and garden suite, form and character permits and development.

Sid Tobias2:20:00

So it's just a committee of the whole or a um a uh committee recommend to council.

Sid Tobias2:20:05

That's what we uh discussed at the last committee the whole meeting.

Sid Tobias2:20:11

I'll move that.

Sid Tobias2:20:12

Move the recommendation.

Sid Tobias2:20:14

Okay, moved.

Sid Tobias2:20:15

Second.

Sid Tobias2:20:16

Seconded by Councillor Lemon.

Sid Tobias2:20:18

Uh any discussion?

Sid Tobias2:20:22

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:20:23

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:20:26

Noted Councillor McKenzie and uh Councillor Rogers are opposed.

Sid Tobias2:20:29

We have no other reports.

Sid Tobias2:20:35

We've already dealt with the correspondence.

Sid Tobias2:20:37

And that brings us down to new business.

Sid Tobias2:20:40

Council Rogers, I'll hand this over to you because you're alpha, but if you'd also like to include under new business something about Christie Point, but advocacy, feel free to.

John Rogers2:20:49

Yes, thank you.

John Rogers2:20:50

In the interest of time, folks, I'm I'm going to table the ENN for another time.

John Rogers2:20:55

So at the next council meeting, it's more important that we deal with uh Christie Point.

John Rogers2:21:04

So with uh uh adding Christie Point as an agenda item, worship is that what we're saying?

John Rogers2:21:09

Okay.

John Rogers2:21:10

Um members, um, I've drafted a uh a motion uh for your consideration um that um council wright uh in support of Christie Point uh residents requesting taps uh together against poverty society uh to provide legal representation to the tenants as a class action uh to make their uh make their case to the province regarding the um the impacts of the capital expenditure expenditures process can I just point out we made a commitment not to make motions without first providing them to staff to forget feedback to us?

Ron Mattson2:21:59

I mean, I don't know how necessary it is to get a motion out today.

Ron Mattson2:22:04

I'm happy with the concept, but that was a commitment we made that we wouldn't make off the cuff motions and submit council.

Don Brown2:22:13

Okay.

Don Brown2:22:14

Council Brown?

Don Brown2:22:16

Yeah, I agree.

Don Brown2:22:17

Actually, I wrote a motion out here to bring to the next council meeting.

Don Brown2:22:21

And I would prefer a strong letter written to the Minister of Housing, uh Callan.

Don Brown2:22:26

Uh, because of the high cost of rentals, I can't believe it.

Don Brown2:22:29

I I I've been I've been a tenant, I've been a landlord and lost tons of money.

Don Brown2:22:34

And I can't believe they would unload the costs onto new tenants.

Don Brown2:22:37

Like unbelievable.

Don Brown2:22:39

I mean, in in a wonderful world, I I'd become a landlord again.

Don Brown2:22:43

I can't believe it.

Don Brown2:22:43

I cannot believe it.

Don Brown2:22:44

A strata, if you don't have your money to in your contingency to fix your roof, you you you take an assessment.

Don Brown2:22:52

But that's that's your property.

Don Brown2:22:53

You've got skin in the game.

Don Brown2:22:55

This is ridiculous.

Don Brown2:22:56

The 3.5% raise every 12 months, and then they're gonna make them pay for their friggin' roofs on a 50 year 60-year-old building.

Don Brown2:23:04

It's unbelievable.

Don Brown2:23:06

I phoned the rev the residential tenancy people today, and I could not believe what they were telling me.

Don Brown2:23:12

I cannot believe it.

Don Brown2:23:13

It's ridiculous.

Don Brown2:23:14

They try to re restrict the raises of rents by 3.5%, and then they allow the the landlord to make all make the tenants pay for all their improvements of that and their investment.

Don Brown2:23:26

They get a tax deduction.

Don Brown2:23:29

This is that's ridiculous I I mean that's strongly left letter I mean this is to me it's almost a well there's more than this as a as an election issue.

John Rogers2:23:40

Counselor um counselor Brown this was part one so the the motion was to um assist the tenants because they do need to have that legal representation but that was not the going to be the only motion to be made you know and further that you know Councilor Brown we would be writing that letter um to the province and and whomever.

John Rogers2:24:02

But um I just wanted to get the the first part taken care of so that these individuals have that legal representation that's essential uh for them to be able to make their case.

John Rogers2:24:11

And obviously we would want to express our concerns as well.

Sid Tobias2:24:14

Question for Councilor Rogers, and I I and I hear you're counseling Mattson, we should discuss that.

Sid Tobias2:24:18

So at the CRD, and I know it's not in our policy, but what we do for same-day consideration for notice of motion, we have to vote on that topic when it comes to it.

Sid Tobias2:24:28

And somebody brings it up that it's given the same day consideration.

Sid Tobias2:24:32

So if we all agree that we're gonna um we're gonna even entertain that notice of motion because it was a late ad, then uh with majority it passes, then we could subsequently pass um the notice of motion.

Sid Tobias2:24:46

If you're okay with that policy by the fly, I'm certainly okay with uh with uh it being written into our policy, but it's called same day consideration, and what you need is the notice of motion uh or or the motion uh as well as uh a majority uh vote in favor of that motion to be can given same day consideration.

Sid Tobias2:25:08

In our current schedule, we're not due to have another council meeting until when?

Don Brown2:25:15

July.

Don Brown2:25:16

There's one one in July.

Don Brown2:25:17

One in July.

Sid Tobias2:25:18

July, right?

Sid Tobias2:25:19

So so this is the last meeting of June.

Sid Tobias2:25:22

So that's how much it would delay.

Sid Tobias2:25:23

So I would be happy for um to consider same day consideration for counselor rogers' motion or any motion that comes in in the future if we all vote for that.

Sid Tobias2:25:35

Um so my question to Councilor Rogers, though, do we need a motion to have TAPS contact or have uh the Christie Point residents contact TAPS?

John Rogers2:25:49

I I think um we we need the motion uh um that council write in support to TAPS because TAPS is is extremely busy with many uh requests for legal representation on a wide variety of uh aspects.

John Rogers2:26:02

This one is is I think particularly relevant uh because it's almost like a class action.

John Rogers2:26:07

It's so many residents in in one location that uh require the assistance.

John Rogers2:26:12

And um, you know, we're just writing a couple letters.

John Rogers2:26:15

You know, we're not asking staff to do anything else.

John Rogers2:26:18

We're just writing the letters.

John Rogers2:26:20

That's it.

John Rogers2:26:20

So I don't think that's um uh there's there's any imposition on staff to do workload or investigating or anything like that.

John Rogers2:26:27

I don't want to get let's not complicate things like that.

Sid Tobias2:26:30

Okay, let's uh let's move it for same-day consideration then.

Sid Tobias2:26:33

So can I have a show of hands, not on Councilor Rogers' motion, uh uh the the actual outcome that but that we want to entertain it and action it at this meeting.

Sid Tobias2:26:43

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:26:46

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:26:48

Seeing none opposed.

Sid Tobias2:26:50

So the motion is that the mayor draft a letter to TAPS in support of legal representation for um christie Point residents.

Speaker_142:27:02

Am I does that sound right?

Sid Tobias2:27:10

And and uh provide advocacy.

Sid Tobias2:27:13

Do we want to just go to the province or do we want to also do uh ubcm because this is now legislation right the whole issue here is the 2019 legislation okay councilor lemon i think we need to um address the legislation and um send a letter to every every council in the in british columbia as well as avi cc and ubcm the whole shoot and match then.

Speaker_Unknown2:27:47

Okay.

Sid Tobias2:27:47

Okay.

Alison MacKenzie2:27:48

Uh Councillor McKinsey I would prefer us to uh just write to the uh provincial government because if we write a letter um regarding this uh property or this group of folks, then I f I feel like we would be responsible for doing that anytime this comes up again.

Alison MacKenzie2:28:11

Um and therefore we would be potentially writing to uh is it TAPS, the acronym, taps uh each time.

Alison MacKenzie2:28:18

Like how do we we're kind of setting a precedent if if we do it.

Alison MacKenzie2:28:23

So that's why I prefer just to write because it's more general about the legislation.

Speaker_142:28:30

Thank you, Councilman McKenzie.

Sid Tobias2:28:35

So so the full meal deal just to define would be um uh M MLA's the pr provincial government, council, UBCM, and TAPS.

Sid Tobias2:28:54

Councils, right?

Speaker_142:28:55

Yeah.

Sid Tobias2:28:56

So that's the full meal deal.

Speaker_172:28:58

Council Rogers.

John Rogers2:29:00

Um I don't know.

John Rogers2:29:03

We we may be um uh I I think we need to focus in on the work um that's that the essential work and that's um ensuring that uh the Christie Point residents get the legal representation and move as quickly as possible to um help um make their case um on this very specific point.

John Rogers2:29:22

Um the rest of the provinces and so forth aren't gonna care and they won't see the relevance um writing a letter to the province is is just as important as the first part so let's make it two adding it the third point to every councilor and and uh ubcm and so forth maybe that comes when we do a um would like to do a resolution but um to ubcm but you know let's I'm just worried that we're going to uh hit with such broad um impact that the grenade won't impact won't uh no it will be like a grenade as opposed to very specific um actions uh uh to the province and to that.

Sid Tobias2:30:07

Yeah, I was just gonna suggest two motions.

Sid Tobias2:30:10

Yeah.

Sid Tobias2:30:10

Uh Councilor Lemon, you had a uh your hand up for one.

Gery Lemon2:30:13

Um this lady standing.

Sid Tobias2:30:17

This isn't normally a time where you actually speak.

Speaker_142:30:24

Yes, please.

Speaker_172:30:41

Council Lemon.

Gery Lemon2:30:42

Yeah, I I think in the letter and whoever whoever makes that that motion, I'm I it it needs to be strong, but it needs to ad what we're talking about um legislation that is treating tenants as though they live in a strata.

Gery Lemon2:30:57

And that's just wrong.

Gery Lemon2:30:59

Um that it it changed so that is worth being spread far and wide, I think, because it changes the situation potentially for tenants everywhere.

Speaker_Unknown2:31:11

That's my point.

Sid Tobias2:31:12

Okay, so let's split it in two.

Sid Tobias2:31:15

Split it in two.

Sid Tobias2:31:15

So what's your proposal?

Sid Tobias2:31:16

Well, let's get a uh uh mover and a seconder on your first proposal.

Speaker_172:31:24

Motion.

Sid Tobias2:31:24

Okay, that's the uh to advocate for taps providing legal counsel for the residents of Christy Plant.

Sid Tobias2:31:32

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias2:31:34

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:31:36

Councillor Lemon and Councillor McKenzie are opposed.

Sid Tobias2:31:40

Um the second part is Councilor Brown.

Don Brown2:31:44

I'd like to make a motion that we write a strongly worded letter to the Minister of Housing, the Honorable Ravi Callan, requesting review of legislation allowing landlords to exceed the maximum 12-month rental increase for repairs and maintenance of their units due to the lack of affordable rental accommodation in Greater Victoria, Greater Vancouver, and Fort Nelson is probably not an issue.

Don Brown2:32:19

And John's right.

Don Brown2:32:20

I mean, let's focus on those areas and get them to look at it.

Don Brown2:32:24

To me, uh it just blew me away.

Don Brown2:32:26

It's blew me away today to even hear it and see it on the website.

Don Brown2:32:29

When they're trying to restrict 3.5% increases and then they're adding another three well, even more percentage than that.

Don Brown2:32:30

Wow.

Don Brown2:32:39

It's just just unbelievable.

Sid Tobias2:32:41

Do is do we have a secondary for counselor seconded by Councillor Rogers?

Sid Tobias2:32:46

Um any discussion.

Alison MacKenzie2:32:50

Can you repeat it one more time, Councilor Brown, please?

Don Brown2:32:53

We write a strongly worded letter to the Ministr Honorable Ravi Cal, Minister of Housing, requesting a review of legislation that allows landlords to exercise max exceed the maximum twelve month rental increase for repairs and maintenance of their own uh buildings due to the lack of affordable accommodation, rental accommodation in Greater Victoria, Greater Vancouver, and the Fraser Valley.

Ron Mattson2:33:24

Council Matthew.

Ron Mattson2:33:25

Yeah, so I'm not sure how that deals with the issue we're talking about.

Ron Mattson2:33:29

I mean, if you're the complaint is you allow the group greater than 3% because they're allowed to add on capital costs, but you you you missed that part.

Ron Mattson2:33:40

Reviewed the legislation that allows the landlord to exceed the three point five percent of the but you know the problem to say we don't allow them to exceed the three point five percent because they're excluded.

Sid Tobias2:33:54

Colleagues, I think we're really split in hairs.

Sid Tobias2:33:56

I think if you if you say if you put a motion to advocate on behalf of the uh residents of Christie Point and their situation, I can smooth out the details.

Sid Tobias2:34:07

I don't want to write a letter at 10 o'clock tonight uh here as a group because even 10 o'clock in the morning we probably wouldn't do such a good job.

Don Brown2:34:15

Because the gentleman said, and he's right, they they're gonna increase the three point five percent in perpetuity and probably every single year after, and pay 150 dollars a month.

Don Brown2:34:25

And that's just for this repair.

Don Brown2:34:27

The building's 60 years old.

Ron Mattson2:34:28

It's gonna be I'm not disagreeing with you.

Ron Mattson2:34:30

I'm just uh your motion didn't do it for me.

Don Brown2:34:32

Okay.

Don Brown2:34:33

Well, well, no, but this the wordsmith, the mayor, can can can word it.

Sid Tobias2:34:39

Yeah, so if you had just a simple motion to say write a letter of advocate uh uh advocacy um to the minister of housing on behalf of the residents of uh Christie Point, and uh that that should be good enough.

Sid Tobias2:34:53

Yeah, um so that that's the mover seconder.

Sid Tobias2:34:57

Any other comments on it?

Sid Tobias2:34:59

All those in favor?

Sid Tobias2:35:01

Any opposed?

Sid Tobias2:35:02

Saying non-opposed.

Ron Mattson2:35:04

I'm not sure.

Ron Mattson2:35:06

I'm not sure if this one's gonna pass, but I think we should also write to UBCM and numbers of others to advise them of this situation because it's certainly going to impact their town.

Sid Tobias2:35:17

This is provincial legislation, so if you get a seconder for that, Councillor Matson.

Alison MacKenzie2:35:26

I'll second it.

Sid Tobias2:35:28

Second it, Councilor Mackenzie.

Sid Tobias2:35:30

So this is our advocacy to UBCM for this because uh uh depending on what happens at the election they might become more popular.

Sid Tobias2:35:38

All those in favor?

Speaker_172:35:40

Any opposed no to counselor Rogers is opposed.

Sid Tobias2:35:45

Okay so that uh is there anything else on the Christie point discussion?

Speaker_172:35:49

Okay.

Sid Tobias2:35:50

Okay so now we're at question period.

Sid Tobias2:35:53

Anyone got a question for council you got two minutes to do it.

Sid Tobias2:35:56

No okay all right cheers Carol, we got anybody on the line for a question.

Sid Tobias2:36:05

Mayor Tobias, we have no callers.

Ron Mattson2:36:08

Thank you.

Ron Mattson2:36:09

Can I make one other request?

Ron Mattson2:36:10

Nobody mentioned the hockey score because I'm not sure and I'm going home to watch the game.

Sid Tobias2:36:19

Uh so I think that brings us to a closed meeting resolution, sir.

Speaker_252:36:24

It does.

Speaker_252:36:25

There's a need to have a meeting closed to the public in person other than the meeting members.

Speaker_252:36:28

Council officers and employees of the town and those identified under section 91, subsection two of the community charter should be excluded on the basis of section 90, subsection 1A, appointment and f enforcement.

Sid Tobias2:36:39

Uh and question for Scott and Sarah.

Sid Tobias2:36:42

Would this last longer than 30 minutes?

Speaker_252:36:46

It should not.

Sid Tobias2:36:47

Yeah, that's what you said about the council meeting.

Sid Tobias2:36:50

Um no, I'm only kidding.

Sid Tobias2:36:51

Sorry, I did not bet on this council meeting duration.

Sid Tobias2:36:54

Uh so uh we also need a motion to extend and let's do that extension until 10:30.

Sid Tobias2:36:59

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias2:37:01

And uh and that'll be motivated.

Sid Tobias2:37:03

Moved and seconded.

Sid Tobias2:37:06

Uh seeing none opposed, motion carries, no rising reports.

Sid Tobias2:37:10

So can I get a move to terminate this meeting?

Sid Tobias2:37:12

We'll go right into the closed meeting.

Sid Tobias2:37:14

Moved by councillor Brown, seconded by councillor Rogers.

Sid Tobias2:37:17

All those in favor.

Sid Tobias2:37:19

Seeing none opposed, we can close her up now.